Seed Media Group

Afarensis

Anthropology, Evolution and Science

Search this blog

Profile

afarcomp3.jpg Afarensis is a 3.5-2.8 million year old hominin from the Kada Hadar member of the Hadar formation in the Middle Awash, Ethiopia. He is approximately 41 inches tall, weighs approximately 60 pounds and has a cranial capacity of a whopping 410 cc (approximately). Afarensis is currently considered to be transitional between apes and humans and displays some traits of both. Since he spends a lot of time on the couch watching monster movies, some observers question whether he is an obligate biped (although no one has observed him climbing a tree). He also has a blog called Transitions:The Evolution of Life His previous blog can be found here.
My blog banners were designed by pough - frequent commenter and Photoshop wizard, Bill Clark, and Chris Whitehouse. Thanks, you all do excellent Photoshop work!

My Amazon Wishlist

Other Information

Recent Posts

Categories

Recent Comments

Archives

Aphorisms


"Loyalty to petrified opinion never broke a chain or freed a human soul..."
Mark Twain


"Ideology is a poor substitute for rational thought..."
Afarensis


"It isn't faith that makes good science...it's curiosity"
Prof. Jacob Barnhardt, The Day the Earth Stood Still


"This man wishes to be accorded the same privilege as a sponge. He wishes to think!"
Clarence Darrow, Inherit the Wind


"...I become fearful when I see people substituting fear for reason..."
Klaatu, The Day the Earth Stood Still


"I want you to grab life by its little bunny ears and get in its face..."
The Simpsons


"This is between me and the vegetable..."
Seymour Krelborn, The Little Shop of Horrors


"There are bad laws and cruel laws and the people who enforce them are both bad and cruel..."
Thea, Isle of the Dead


"With the first link, the chain is forged. The first speech censored, the first thought forbidden, the first freedom denied, chains us all irrevocably." Jean- Luc Picard, Star Trek: The Next Generation

"But the limit of tolerance for these human foibles is obtained when the proponent of a questionable scientific doctrine endeavors to maintain it against all possible odds by misrepresentation, misinformation and suppression of contradictory data, and by insinuating unfairness in opponents of his views."
Franz Weidenreich, Morphology of Solo Man


"Man stands alone in the universe, a unique product of a long, unconcious, impersonal material process with unique understanding and potentialities. These he owes to no one but himself, and it is to himself that he is responsible. He is not the creature of uncontrollable and undeterminable forces, but his own master. He can and must decide and manage his own destiny."
George Gaylord Simpson, Life of the Past


Yeah he's the Dick to the Dawk to the phd, he's smarter than you he's got a science degree! Yeah he's the Dick to the Dawk to the phd, he's smarter than you he's got a science degree!
Unknown

Whoever fights monsters should see to it that in the process he does not become a monster. And when you look into the abyss, the abyss also looks into you.
Frederich Nietzsche


But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security.
The Declaration of Independence



View My Stats

Subscribe via Email

Stay abreast of your favorite bloggers' latest and greatest via e-mail, via a daily digest.

Sign me up!

« Good News For Iraq and Other Interesting Anthropology News | Main | Pensacola Christian College in the News Again »

The Logical End Result of Repatriation Laws?

Category: BioarchaeologyRepatriation
Posted on: June 25, 2008 8:40 PM, by afarensis, FCD

Nature has an interesting news item called Online anthropology draws protest from aboriginal group:

As Europe's museums begin archiving their collections in digital format, skeletons are emerging -- and not just of the physical variety. One South African tribe already says it will oppose the inclusion of images of its people's remains in any multimedia format. The University of Vienna has started to digitize the collection made in the early twentieth century by Rudolf Pöch, considered one of anthropology's founding fathers. The project, headed by Maria Teschler-Nicola, will improve the collection's accessibility for researchers and store the delicate material in a sustainable way, using electronic records of physiological measurements as well as two and three-dimensional scans. But the full collection, which includes human remains and thousands of ethnographic artefacts, was gathered using unethical methods, such as grave-robbing.

Although, in general, I am sympathetic to the idea of repatriation there are limits. One of those is when it completely cuts of the notion of the scientific study of human kind. I have always thought that the digitization of artifacts and skeletons was an excellent compromise between the demands of human dignity and the needs of the scientific community. This, in my opinion crosses that line.

Comments

I do have to agree-there needs to be some middle ground between returning artifacts and remains that were obtained under less than honest measures and the ability of science to study.

Posted by: donna | June 25, 2008 9:43 PM

This is a really tough area to get into - remains essentially stolen from many parts of the world which deserve respectful treatment, especially when the tribes or societies they came from ask for them back.

I think the response from all sides needs to be a frank assessment of the gains from continued research versus the cultural implications of repatriation and burial. Is there more we can learn by holding on to these remains in their current locations, or is it time to gratefully acknowledge that the remains need to go back to their homes? I think, in cases of remains that have been in institutions for decades, we may have reached the end of their use as scientific data points, and they should be returned with some gratitude (and perhaps symbolic compensation). Perhaps we should also seek to develop anthropologic infrastructure in many of these countries of origin, so the recipients of the remains can be equal partners in their study.

Posted by: Philip H. | June 26, 2008 10:03 AM

Well, yes, but that is not the issue here. The issue is that some museums want to digitize the artifacts, skeletons, and other cultural items before they are repatriated. Basically, the remains would be repatriated bu, because they had been digitized they would still, for all practical purposes, be available for future study via the digitized images. As pointed out above, some groups are objecting to that digitization.

Posted by: afarensis, FCD | June 26, 2008 10:27 AM

It reminds me very much of one of the old Arabian stories of the wise judge, in which the "theft" of the smell of cooking shawarma is "compensated" by the sound of a shaken bag of money.

Posted by: speedwell | June 26, 2008 12:08 PM

Thanks - had to giggle at that one

Posted by: John Monfries | June 26, 2008 9:26 PM

Post a Comment

(Email is required for authentication purposes only. Comments are moderated for spam, your comment may not appear immediately. Thanks for waiting.)





Having problems commenting? (UPDATED)

Blogs in the Network

Advertisement

Top Five: Most German

Search All Blogs