An interesting post from Repository for Bottled Monsters gathers together a few links on art/exhibit censorship, like this opinion, "Why Some Art Should Be Censored," from the Shreveport Times: "Another sort of case concerns the use of human corpses in art. There is a venerable tradition of showing the dead for various reasons, as in Rembrandt's famous The Anatomy Lesson of Dr. Tulp or Goya's depictions of the horrors of war -- not to mention numerous crucifixions. . . "
bioephemera
a blog about the intersection of science, art, and culture by Jessica Palmer, PhD
Profile
Jessica Palmer has a PhD in Molecular Biology and has been blogging about the intersection of art and biology since 2006.
read the first BioE post.
The contents of this blog are the personal opinions of the author, independent of any organizations with which she is affiliated, and should not be construed as professional advice.
Search
Recent Posts
- Goodbye to Scienceblogs
- SpaceChem!
- Mechanical butterfly, circa 1911
- Pseudonymity: Five Reasons the New Scienceblogs/NG Policy is Misguided
- Seeing the invisible? There's an app for that
- Kate MacDowell: bloodless bodies
- Helping Vermont
- Glass acorns
- Greg Dunn's golden neurons
- Window Shopping
bioephemeral sampler
- Anamorphic Skulls
- Art vs. Science Part 2: You want raw data? You can't handle raw data
- Taking Darwin's Name in Vain
- Wombs, Waxes, and Wonder Cabinets
- The Fossils of SoHo
- Gas Works Park
- God is More than a Flying Brain
Categories
- Artists & Art
- Biology
- Blogosphere
- Book Reviews
- Books & Essays
- Cephalopodmania
- Citizen Science
- Conspicuous consumption
- DC
- Dataviz
- Department of the Drama
- Design
- Destinations
- Education
- Ephemera
- Events
- Film, Video & Music
- Frivolity
- Gender Issues
- Health
- History of Science
- Journalism
- Littademia
- Love
- Maps
- Medical Illustration and History
- Museum Lust
- My Artwork
- Neuroscience
- Nonacademic Careers
- Photography
- Poetry
- Random Acts of Altruism
- Retrotechnology and steampunk
- Science
- Science in Advertising
- Science in Culture & Policy
- Wearables
- Web 2.0, New Media, and Gadgets
- Wonder Cabinets
- Words
- Yikes!
Archives
- September 2011
- August 2011
- July 2011
- June 2011
- May 2011
- April 2011
- March 2011
- February 2011
- January 2011
- December 2010
- November 2010
- October 2010
- June 2010
- May 2010
- April 2010
- March 2010
- February 2010
- January 2010
- December 2009
- November 2009
- October 2009
- September 2009
- August 2009
- July 2009
- June 2009
- May 2009
- April 2009
- March 2009
- February 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008
- October 2008
- September 2008
- August 2008
- July 2008
- June 2008
- May 2008
- April 2008
- March 2008
- February 2008
Blogroll
- Wonderkammer
- Bibliodyssey
- Cabinet of Wonders
- Curious Expeditions
- Mapping the Marvellous
- Morbid Anatomy
- Street Anatomy
- Science
- Adventures in Ethics and Science
- Armed With Science
- Beagle Project
- Biocurious
- Biology in Science Fiction
- Cocktail Party Physics
- Code For Life
- Comrade Physioprof
- Cosmic Variance
- Culturing Science
- Deep Sea News
- Dendroica, a DC Birding Blog
- DrugMonkey
- Evilutionary Biologist
- Female Science Professor
- The Intersection
- Genetic Future
- Tom Levinson's Inverse Square Blog
- It's a Micro World
- Laelaps
- Medical Humanities Blog
- Mind Hacks
- Neurocritic
- Neuroskeptic
- Neurophilosophy
- Neurotopia
- Not Exactly Rocket Science
- Omics! Omics!
- Pharyngula
- Scicurious
- Sciencegeekgirl
- Scientific Activist
- SCQ
- Terra Sigillata
- The Last Word on Nothing
- Thus Spake Zuska
- Twisted Physics
- Weird Bug Lady
- White Coat Underground
- Zooillogix
- Art, Sciart, Design, Ephemera
- 50 Watts
- Agence Eureka
- BLDGBLOG
- Brad Blogspeed
- Daily Dose of Imagery
- Dream Tree
- Edward Winkleman
- E-L-I-S-E
- Erratic Phenomena
- Fernando Vicente
- feuilleton
- Found in Mom's Basement
- Hungry Hyaena
- Jark and Mason
- NextNature
- homonculus
- Party Like An Art Star
- Phantasmaphile
- Universe
- Wunderkammer: Journal of Environmental Art
- Scientific/Medical Art & Natural History
- A Repository for Bottled Monsters
- Biomedicine on Display
- coelecanth diaries
- Drawing the MotMot
- Hairy Museum
- Rigor Vitae
- SaCrIt
- Somatosphere
- The Flying Trilobite
- Zymoglyphic Curators Blog
- Web 2.0, Media and Dataviz
- Berkman Center
- Columbia Journalism Review
- Flowing Data
- Future of the Internet
- Infosthetics
- Middle Savagery
- Nieman Journalism Lab
- Visual Complexity
- Books, Essays, Language
- 3 Quarks Daily
- Blog of a Bookslut
- "Blog" of "Unnecessary" Quotation Marks
- Bookn3rd
- Cabinet Magazine
- Cataloguer's Desk
- Collision Detection
- The Edge
- In The Middle
- Language Hat
- Language Log
- Making Light
- Nanopublic
- Name Inspector
- Poetry Daily
- Ptak Science Books
- Rag and Bone Blog
- Science Musings
- The Worlds Fair
- Law
- The Becker-Posner Blog
- Genomics Law Blog
- JOLT digest
- Lawgeek
- Neuroethics and Law Blog
- Patent Baristas
- SCOTUSblog
- The Situationist
- Steampunk & Alt Culture
- Boing Boing
- Brass Goggles
- Coilhouse
- Hollister Hovey
- Laughing Squid
- Monster Brains
- Points of View
- Archaeoporn
- Blunt Instrument
- Crooked Timber
- Dandelion Diva
- Diary of a Mad Natural Historian
- Fashion for Nerds
- The Greatest & Best Website
- Geoffrey Chaucer Hath a Blog
- Letters From the Inquisition
- Multilocus
- Say What?!
- She Walks Softly
- Via Negativa
- Witless Wanderer
- Miscellaneous
- DCist
- Dream Anatomy
- Haute Macabre
- Photoshop Disasters
- Sociological Images
- Wordie
- My Life in Stick Figures
- xkcd
« Iconic? "Science" says your brain doesn't buy it. . . at least according to Campbell's | Main | A not-so-fun cartoon: "plastics kill" »
Are some museum exhibits immoral?
Category: Blogosphere • Medical Illustration and History • Museum Lust
Posted on: March 6, 2010 5:11 PM, by Jessica Palmer
TrackBacks
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://scienceblogs.com/mt/pings/132882
Comments
This is a very interesting issue, implicated by exhibits like "Bodies", and by collections of medical/anatomical specimens. My own opinion is that so long as some degree of respect is paid to the former humanity of the specimens, then it is ok. So with Bodies, I consider the extreme attention to detail of the dissections and preparation to constitute that respect.
Posted by: Comrade PhysioProf | March 6, 2010 6:17 PM
Although some of those knockoff plastination tours utilize bodies of inmates sentenced to death in Chinese prisons. In those cases, I would say censure is apropos.
Posted by: jimspice | March 6, 2010 6:39 PM
I do think that we should not exhibit things that glorify torture. Ban all those crucifixes, I say, especially from art museums where innocent children might inadvertently see them.
Posted by: John S. Wilkins | March 6, 2010 7:00 PM
There are countless examples of natural history museum exhibits having surpassed their shelf life, particularly when they relate to outdated interpretations of human cultures, but also as they relate to now-obsolete (and laughable) ideas of phylogenetic relationships. (linear trajectory of fish--amphibian--african human--white roman male bust, for example)
Posted by: pupating | March 6, 2010 9:17 PM
The Shreveport Times article seems to be conflating two different issues: should art be "censored", and should "art" be an excuse to justify otherwise illegal actions? Prosecuting someone for animal cruelty or illegally interfering with corpses does not constitute "censorship", regardless of whether they claim to be an artist or not.
Posted by: Andrew G. | March 7, 2010 4:32 AM
"So with Bodies, I consider the extreme attention to detail of the dissections and preparation to constitute that respect."
How does that constitute respect for their humanity? I can think of a few (definitely immoral) exceptions to that rule.
I did not attend any of the exhibits as I did not feel confidant that all the "participants" on display had agreed to be there. Perhaps this view is misguided, but I had also heard stories about the Chinese prisoners.
Posted by: Isabel | March 9, 2010 3:30 PM
Thanks for posting this. The articles in the links really helped me with thinking about these issues, gave me a nice framework to place some of my thoughts against.
I did not attend any of the Bodies exhibits that came through Philly. It doesn't fit with my moral sense of what is right to do with a dead body. I don't personally feel comfortable making an afternoon's entertainment out of dead bodies, however respectfully they were treated, however ethically they were obtained (and I was not at all sure I could be sure of either of those things). I could listen to an argument for a different viewpoint, but that's just where I am with it now.
The cases of public art and art affecting religious sensibilities I find the most interesting and difficult to deal with.
Posted by: Zuska | March 11, 2010 12:24 AM