Casaubon's Book

This post ran a year and half ago at The Oil Drum, but I thought it was worth re-running, as I begin my new Adapting in Place class (still two spots if anyone wants them – email jewishfarmer@gmail.com – and no, it isn’t too late!). How do you even get started thinking about how to prepare for a lower energy and less stable climate future?

Beginnings

The first question to ask is whether we should take in-place Adaptation seriously at all. Shouldn’t we, ideally, try and choose the best possible place to deal with the coming crisis? Some analysts suggest we will have to have vast population migrations out of suburbia, say, to more densely packed and walkable cities, while others propose re-ruralization. My suspicion is that both of these will probably occur to some degree – but that the progression will be intermittent, not very well organized. And plenty of people will stay in place, either in their homes and apartments, or will settle in property known to them, owned or rented by family or close friends.

Why will they stay? Well, for millions of people who own a home, but aren’t in immediate danger of foreclosure, the option of selling, even if they are not “underwater” is problematic – with home sales at historic lows, most of us will be staying put, if we don’t lose or abandon our properties. They can’t afford to change jobs, because they will lose seniority and potentially get the axe. They can’t afford the additional costs of moving, buying a new property or paying first, last and security.

And if they do move? Some of us will migrate, but a lot of us have compelling reasons to live where we do – community, culture, and family. What most of us will probably do in dire circumstances is simply consolidate resources with people we can trust – we’ll take in boarders or move in with family or friends. In tough times, we are likely to need family and community more – thus staying close to elderly parents or grandparents who can help with childcare while parents look for work becomes more urgent.

Some of us may also decide where we are is the right place – it isn’t just a matter of not being able to move, but of believing that we are best in places we know. The time for the radical changes required by picking up and moving and starting over may have been a few years ago. More familiar projects may be wiser and better for many of us.

Another force pushing us to stay put, as I wrote in my book _Depletion and Abundance: Life on the New Home Front_, one of the most powerful strategies for mitigation is likely to be a move into the informal economy. Teodor Shanin, founder of Peasant Economics has observed that the formal economy (the one most but not all Americans operate in) makes use of only ΒΌ of all the world’s workers. Most economic activity takes place in the informal economy, and the informal economy generally expands in response to contraction by the formal economy. In an essay in “New Scientist” Shanin writes,

“The concept emerged in Africa 25 years ago. Researchers began to notice that there was no economic explanation for how the majority of the population survived. They didn’t own land. They didn’t seem to have any assets. According to conventional economics, they should have died of hunger long ago, but they survived. To understand this, researchers looked at how these people actually lived, rather than at economic models . They found that their way of life was completely the opposite of how a human being in industrial society survives. They didn’t have a job, pension, steady place to work or regular flow of income. Families held a range of occupations from farming and selling in the market to doing odd jobs or handicrafts. Their aim was survival rather than maximization of profit. Rather than earn wages, labor was used within family.” (archive.newscientist.com/secure/article/article.jsp?rp=1&id=mg1 (article is behind a paywall))

Similar informal economies have emerged in undergoing collapse or economic crisis in Russia, Argentina, and elsewhere, and there is really no reason to believe that the informal economy – which includes domestic labor, cottage industry, illegal activity, under the table businesses, and family economics will not expand here . These economic activities generally make use of family, local, household resources and needs – the soil your home sits on, the wood on your woodlot, providing services to neighbors, making use of household space to operate a business. Where homes have been a major economic drain, they have the potential, for those not over-leveraged, to become a source of income.

It seems likely then that some people whose homes have been or can be made valuable to them – by improving soil, the starting of cottage industries, strong social, familial and community ties, and local economic initiatives will have strong incentives to stay in place. We may see the common pattern of Global South employment in which some family members are sent where formal jobs are available to work, while most of the family remains together. With more people per household, mortgage and property costs may become manageable, while the benefits of family and community are increased by our lack of fossil fuels.

Triaging Your Situation

This does not mean that everyone can or should stay in place. Those who bought homes with ARMs, or at the peak of the market, those already in financial trouble, or without community and family ties may wish or need to relocate. But I still anticipate that at least in the short term, a large number of people all over the world will respond to the present crisis by remaining in their present homes or in a place they have existing ties.

So it is worth asking – what are the first steps if you’ve decided to remain your home, with all its imperfections and disadvantages (and its perfections and advantages – remember, there is no perfect place)? Your goal is to be able to handle what is thrown at you, crises economic, energetic, ecological or political – or all of the above. And the first step, as always, is triage – setting priorities.

First Steps

We all need to get ready to deal with the kind of short term crisis that affects almost everyone sooner or later. Given the fragility of our systems, more and more of these disruptions are likely. Thus, our first project is a medium range systems problem – something that can be caused by ice storms, blizzards, hurricanes, tornadoes, flooding, geopolitical crisis, blackout… you name it. We need to be ready to get along for a few weeks to a month in a very messed up short term situation. This is useful even if what we face is a very messed up long term situation.

That means moving first to get basic needs met. Thus, we concentrate on first tier solutions. The qualities that these first tier solutions must have are these

1. They keep you alive and healthy.

2. They are simple, accessible and not too expensive – since everyone needs these

You need a reserve of food, and a way to cook it without power, lots of warm clothing and blankets if cold is a potential problem, and sufficient water and ways to keep cool if heat is the issue. You need stored water and a backup source of water. You will want some basic lighting and a way to manage toileting and hygiene issues, clean bodies and clothes. You need away to keep aware of events and communicate with family and community.

Other than the food, medications and water, the emergency measures could be quite cheap, because they don’t have to be comfortable and pleasant – for a few weeks, you can winter camp in your house, for a few weeks you can pee in a bucket, for a few weeks you can do laundry infrequently in another plastic bucket, light your evening with your headlamp and rechargeable batteries, communicate with your neighbors by trekking out to knocked together neighborhood bulletin board. That is, you can be uncomfortable and/or inconvenienced for the short term, in most cases. That doesn’t mean all the short term solutions are unpleasant – in fact, sometimes you’ll be surprised by how minor the inconvenience is, but the most important thing is that you have a way of meeting those needs, not that it be the perfect method.

For those who can’t tolerate much discomfort or inconvenience, because of health problems, age, disability or simple intolerance, then you will need to move up a little in the list to the next steps, the long term solutions to these problems. That is, you may need solar panels, expensive equipment or a generator, which come with attendant costs. But for most of us, the first-tier inconvenient but survivable solutions get us part of the way there, and many of them could be used longer if we had no choice.

But we all know that short term isn’t everything. What happens if we can’t afford electricity or gas anymore? What happens if we’re suddenly in the Long Emergency, not the short one? The preparations you’ve made for a short term crisis will get old really fast – but most of them will still serve you. That is, you will not like lighting your house with only a headlamp and two flashlights, and you will not like going to bed when it gets dark in December in the north, but you can do it if you have no choice. Some of us may already have second tier solutions in place – we might have a wringer washer already and not need the plastic buckets. Still, I recommend that you have the equipment or ability to use these minimal backup solutions, if only so you can teach others in your community.

Going Further

The next level of preparations are partly about survival, but more about creating a life you can live with in the long term. If you have money, these are easy changes to make. If you don’t have money, it will take time, and saving and scavenging to manage these systems – and you may be stuck with the original, inexpensive backups at times. Only you can decide what you can afford, have time to do, and what portion of your resources you can devote to improving your comfort and giving you more time – but my own observation is that these accommodations increase rapidly in value in tough situations.

This is where you begin going step by step through the systems you depend on, figuring out what you can do to allow you to live decently and comfortably. Step by step, you start replacing, adding or converting to sustainable systems that will serve you in the absence of existing infrastructure. My own belief is that while renewable energy systems are an excellent supplemental second tier system, your primary systems should operate a technological level you are like to be able to support even in the worst-case scenarios you think likely.

That is, even someone with a solar system large enough to run their washing machine should have a bucket at a minimum, and might want a small pressure washer. Even someone with a generator for their well pump might want a manual pump on their well or rain cachement. Someone with a chainsaw still needs an axe and bucksaw. The reason for this is that things break, supply lines can be disrupted, replacement parts may not be available. Redundancy is healthy – and can be essential. And if you must choose between the solar panels and manual well pump, my own feeling is that you should prioritize a system you can manage, repair and fully understand, whichever that is.

For those without much money, it is much easier to convert permanently to the alternatives in many cases, than it is to maintain both “normal” and “backup” systems. That is, it is hard, if you are poor, to afford solar lanterns – unless, of course, you use them as a lighting source and save money on your electric bill. Sometimes if things seem to costly, the problem may be that you are imagining them as a backup, not a conversion to a new way of life. You may prefer the old way, but if you are serious enough about your concern for the future, converting early isn’t the end of the world – our family has made this choice a number of times, in fact.

Some of the choices are easy and cheap – turning your lawn into a landscape of edibles can be quite inexpensive, if you can get slips and starts and divisions from people and buy plants and seeds from your cooperative extension. Converting to a composting toilet is inexpensive and can save you a lot of money on your water bill. Switching to eating out of your food storage can save a lot on your food budget. Sometimes you can do things on the cheap if you have time – but if you have neither time nor money, things get difficult, so you need to prioritize.

The Order and Ethics of Things

There are two good ways to prioritize, and honestly it makes sense to do both simultaneously. Prioritize by urgency, and by availability. Generally, you should concentrate on the things that will matter to your happiness and comfort the most – for a family with two kids in diapers, this might be not having to do laundry in a bucket, for someone who is always cold, a good heat source. But don’t also forget (and this is a great chore to delegate to elderly relatives, friends who want to barter or teenagers) to keep an eye on craigslist, freecycle, garage sales and to talk about what you are trying to do with others, so you can take advantage of opportunities. Try and have a list of all the stuff you’d like to do, so that when that old handwasher or treadle sewing machine shows up, you can cross that off your priority list.

While you are finding comfortable ways to keep cool, refrigerate food, keep safe, go to the bathroom and the rest, we can also begin thinking about the long term sustainability and community implications of these projects. That is, if you are going to burn wood, you need to be planting trees and harvesting carefully. You are just as vulnerable to diseases caused by human waste disposal problems as your neighbors – even if you don’t contribute to them, you may get sick when you water supply is contaminated. So after you deal with your own water system, share your knowledge. Renewable and lasting systems are central. If your private solutions are likely to contribute to the long term problems, pick different solutions.

In peasant economics, we find that most wealth accumulated by families is passed down through generations. Thus, as Shanin observes, a bicycle for a family may be expected to last until the family’s father is too old to ride it and the daughter can take over. Land and property are passed down, and mostly stewarded – they are not they not disposed of lightly, because they imply an obligation to future generations who are not expected to have enough wealth to replace what we are careless with now. It would behoove most of us, as we make our adaptation plans, to ensure that our strategies serve not just our present, but our future – if our adaptations destroy future capacities to warm, feed, slake thirst, protect other people, perhaps we need to find new adaptation strategies.

Finally, you should practice. That doesn’t just mean trying the solar battery charger once, or making sure you know how to cook on your woodstove – try living with these systems routinely, and turning off the ones you’ve depended on up until now. Consider a test run, when you turn everything off in the winter for a week, or where you live only on your stored and garden food for a month – these tests will tell you really basic things you need to know, and show you the holes in your system while you still have a chance to plug them.

Comments

  1. #1 T
    October 5, 2010

    “crises economic, energetic, ecological or political”

    Not to show too much levity, but this reminds me of “I Am the Very Model of a Modern Major General” … :)

    On the other hand, maybe we need all the levity we can get.

  2. #2 Dunc
    October 6, 2010

    I’m surprised not to see more mention of social capital in this… Now, I probably can’t afford to move from where I am at the moment (and I’m not walking away from my allotment any time soon), but even if I could, I probably wouldn’t, because it would involve sacrificing a lot of very valuable social capital that it’s taken me many years to acquire. I know guys who can get me malted barley or bulk manure at good prices. I know the local organic growers and sellers. I know a doctor who’s also a hunter, a couple of blacksmiths, a flint-knapper, and a good green witch. I even know a man with an illegal still in his basement…

    To paraphrase the old stoner maxim: social capital will get you through times of no financial capital better than financial capital will get you through times of no social capital.

  3. #3 Brad K.
    October 6, 2010

    @ Dunc,

    In thinking about beyond the event horizon – what might “good prices” mean if today’s currency weren’t a useful means to pay for things?

    @ Sharon,

    When triaging – a couple of appliances come to mind. One is the lowly can opener. The venerable Ekco manual can opener works better – though is less dressed up – than many of the deco things being sold at Wal-Mart and other places. I found Ace Hardware is the only real outlet anymore for Ekco – and they had to special order me three (I had to take three to get them to order me one).

    The other is the vacuum cleaner. Old movies show “carpets” being draped over the balcony, clothesline, or sturdy rail, and whacked with a wire “carpet beater” to knock the dust and mites, etc. out of them. I am thinking wall-to-wall carpet will do in the short term without electricity, but I have seen very few organic, sustainable, alternative power source vacuum cleaners around. The manual carpet sweeper you roll across the carpet will certainly pick up stuff off the top – but if you have a knap 1/4 inch or more, that isn’t going to do a lot of good, long term.

    After a few months traffic with no cleaning, that carpet, and especially the pad, is going to be getting packed with undesirable household stuff.

    Do you recommend pulling carpet when that time comes, or is there an alternative for cleaning?

    Or is this a niche for portable, wood-fired boiler, steam engine driven vacuum and steam cleaning services?

  4. #4 Fred
    October 6, 2010

    I know guys who can get me malted barley or bulk manure at good prices. I know the local organic growers and sellers. I know a doctor who’s also a hunter, a couple of blacksmiths, a flint-knapper, and a good green witch. I even know a man with an illegal still in his basement…

    Spot the useless person.

  5. #5 Dunc
    October 6, 2010

    In thinking about beyond the event horizon – what might “good prices” mean if today’s currency weren’t a useful means to pay for things?

    That question is pretty much impossible to answer in any meaningful sense. But I believe that people who produce useful things will continue to do so, and trade will also continue as it has done since at least the Neolithic. Cultivating good relations with useful people is always a worthwhile strategy. But to boil it right down to brass tacks, “good prices” means a reasonable exchange of labour or use-value. I’ve done agricultural labour for room and board before now, and it’s not the worst trade I’ve ever made. For example, a good “price” for malt is one which enables me to produce beer at a “price” that people are willing and able to pay. Whether that’s cash money, barter, or whatever doesn’t really matter. Since people have been able to manage this since the dawn of civilisation, I don’t expect it to be impossible in the future.

    Fred – just because I didn’t list my own skills and productive capabilities doesn’t mean I don’t have any. They’re just not relevant to the point I was making, which concerned the importance of social capital. But you’re right, it is easy to spot the useless person…

  6. #6 darwinsdog
    October 6, 2010

    But you’re right, it is easy to spot the useless person…

    So which one is it?

  7. #7 Dunc
    October 6, 2010

    Perhaps my jibe was too subtle? OK – it’s the one posting content-free comments on the uselessness of other people.

  8. #8 Sharon McDonnell
    October 6, 2010

    There are some wonderful take home lines here. I particularly enjoyed the one about Africa and the economists. Also, in Northern Vermont the image of Peasant economics is apt.
    Thanks for the post and re-post!

  9. #9 Perry
    October 6, 2010

    When we get to the point that we don’t have electricity to run a vacuum cleaner, dirty carpets will be the least of our problems. I feel especially sorry for those who rely on a steady stream of prescription drugs. And for people who haven’t taken the time to learn how to cook plant-based meals, the learning curve is going to be pretty steep.

    As Winston Churchhill said during World War II – “He who fails to plan is planning to fail”.

  10. #10 Raven
    October 7, 2010

    Ah, dirty carpets are a problem if you have babies crawling around putting stuff in their mouths and possibly getting diarrhea from it, or if you have asthma and are hoarding your inhalers–then dust is really a problem.

    In either situation I’d find some way to pull the carpets; if there were no vulnerable people in the household, you might do better by laying down mats, tarps, etc that can be taken outside and beaten and so maintaining the cleanliness of the carpet underneath as long as you can.

    For the vulnerable better would probably be to get rid of them *now* and find some way to finish the subfloor underneath.

  11. #11 darwinsdog
    October 7, 2010

    You’re going to need those carpets, dirty as they may become, for insulation, Raven. I don’t think it’s a good idea to rip them up. I like your suggestion of covering them with rugs & mats that can be taken out & shook or beaten. Throw rugs can be had pretty cheaply from thrift stores, or one can weave his or her own from rags.

    “..those who rely on a steady stream of prescription drugs..” or “..are hoarding your inhalers” are simply fuckered.

  12. #12 ildi
    October 7, 2010

    Key items you forgot to list for the Long Emergency: weapons and plenty of ammo and the skills to use them.

  13. #13 Perry
    October 8, 2010

    ildi, I agree.

    I really wanted to put in wall to wall carpet. These hardwood floors are really cold. But noooo . . .
    first things first, and I went the guns/ammo/training route first. Not much point in having a well stocked pantry if you can’t protect it.

  14. #14 Beverly
    October 11, 2010

    Here in Utah many people have long been trained to have a years supply laid by, the L.D.S. Church is big on that and most of our neighborhood has done their part. While not of their religious persuasion the idea has always seemed very sensible to me as I was raised by grandparents who weathered two world wars and the last Great Recession with the attending influenza, rationing and scarcity. They worked hard, but never really lacked. Our LDS neighbors have been gracious enough to allow us to buy storage food from their canneries over the years, both then and now. Buying from a co-op or bulk cannery is a great way to go.

    We too can get by and gracefully. As a sociologist I have been doing some very detailed reading about the Anabaptist groups who count among their numbers the Amish, Mennonites and Bretheran. It’s very revealing how the conservatives in these groups will probably adapt very well to the Long Emergency. You don’t have to bring religion into the equation to gain some very useful insights,(but religion is really a powerful “glue”.) The reading is very worthwhile and Amazon carries a good number of books. I have been shopping Lehman’s Non Electric who offer some insights and customer reviews as to what will be useful, then I proceed to try to find as much as possible locally. A pressure washer is on “the list” but may have to be purchased new.

    I might add there are already a good number of people who are looking for treadle sewing machines. Even the old 1940′s and 50′s models can be adapted but they too are a bit scarce. The really cute old machines with the scroll work would look nice enough to make sewing fun. Niche markets here!

    This month I’m buying seeds. There are not as many mark downs as there used to be as people are becoming aware that seeds often have a good keeping life. Do stick to non hybrid seeds for the most part. I’ve also saved seeds and starts from my garden and planted garlic. Fruit trees are on sale in our area and from the way the price of them went up this spring I’ve been buying while they’re 30% off. Besides it takes a standard sized fruit tree as much as 5 to 6 years to bear. I go with semi dwarf trees except in peaches then I go standard. Next year I may not be able to afford them. Social Security and annuities are fixed and/or “frozen”. I find myself buying fruit trees again as we have consolidated two households because of the times we’re facing. The reviled “McMansion” can be pretty handy!

    In your years supply don’t forget your pets! If you can give, many food pantries will be happy to take donations of pet food as well as people food.

  15. #15 darwinsdog
    October 11, 2010

    ..the Amish, Mennonites and Bretheran. It’s very revealing how the conservatives in these groups will probably adapt very well to the Long Emergency.

    Do you really think so? Do Amish blacksmiths still cook their own charcoal for their forges? Do they operate sawmills for producing milled lumber for their houses & barns? Do they still rely on hex healers for medical & veterinary care? As pacifists, how will they defend their larders from the starving “English”? Religion may be a powerful “glue” but it may turn out to be the glue that binds with a fatal solidarity for these people.

  16. #16 Ewan R
    October 11, 2010

    I know a doctor who’s also a hunter, a couple of blacksmiths, a flint-knapper, and a good green witch.

    That doctor must be frickin built if she’s a couple of blacksmiths – most people would stop at being just one!

The site is currently under maintenance and will be back shortly. New comments have been disabled during this time, please check back soon.