Now on ScienceBlogs: Oldest Human-Made Object in Space

ScienceBlogs Book Club: Inside the Outbreaks

Search

Profile

This is the Official Blogger SAT Challenge web site. Here, you'll find the essays posted by the entrants in the challenge, with tools to allow you to rate them and see the "expert" scores.

Our Blogs

The Origin of the Challenge

Analysis of the Results

Recent Comments

Acknowledgements

The Challenge is the work of Dave Munger and Chad Orzel, and grew out of discussions on ScienceBlogs.

Special thanks to Kate Nepveu and Jeremy Campbell for help setting up the site, and to our expert graders: David Bruggeman, Suzi, Elisa Davis, Natalie Hudson, Battlepanda and Lisa.

« 88287723.00 | Main | 287897726.00 »

86505267.00

Category: graded
Posted on: September 26, 2006 2:01 AM, by ScienceBlogs Admin

Ultimate success is often called genius. People recognize genius, but seldom are able to define it. One supposes that people of genius have natural talent, or at least natural talent for some task.

Recent work, however, suggests that at least many who excel got there primarily through hard work. One example is Mozart. He was a child prodigy, yes. However, his father was known to be a task master. And, Mozart's early symphonies would hardly be considered great works, and would have no acclaim at all if not part of his larger works developed later in life. Tiger Woods is thought of as a 'natural'. Yet Tiger spends long hours watching videos of his own play, then hones his techniques. Chess players clearly get better at the game through long hours of work.

Hours are not enough. If one plays 'Mary Had A Little Lamb' on the violin for hours and hours, one will eventually stagnate, with little improvement. One must face multiple challenges to achieve greatness.

For, for true greatness, Booker T. Washington has hit on a good measure. But the fact remains that most people are measured by a different scale. It isn't true greatness that is measured, but rather a sort of popularity contest. There are few who take the time to take the true measure of anyone.

And, there are few who listen to those who do. One might say that the current President is a great man. After all, nearly half of the people who voted elected him President. But the advertising that went on that claimed his greatness did not come from unbiased researchers. So the claim to greatness is quite hollow.

Unfortunately, history is also subject to this kind of popularity issue. Many claim that Aristotle was a great man. It may have been true. From the modern perspective, however, he helped hold back the advance of science for at least 1,500 years - hardly the sort of thing anyone would like to be known for as the result of their life's work.

So, no, Booker T. Washington has largely missed the mark.



Show the score given by the expert grader

Rate another random entry

Share on Facebook
Share on StumbleUpon
Share on Facebook

ScienceBlogs

Search ScienceBlogs:

Go to:

Advertisement
Follow ScienceBlogs on Twitter

© 2006-2011 ScienceBlogs LLC. ScienceBlogs is a registered trademark of ScienceBlogs LLC. All rights reserved.