Seed Media Group

Search this blog

Profile

away%20from%20computer.jpg

I am the Online Community Manager at PLoS ONE. My scientific specialty is chronobiology (circadian rhythms and photoperiodism), with additional interests in comparative physiology, animal behavior and evolution. I am not an MD so I cannot diagnose and treat your sleep problems. This is a personal blog and opinions within in no way reflect the policies of PLoS ONE. You can contact me at: Coturnix@gmail.com


Join us at ScienceOnline'09

Buy the 2007 Science Blogging Anthology:

The Open Laboratory

Buy the 2006 Science Blogging Anthology:

The Open Laboratory

Recent Posts

Recent Comments

Archives

Blogroll

Subscribe via Email

Stay abreast of your favorite bloggers' latest and greatest via e-mail, via a daily digest.

Sign me up!

My Old Stuff

Make Me Happy

Add this blog to my Technorati Favorites!

Add Scienceblogs to your Technorati Favorites!

Make Me Solvent

Amazon Honor System Click Here to Pay Learn More

A Blog Around The Clock swag store

I Support

Project Exploration

Project Exploration

Bloggie Stuff

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported License.

« Rise and Fall of HIgher Education | Main | What is 'citizen journalism'? »

Left vs. Right online

Category: BloggingMediaPolitics
Posted on: July 26, 2008 5:26 PM, by Coturnix

There has been a lot of chatter on the interwebs (for years, but again now) about the differences between the ways the political Left and Right use the Internet and blogs:

GOP losing the new-media war:

.......The right is engaged in the business of opining while the left features sites that offer a more reportorial model.

At first glance, these divergent approaches might not seem consequential. But as the 2008 campaign progresses, it's becoming increasingly clear that the absence of any websites on the right devoted to reporting -- as opposed to just commenting on the news -- is proving politically costly to Republicans.

While conservatives are devoting much of their Internet energy to analysis, their counterparts on the left are taking advantage of the rise of new media to create new institutions devoted to unearthing stories, putting new information into circulation and generally crowding the space traditionally taken by traditional media. And it almost always comes at the expense of GOP politicians.

While online Republicans chase the allure of punditry and commentary, Democrats and progressives are pursuing old-fashioned shoe-leather reporting, in a fashion reminiscent of 2004........

A different view on the left versus right online debate:

In the regular debate about about how the right can catch up online, several points are often missed. The first is that the left has developed a movement based on the interconnectedness of people inside the movement. People get recruited, energized, and leveraged. This may or may not be as much a function of larger demographic and political trends, as it has something to do with the netroots specifically.

At the same time, the right has often been better at campaign mechanics, especially in recent years. Our assumption seems to be that if we get enough people to go and vote in this country -- which we still believe is just right of center -- then we can win.

Rebranding via Blogging:

The web is conducive to insurgency movements. That's been the Democrats for the last eight years. They were out of power and needed different tools. Progressives perceived that the political culture had shifted, but the Democratic Party did not shift with it, so they began telling a story about a different vision of the Democratic Party and the political system. They made fundamental criticisms of both parties and the media, and rallied a lot of people to them. They erected a very effective mechanism for bringing the party in their direction, they created a gravitational pull so the political leaders and the money people had to come to them. That has fundamentally reshaped the Democratic Party. The Republican Party, on the other hand, was perceived by most in its base as being a more effective machine.

Via Ed Cone:

What the left does better online: report, rather than just opine.

Why they had to do it: the mainstream media was "browbeaten" into ineffectiveness.

Read the entire articles for more.

Well, an anti-democratic party cannot allow its lowly prole members to do anything but follow orders. It is a hierarchical structure where all the information (hmm, talking points and lies) flow from the top down. And how much fun is it to read second-hand lies on some blog instead of first-hand lies straight from Cheney? No amount of re-branding will ever change the basic core worldview of the GOP-ers, thus they can never have anything like a bottom-up online movement, independent from the party elders, working at reshaping the party from within.

Comments

This reminds me of the hypothesis that while some people collect facts before making a decision, others make an emotional decision then fit their facts to justify their hypothesis. Guess who is who. Unfortunately, the left doesn't know how to talk to the right. Lefties can gather all the reporting they want to, the right is better at dismissing them to fit their emotional state of mind.

Posted by: Phil | July 27, 2008 4:38 AM

From Soren Dayton's article:


If this ends up being a close election, or a very close election, it is going to come down to electoral technology. Maybe it will be ACORN crashing the rolls and delivering illegal voters.

This is revealing. Soren Dayton believes low and moderate income voters are illegal voters.

Posted by: llewelly | July 27, 2008 12:44 PM

Phil: yes. The twenty-eighters will vote GOP no matter what, but they get their news in church anyway. Nonetheless, the way left blogosphere has pushed news onto corporate media in a way that will gradually change the emotional states of many in the middle.

llewelly - yes, the righters are trying to find all sorts of slights-of-hands to excuse their obnoxious worldview and reinforce rightwing frames.

Posted by: Coturnix | July 27, 2008 1:38 PM

Post a Comment

(Email is required for authentication purposes only. Comments are moderated for spam, your comment may not appear immediately. Thanks for waiting.)





Having problems commenting? (UPDATED)

Blogs in the Network

Advertisement

Top Five: Readers' Picks

Search All Blogs