A Blog Around The Clock

New journal: Ideas in Ecology and Evolution

Ideas in Ecology and Evolution is a new Open Access journals which is also experimenting with the review process.

Bob O’Hara and commenters go into details. I hope it does not end like Medical Hypotheses: a great source of blog-fodder for snarky bloggers and not much else. We’ll keep an eye….


  1. #1 Bruce G Charlton
    December 13, 2008

    I am the editor of Medical Hypotheses – Hi!

    I agree that the journal does seem intensely to irritate a certain kind of science blogger – some of whom have apparently had their sense of humor excised along with any scientific adventurousness thay may once have possessed ;=)

    However, the Thomson ISI Impact Factor of 1.3 and c. 45000 article downloads per month are objective evidence that Medical Hypotheses also plays a significant scientific function.

    Peer review is neither necessray nor sufficient for science, and not all journals should be peer reviewed. There is space for a diversity of editorial evaluation processes, surely?

    Live and let live…

The site is currently under maintenance and will be back shortly. New comments have been disabled during this time, please check back soon.