Cognitive Daily

The Stroop Effect is one of the most-studied phenomena in psychology. The test is easy to administer, and works in a variety of contexts. The simplest way to see how it works is just to look the following two lists. Don’t read them, instead say the color each word is displayed in, as quickly as you can:

i-baa00243255a2b7099346b33ae07045d-stroophyp.gif

If English is your native language, you should be much quicker at naming the colors of the first list than the second list. Why? Even though the task is to identify the colors, proficient readers can’t stop themselves from reading the words, which slows color identification in cases where the color is different from the word.

But recently, Amir Raz and colleagues noticed that they could reduce and even eliminate the Stroop Effect by hypnotizing participants and suggesting to them that the words were in a foreign language, so they could focus solely on color. In a new experiment, Raz and three other researchers attempted to see if the hypnosis itself was necessary.

Research has shown that hypnosis is only effective when the person being hypnotized is already susceptible to hypnosis. In order for hypnosis to work, the person being hypnotized must be highly suggestible. But what if highly suggestible individuals are offered suggestions without first being hypnotized? Raz’s team reasoned that perhaps the same effect would result.

The team identified 25 highly suggestible individuals, then divided them into two groups. Each group practiced the Stroop task for a few minutes: a word was flashed on the screen, and participants had to press a key on the computer corresponding to the color it was displayed in. Then one group was hypnotized, but the other was not. After hypnosis (or a break lasting the same amount of time), each group received the same suggestion:

Very soon you will be playing a computer game. When I clap my hands, meaningless symbols will appear in the middle of the screen. They will feel like characters in a foreign language that you do not know, and you will not attempt to attribute any meaning to them. This gibberish will be printed in one of four ink colors: red, blue, green, or yellow. Although you will only be able to attend to the symbols’ ink color, you will look straight at the scrambled signs and crisply see all of them. Your job is to quickly and accurately depress the key that corresponds to the color shown. You will find that you can play this game easily and effortlessly. When I clap my hands twice, you will regain your normal reading abilities.

For half the task, they operated under the influence of the suggestion, and for the remainder of the time, they did the standard Stroop task, with no suggestion (half the participants were given the suggestion for the first half of the task, and for the other participants, the order was reversed). This chart shows the level of Stroop Effect for each condition:

i-6659755a1e077f37b380308eb6597f4e-stroophyp2.gif

Whether or not participants were hypnotized, all showed a diminished Stroop Effect when it was suggested that the words were gibberish. There was no significant difference in the results between hypnotized and non-hypnotized participants.

While the Stroop effect was not completely eliminated in this task, Raz’s team argues that this experiment demonstrates that reading is not entirely involuntary. The experiment is an example of a simple way that individuals who have not been hypnotized can voluntarily reduce the tendency to automatically read the word they are looking at.

Raz, A., Kirsch, I., Pollard, J., & Nitkin-Kaner, Y. (2006). Suggestion reduces the Stroop Effect. Psychological Science, 17(2), 91-95

Comments

  1. #1 jade
    November 25, 2006

    can you put this in a pritable form

  2. #2 Dave Munger
    November 25, 2006

    Jade:

    Sorry, we don’t offer a “printer friendly” format at this time. I’ve brought up the issue with our technical staff, and it may be something we’re able to offer in the future.

    Best you can do now is to copy the text and graphics into an MS Word file, and print from there.

  3. #3 Sydney
    February 20, 2007

    I am using the stroop effect as my 7th grade science fair project! I hope i win!!

  4. #4 aj torralba
    July 26, 2007

    can you give me the theory that you used for your experiment? Because i am conducting the same experiment but my teacher said that i need a specific theory of attention. Can you help me with this.

  5. #5 Dave Munger
    July 26, 2007

    I’m not exactly sure what your teacher is looking for but you might want to look at this post for some ideas about theories of attention.

  6. #6 dreikin
    December 6, 2007

    Interesting note: Instead of reading straight down the lists, I read them left to right. I’ve done the task several times before, but usually the image looks more like this:
    http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/farid/illusions/stroop.html

    On this one, I did quite a bit better than I normally do (albeit, I’m fairly fast at it since I can block out the reading element by practice). I think two things – one I noticed as I did it, and another only afterward – might have helped:

    1) Because every other one was correlated, that might have been able to help me ‘setup’ for the next uncorrelated one.

    Do you know if there’s been any research to see if, when the test is presented as correlated reading, then uncorrelated, there is a performance difference between the start of the uncorrelated reading (first 5 words, maybe), the middle, and then maybe a pick-up in speed, or increasing lag, towards the end?

    2) This is the one I noticed: because of the layout, I was able to ‘seek ahead’ to pick out the color of the next few words from my (not very) peripheral vision. I think this one was more significant (or the only significant factor).

    Ah, and I don’t consider myself to be (though I haven’t tested it) highly suggestible.

  7. #7 Harq al-Ada
    December 6, 2007

    How do they measure suggestability? That sounds like a difficult thing to do.

  8. #8 Bryan
    December 13, 2007

    HI!@I!OUIYHASui DVISyhfdgsy v
    i neeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeed morrrrrrrrrrrrrereooroerco inof ofofuf i unf dsg INFO on the CTcdoujq iovstro STROOP EFFECT

  9. #9 Olivia
    October 25, 2008

    I’m using this idea to build onto a science fair project. What variable would I be using? Would it maybe be the color of the writing? And how exactly would you state the question?

  10. #10 Antonia
    November 2, 2009

    this test is confusing but how do you measure something like this with out just timing it. Any ideas?