Now on ScienceBlogs: What's the buzz?: Synthetic marijuana, K2, Spice, JWH-018

Enter to Win

The Corpus Callosum

The Corpus Callosum is an occasional journal of armchair musings, by a suburban, reality-based, slightly-left-of-center guy, who reserves the right to be highly irregular at times. Topics: social commentary, neuroscience, politics, science news. Mission: to develop connections between hard science and social science, using linear thinking and intuition; and to explore the relative merits of spontaneity vs. strategy.

Search

Profile

cc-head-41px.jpg


Corpus Callosum is written by a psychiatrist at a small community hospital somewhere in the USA. Email to cc.scienceblogger at gmail dot com.


Banner images from CNS Forums. Banner font: Ringbearer.
Wikio - Top Blogs - Sciences


Subscribe with Bloglines
Add this blog to my Technorati Favorites!
Feedburner Feed


Quick Add-Feed Links...

add to My YahooSubscribe in NewsGator Online
Subscribe with Pluck RSS reader Add to My AOL
Add to PageflakesAdd to Netvibes
 Add to GoogleSubscribe in Rojo


Widgetize!
Change Congress



Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial -Share Alike 3.0 United States License.

Recent Posts

Recent Comments

Categories

Archives

Blogroll


The main blogroll has been moved to its own page, so as not to delay the opening of the main page.

Carnivals



synapsebutton.jpg

th_elogo1.jpg

Evilutionists!

tbbadge.gif

Skeptics Circle

Other Stuff



blog counter

« Statistically Improbable Phrases in the Debate | Main | Paliperidone: Cost Effective (?) »

Solar Power: What Is Wrong With This Picture?

Category: Energy
Posted on: October 5, 2008 7:48 AM, by Joseph j7uy5

solar-1.jpg

The photo shows the first commercial implementation of a new kind of solar-powered electrical generation station (source: IEEE Spectrum). 

The problem, of sorts, is that it is not in the USA.  It is in Spain.

The system uses parabolic reflectors to heat a kind of oil.  The oil is circulated through a system that runs steam turbines to generate electricity.  But, is uses only part of the heat for that purpose.  Some of the heat is stored in huge tanks of molten salt.  

A short video that shows the Andasol 1 station, and the manufacturing of the components, is here.

After dark, the heat from the tanks is used to keep the turbines running.  Thus, the station produces electricity even when the sun is not shining.  

This gets past one of the biggest problems with solar power.  It also reduces the final cost:

The developers say Andasol 1's electricity will cost 11 percent less to produce than a similar plant without energy storage—dropping from 303 euros per megawatt-hour to 271 euros per MWh.

Installations in the USA have focused on lower costs for the initial installation.  The storage system adds to the initial cost, obviously, but reduces the total cost per megawatt over the life of the system.

The cost-effectiveness is increased even more, in areas that charge higher prices for power delivered at peak times (time-of-day pricing).

Soon, they will build a system that uses the molten salt in both parts of the system.  That is, instead of using the solar arrays to heat oil, then using the hot oil to heat the salt, it heats the molten salt directly in the solar array.

The problem with the picture is that we produced the technology here is the USA [at Sandia Labs (satellite view)], but Spain is getting the benefit.  I have nothing against Spain: more power to them, I say.  But it is very strange that we all would be ranting about dependence on "foreign" oil, while ignoring the solutions that we ourselves have developed.

In other news, the US military is getting fed up with the high price of oil.  Every $10 increase in the price of a barrel of oil leads to a $600 million/year increase in the Pentagon's energy cost.

To combat this threat, they have built a geothermal power station at the Coso Geothermal Field at their China Lake U.S. Naval Air Weapons Station.  It's a great idea.

In fact, the USA is the world's leading producer of geothermal power.  But what countries get the greatest percentage of their power from geothermal sources?  Iceland and the Philippines.  Curiously, Alaska is the State with the greatest geothermal resources, yet they are just starting to make use of this resource.

Share on: Stumbleupon Reddit Email + More

TrackBacks

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://scienceblogs.com/mt/pings/82850

Comments

1

I like your article, but it's a little misleading. We have solar plants similar to this in California. The Kramer Junction Solar Power Plants (http://www.solel.com/products/pgeneration/ls2/kramerjunction/) use this tech. Although, I admit I don't think it uses the storage solution - simple and ingenious! Also, the geothermal plant at China Lake is really not so new (http://www.caithnessenergy.com/geothermal.html), it's been around for a while.

The gist of your article is right on target. It is embarrassing that we are not investing more in these technologies. Then again, since I live near both of these facilities, I can tell you that the government and environmental regulations in this country, while good intentioned, have a strangle-hold on all new development. For example, for every acre displaced by the Kramer Junction facility, they had to buy 100 acres elsewhere just in case there happens to be any endangered flora or fauna. Keep in mind, that's 'just in case' - not that they actually found any. Also nearby are the Tehachapi High Wind Farms (http://www.edison.com/). Those are constantly being protested by people with concerns about birds, bats, and other affected 'things'. Until we can come to grips with out own societal hang-ups, we're doomed to oil dependency.

Posted by: Larry Riendeau | October 6, 2008 9:42 PM

2

"But it is very strange that we all would be ranting about dependence on "foreign" oil, while ignoring the solutions that we ourselves have developed."

They are not substitutes. The solar technology in question could not run an airplane, truck, or most trains. Transportation + chemical synthesis is where most petroleum goes. Conversely, virtually no petroleum is used to provide electrical grid power.

Where we (U.S.) ought to be using this is the desert southwest. I look at a field of fluid heaters and I see a water recycler/desalinator. Water stores almost indefinitely, too.

Posted by: Daniel Newby | October 7, 2008 6:18 PM

3

Excellent article.

Posted by: Aeronautica | October 13, 2008 3:37 PM

Post a Comment

(Email is required for authentication purposes only. On some blogs, comments are moderated for spam, so your comment may not appear immediately.)





ScienceBlogs

Search ScienceBlogs:

Go to:

Advertisement
Collective Imagination
Enter to win the daily giveaway
Advertisement
Collective Imagination

© 2006-2009 ScienceBlogs LLC. ScienceBlogs is a registered trademark of ScienceBlogs LLC. All rights reserved.