The Frontal Cortex

Prisons and the Brain

What are the psychological effects of “doing time”? Do harsher prison conditions create harder criminals? These are the questions that the economists M. Keith Chen and Jesse Schapiro were determined to answer. Their conclusions are sobering:

Some two million Americans are currently incarcerated, with roughly six hundred thousand to be released this year. Despite this, little is known about the effects of confinement conditions on the post-release lives of inmates. In this paper we estimate the causal effect of prison conditions on recidivism rates by exploiting a discontinuity in the assignment of federal prisoners to security levels, and find that harsher prison conditions lead to significantly more post-release crime.

This really shouldn’t be so surprising. There’s now a strong scientific consensus that impoverished environments – and there are few environments as impoverished as solitary confinement – are toxic for the brain. Not only do these conditions vastly increase the likelihood of brain disease, but they are also incredibly stressful. The worst part of chronic stress – besides the fact that it kills your neurons – is that you become incapable of mounting an effective stress response in the future. Just look at the effects of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). Victims not only exhibit acute sensitivity to innocuous triggers – they think every loud noise is a gunshot – but they exhibit a prolonged and elevated stress response to those same events. These leads to violent outbursts, which are also stressful. As a result, daily life becomes unbearably arduous. Chronic stress ends up becoming a vicious positive feedback loop.

So this is what we’re doing to the several million inmates of our prison system. Of course, we shouldn’t judge our penal system solely by its effects on neural plasticity. But we also shouldn’t be surprised when that system creates an enormous population of dangerous minds.

I once worked in a lab where the rats started eating their cagemates. It was bloody and disgusting. A post-doc eventually decided that there were too many rats in each cage, and that the density was stressing the rodents out. Unfortunately, these stressed out rats were too far gone: even when the population density was reduced, they still insisted on fighting each other to the death. Stress had broken their brains.

Comments

  1. #1 David
    December 13, 2006

    Am I a geek if I first read the title as “Prions and the Brain”?

    You had me really excited for a second there.

  2. #2 Jonah
    December 13, 2006

    Sorry to disappoint. I’m also pretty excited about prions and the brain. In fact, I used to work for Kausik Si, who is doing some of the most interesting work in prions and the brain:
    http://www.wi.mit.edu/news/archives/2003/sl_1224.html

  3. #3 Mark
    December 13, 2006

    Interesting that you bring this up so soon after Eric Rudolph was in the news complaining that his supermax prison was so unpleasant. He won’t be getting out of prison so I am not worried about recidivism, even if he showed any signs of remorse. On the other hand, a pragmatic approach might work better with convicts who might actually return to society and who might conceivably be rehabilitated.

  4. #4 Clayton
    December 14, 2006

    The corruption and violence, aggrevated by overcrowding, are the main issues IMO. The “peer influences” being the major factor. Too many people seem to think that the “harshness” stems from a lack of pingpong tables, A/C, gourmet food, and comfy mattresses. Billions of people live without these things without becoming more violent. As of 2004 the average cost of incarceration was $23,206 with 2,134,566 prisoners. That puts the total cost at $49,534,738,596. What’s in your wallet?

    Whatever the proposed solution, the evidence as to it’s cost effectiveness had better be compelling. I suspect that what we see is simply a result of putting violent prone individials in proximity with one another without adequate safeguards to stem the inherent friction that results.

The site is currently under maintenance and will be back shortly. New comments have been disabled during this time, please check back soon.