Now on ScienceBlogs: That Which I Sowed in Tears, I Now Reap in Joy: A Love Letter to my Beautiful Readers

Seed Media Group

« Don't Read the Business Page | Main | Lesch-Nyhan »

The Daily Show on Psychology

Category: Culture
Posted on: August 10, 2007 8:06 PM, by Jonah Lehrer

Jon Stewart, interviewing Tal Ben-Shahar, who teaches a positive psychology class at Harvard:

"I was a psychology major, so I know a lot of it is bullshit."

Watch the video here.

Share on: Stumbleupon Reddit Email + More

Trackbacks

Trackback URL for this entry: http://scienceblogs.com/mt/pings/47718

Comments (5)

1

and you agree? What's your point?

Posted by: tekel | August 13, 2007 10:27 AM

2

I was just surprised that Jon Stewart was a psych major. I'm not eager to weigh in on the "bullshit" question.

Posted by: Jonah | August 13, 2007 10:49 AM

3

aaaah. Well obviously, not ALL of psychology is BS... Maybe Stewart picked his major based on what classes the pretty girls were taking. Certainly psychology is less depressing than, say, PoliSci.

Posted by: tekel | August 13, 2007 11:16 AM

4

I would note that many people, like Stewart in the segment, seem to believe that branches of psychology are BS because they aren't inherently reductionist. I think that's mistaken. Lots of uber-reductionist neuroscience is BS (ie, it's utterly wrong and will be disproved in 5 years) but I think many of the core tenets of social psychology, for example, have aged very well. Just look at cognitive dissonance. That's a fifty year old theory that is still as relevant and applicable as ever. So if it's BS, then it's BS that has stood the test of time.

Posted by: Jonah | August 13, 2007 11:21 AM

5

There is not that much point in getting worked up over an entertainer, who wasn't even totally dismissive. Psychology is just more bullshit-tolerant than other sciences. Objectivity is difficult and sometimes undesired when your subject is you. Psychological theories do not have the benefit of mathematically defined concepts like physics and chemistry. And unlike biology, the model system is a black box. And unlike all 3, its parameters are sensitive to social bias. In order to tell what is bullshit and what is not in psychology you have to be very critical and vigilant, things people are often not wont to be. And Jonah's right, an important feature of a good theory is if the resultant airplane will fly, and certainly there are many examples from psychology.

Posted by: caribbeanwaffle | August 15, 2007 12:39 AM

Post a Comment

(Email is required for authentication purposes only. On some blogs, comments are moderated for spam, so your comment may not appear immediately.)

ScienceBlogs

Search ScienceBlogs:

Go to:

Advertisement
Follow ScienceBlogs on Twitter
Visit the Collective Imagination blog
Advertisement

© 2006-2009 Seed Media Group LLC. ScienceBlogs is a registered trademark of Seed Media Group. All rights reserved.

Sites by Seed Media Group: Seed Media Group | ScienceBlogs | SEEDMAGAZINE.COM