How universal are our first impressions of people? Test yourself against this piece of video art:
Do you agree with most of the descriptions? The art is surprisingly riveting, no?
Absolutely fascinating. I’m bowled over by this. Amazing how differently the same person is perceived by different observers. As I watched the video, the faces that recurred looked different the second time, maybe due to their familiarity.
Interesting also to ponder the relationship between how a person thinks they look and what they project to others.
And nobody seems to like kids much, innit?
That poor kid — The rest of the people must be stepparents.
I disagreed with almost all of the impressions.
Amazing piece. Thanks!
Intriguing. I didn’t / don’t know what to “conclude,” if anything. I sort of figured, at the end, there would be some series of captions, something like “serving life sentence for serial murders” for the innocent-looking ones, or “does volunteer work with HIV patients” for the so-called aggressive faces. That’s just me.
Interesting. I think part of what was intriguing was comparing two faces so exactly side by side. I’m not sure whether it was intentional but it seemed like people were paired up with a great deal of similarity – similar symmetry of noses, shape of eyes, etc. It was fascinating to watch them make judgments about people who sometimes looked so similar to themselves. Then again, maybe I imagined that.
A friend of mine is currently reading the book “Blink” by Malcom Gladwell, which discusses the impressions we make within the first two seconds of encountering someone or something. In the book he references Project Implicit (https://implicit.harvard.edu/implicit/demo/background/index.jsp), a study being performed to “help people to gain greater awareness about their own unconscious preferences and beliefs.” Both the book and the research are so intriguing!!!
In some cases, it seemed like the person not speaking was listening to or could hear what the speaker was saying about him or her — but I couldn’t be sure of that. Do you know?
When we meet someone, is it the emotional brain that reacts to visual and other sensory cues and then the rational brain that gives reasons for our gut instinct/snap judgement?
Alot of the first impressions that people described were quite different from my first impression.
Nice post, and a fantastic blend of what is like the unification of the arts and sciences, promoting the third culture.
For me, what was most interesting was becoming aware that I was not only forming my own opinions about those being judged, but forming ideas about how each observer would judge each subject. There are so many layers to this re: how we see other people, ourselves, our own perceptions, and the perceptions of others.
Wow. What an incredibly interesting art piece. I’ve never been one for first impressions. I judge people of course, I’m not saying I don’t but not by the red in people’s eyes… I didn’t notice it until it was pointed out at me. Does that mean I’m apathetic? Lazy? or maybe even unobservant? Each way you, the person reading this comment has already judged me based on what I’ve written in these 6-odd lines.
Brings me back to Blink!
Not very universal at all, I’d say … except that one fellow truly _did_ look tired. I thought Mr. Clinically Dead was funny.
New comments have been temporarily disabled. Please check back soon.
NOTE: This blog has moved. The Frontal Cortex is now over here.
I’ve got some exciting news:…
Over at Gizmodo, Joel Johnson makes a convincing argument for adding random strangers to your twitter…
I’ve got a new article in the latest Wired on the science of stress, as seen…
Over at Sciam’s Mind Matters, Melody Dye has a great post on the surprising advantages of…
Joe Keohane has a fascinating summary of our political biases in the Boston Globe Ideas section…