Barista has more on the history of Spiked. It seems that they have set up another astroturf operation called “Sense about Science”, chaired by Dick Taverne.

Comments

  1. #1 Aaron Swartz
    August 7, 2005

    I think that period should be a comma.

  2. #2 TCO
    August 8, 2005

    There are two aspects to consider in the errors: how much they change the point of a paper (how they affect a final result), and how much they indicate that the person making the error is a nincompoop, unreliable and unworthy to remain in the debate.

    I think either error are understandable in terms of the vast amount of computation occuring and that neither participant needs to hide his head in shame and refrain from battling on the areas of content. I have a hard time thinking that men who can use words like eigenvector and know what it means are unaware of the difference between grads and radians or sqrt versus not sqrt.

  3. #3 TCO
    August 8, 2005

    Even an error that radically shifts the final answer does not mean that the person making it should stop engaging in work in the field. It could just be luck to make an error in an area where the effect is large versus one where it is small (might be an identical sort of error even). Although of course the effect is more unfortunate. And we can rationally criicise the inability to “second check the work for reasonableness”.

  4. #4 TCO
    August 8, 2005

    I don’t think that Mc’s error on the radians was in the nature of not knowing the difference. I don’t think it is even as bad as making such a mistake when working on a calculator (cause there you have that little symbol in the display telling you the mode). ACtually I can see how it would be pretty easy mistake to make if the wording of the input asked for lattitude rather than “angle”. Who thinks of lattitude in angle? Is the source data commonly kept in degrees (yes). And why would one expect a manual conversion outside the program? Anyway…it’s not that big a deal.

  5. #5 TCO
    August 8, 2005

    Can you talk to Steve? His spambot ate a bunch more of my posts…either that or I’ll plague you…

The site is currently under maintenance and will be back shortly. New comments have been disabled during this time, please check back soon.