Category: kates
Paul Blackman writes: I'm not sure Kates actually prevents anyone from learning anything. He presents something with a clear bias, but he no more prevents anything than does Tim's commentary. Kates claims that he is trying "to place Malcolm's contribution...
Read on »
Posted by Tim Lambert at 12:58 AM • • 0 TrackBacks
Category: kates
My comments on this article by Don Kates. Mr Kates does readers of the History News Network a grave disservice with his article. He pretends to provide them a criminologist's perspective on the guns-crime question, but only quotes from pro-gun...
Read on »
Posted by Tim Lambert at 2:19 PM • • 0 TrackBacks
Category: kates
In the Tennessee Law Review (v61 513-596 1994) Kates et al wrote: the inventive Dr. Diane Schetky, and two equally inventive CDC writers Gordon Smith and Henry Falk in a separate article actually do provide purportedly supporting citations for the...
Read on »
Posted by Tim Lambert at 11:03 AM • • 0 TrackBacks
Category: kates
If you just want to look at accidental death, I would note that most of the decrease in fatal gun accidents in the US occured before there was an increase in handgun ownership Table 2.1 of Kleck's "Point Blank" shows...
Read on »
Posted by Tim Lambert at 10:00 AM • • 0 TrackBacks
Category: kates
Don B Kates, Jr. writes: Having been out of town on two different trips, I have not had a chance to finish my response to Mr. Lambert's latest screed to me. But I note his comment that Ed Suter has...
Read on »
Posted by Tim Lambert at 7:11 AM • • 0 TrackBacks
Category: kates
Someone writes: TO List Supervisor, Prof. Volokh: Mendacious, Fabrication, Falsity, Untrue. These words used by Mr. Lambert to describe Mr. Kates's arguments. Is it permissible to call a list member a liar if you use a thesaurus? No. The only...
Read on »
Posted by Tim Lambert at 9:26 PM • • 0 TrackBacks
Category: kates
[Writing to Don Kates] You asserted that handguns are involved in less than 50% of criminal firearm injuries. You dismissed my calculation that the data in your paper implied that the percentage was 90-97% as some sort of trick. Could...
Read on »
Posted by Tim Lambert at 11:01 AM • • 0 TrackBacks
Category: kates
Don B Kates, Jr. writes: In vol. 62 # 3 (1995) of the TN Law Rev, Henry Schaffer, three professors at Harvard and Columbia Medical Schools, and I have an article evaluating the medical/public health literature on firearms. Our general...
Read on »
Posted by Tim Lambert at 8:05 PM • • 0 TrackBacks