Gupta for Surgeon General? Cool.

As my regular readers know, I recently lost my father-in-law. He was a terrific teacher and loved to brag about students who had done well. One of his favorite “brags” was Sanjay Gupta of CNN, and now, the Washington Post is reporting that Obama wants Sanjay to be the next Surgeon General.

Dick, I wish you were around to see it.

Comments

  1. #1 mike
    January 6, 2009

    Don’t know a lot about Gupta, but my preferred neurosurgeon would have been Steven Novella!

  2. #2 Coturnix
    January 6, 2009

    Anyone but Egnor!

  3. #3 Joe
    January 6, 2009
  4. #4 PalMD
    January 6, 2009

    I tend to agree with val that he lacks a bit of gravitas, and i am a bit worried about his journalism creds pushing him to “both sides-ism” but i see potential.

  5. #5 BDM
    January 6, 2009

    As soon as I heard about the Gupta pick, I came here assuming you doofuses would be all for it. I’m disappointed to learn I’m right. Gupta is a pharmaceutical industry hooker, & I find it ironic that someone who has “a special interest in the ways patients are deceived by charlatans” is actually in favor of this bonehead move.

  6. #6 PalMD
    January 7, 2009

    I’m not saying the guy’s a perfect choice, but before being an asshole slinging ad homs all over the tubes, you wanna give some data?

  7. #7 freelunch
    January 7, 2009

    I have a vague memory that Gupta has been fairly tolerant of woo. Given your willingness to support him, I’m guessing that my memory about that is erroneous. Do you have any further information about Gupta’s attitudes about the imaginary medicine disciplines?

  8. #8 BDM
    January 7, 2009

    Gupta conceals the true affiliations of his guest “healthcare experts:”
    http://mediamatters.org/items/200707120001?f=s_search

    Gupta cherry-picks facts to promote Big Pharm:
    http://www.rawfoodinfo.com/articles/art_doctoringthenews.htm

    Gupta is a paid shill for Big Pharm:
    http://blog.lib.umn.edu/schwitz/healthnews/155662.html

  9. #9 SLC
    January 7, 2009

    Re Mike

    Dr. Novella is a neurologist, not a neurosurgeon.

    Re BDM

    The tipoff that Mr. BDM is a crank comes from his use of the term “big pharma”, in addition to his link to a quack website rawfoodinfo.

  10. #10 SLC
    January 7, 2009

    Re PalMD

    Dr. Orac and Prof. Myers seem rather less enthusiastic about Dr. Gupta then Dr. PalMD.

  11. #11 PalMD
    January 7, 2009

    um…citing “rawfoodinfo.com” isn’t all that credible.

    I was very mildly in favor of the choice, but if cranks like you are against it, i might have to start cheerleading for the guy.

  12. #12 BDM
    January 7, 2009

    Rawfoodinfo simply reprinted the piece, which originally ran on Counterpunch:
    http://www.counterpunch.org/martens07202007.html

    Is that as far as you got?
    I didn’t use the term “big pharm” to signal my allegiance with anyone; it is simply an abbreviation. I guess I should’ve used “pharmaceutical industry.”
    You obviously didn’t follow the links, but rather looked for the easiest escape route by dismissing the rawfoodinfo url & calling me a “crank.” Well, one ad hom deserves another, right?
    If you want to play tit-for-tat, I concede. You win. If, on the other hand, you want to find out whether or not Gupta is a good pick for Surgeon General, follow the links.

  13. #14 PalMD
    January 7, 2009

    If you’re disturbed because Gupta endorsed Garasil, you are officially on my crank list.

  14. #15 BDM
    January 7, 2009

    I’m disturbed that Gupta began endorsing Garasil eight months before testing on the drug had even been completed. Even the AMA says Garasil’s efficacy is modest at best. Gupta is promoting a product, not a treatment; his endorsement is an advertisement disguised as an objective scientific opinion, which I oppose. If that puts me on your crank list, then I’m proud to be a crank.

  15. #16 SLC
    January 7, 2009

    Re BDM

    Counterpunch. The antisemitic far left wing counterpart to stormfront and rense.

  16. #17 BDM
    January 7, 2009

    Nice try, SLC. The issue at hand is whether Gupta is a sound choice for Surgeon General, which, in my opinion, he is not, especially considering all the “change” rhetoric from the Obama campaign. Alexander Cockburn’s alleged anti-semitism is neither here nor there, since he didn’t write the article I linked to above.
    Honestly, the arguments you people employ simply to avoid conceding a point astonish me. I thought this was the Science Blogs.

  17. #18 sohbet odaları
    June 16, 2010

    If you want to play tit-for-tat, I concede. You win. If, on the other hand, you want to find out whether or not Gupta is a good pick for Surgeon General, follow the links.

The site is currently under maintenance and will be back shortly. New comments have been disabled during this time, please check back soon.