Crazy Luddite Libertarian Mike Adams is following his usual script, ghoulishly using the school shooting in Newton to pillory his usual bogeymen he blames for anything. True to form he is blaming psychiatry and medications for the school shooting. What was it I said yesterday?

At some point it is likely he’ll find a way to blame his other favorite bogeymen, GMOs, pharmaceuticals, doctors (especially psychiatrists), and scientists.

Did I call this or what?

What is really stunning is how the cranks have continuously, and incorrectly flogged the IOM’s “to err is human” study for the last decade. Depending on the crank, they claim the study shows that either doctors or drugs are responsible for 100k deaths a year, but I’m pretty sure no one has actually ever read it. The study actually suggests that medical mistakes may have contributed to between 44-98k deaths a year (they always cite the high end), but, you have to actually look at what the mistakes are. Drug related mistakes or “adverse drug events” were estimated by the IOM to be responsible for 10% of these preventable errors. A large portion of the errors are the failure to intervene or failure in timely diagnosis. Which means, the IOM on review of a hospitalization felt that a death may have been caused by a failure to intervene. In other words, it’s very strange that the cranks use a study to call doctors a killer, when the study actually shows one of the most common medical errors was the failure to medically intervene. For example, such a mistake may be not recognizing a stroke and providing the appropriate medication in time.

The IOM study was meant to show how doctors could do better, that we could implement systems to prevent mistakes that were too common in medical practice. But the cranks wave it around to say, “medicine doesn’t work!” when the study frequently blames the failure to provide an appropriate medical intervention for the deaths. Anyone else see the problem with their logic?

Doctors just can’t win with these people, but that’s ok. We’ll be fine. We have the medications and technology that actually work, and as studies like the IOM’s show, we’re also willing to admit we can do better.

Comments

  1. #1 Michael Caton
    San Diego, CA
    December 15, 2012

    Adams is right there with Scientology, who take these tragedies as an opportunity to bash pyschiatric medical care. This one relating to Aurora is circulating on Facebook and elsewhere. I had never heard of Scientology’s front organization (Citizens Commission for Human Rights International) so it’s worth getting it out there. http://www.cchrint.org/2012/07/20/the-aurora-colorado-tragedy-another-senseless-shooting-another-psychotropic-drug/

  2. #2 B. Zar
    Europe
    December 16, 2012

    Not only scientologists warn for crazyness-by-psychiatric-pills, see e.g. http://www.ssristories.com/index.php?sort=date

  3. #3 OleanderTea
    Boston, MA
    December 17, 2012

    Were it not for psychiatric medications and caring psychiatrists and psychologists, I’d be dead. I wonder how many thousands of people like me are out there, doing fine but uncounted in the brou-ha-ha?

    But yeah, Adams, et al, are ghoulish in the extreme.