Developing Intelligence

Don’t think of a white bear. Doesn’t work so well, does it? Yet under some circumstances, people appear to be able to do precisely this: as described last week, young adults are thought (by some) to actually suppress the neural activity related to to-be-ignored stimuli, and even delay the peak of this neural activity, relative to a situation in which stimuli are to be just passively-viewed. In a follow-up paper at Nature Neuroscience, Gazzaley et al report that cognitively-intact older adults (60-77 years of age) show an impairment in this ability, without concomitant impairments in the enhancement effects normally observed to to-be-attended stimuli.

Gazzaley et al report that normal aging is not only accompanied by impairments in working memory for the to-be-attended stimuli, but also correlated with it, perhaps suggesting a critical role for these suppression effects in good performance, and in age-related decline in performance. In addition, those older adults showing large behavioral impairment, but not those who were better matched to the younger subjects, rated the to-be-ignored stimuli as more familiar than the younger adults, indicating that perhaps they failed to inhibit processing of those to-be-ignored stimuli.

On the other hand, some aspects of the design seem to indicate that young adults use an oculomotor strategy to accomplish suppression. That is, they might have been looking at uninformative parts of the stimuli or closing their eyes altogether, which would be expected to yield a large number of saccade/blink related artifacts in the EEG, or the presence of high-amplitude “alpha” waves, respectively. Both phenomena were observed in previous work, with 7 out of 18 young adults being excluded for these reasons. In the current study with older adults, EEG was not used – so we cannot know whether similar numbers of older adults would have been excluded for these regions, or whether they might not have used this strategy.

Nonetheless there are reasons to believe that poor strategy use could be more central to age-related decline than inhibitory deficits – a number of previous studies indicate that older adults are impaired at cognitively monitoring their own performance and at identifying and selecting optimal strategies. For example, this study by Brigham & Pressley showed that 60-88 year-old adults were less able to detect the advantage conferred by an explicitly taught strategy for studying word lists, and were less likely to apply it when learning subsequent lists, than younger adults (24-39 years old). Even if older adults actually discovered the advantageous oculomotor strategy for the Gazzaley paradigm, they may have failed to use it. Alternatively (or additionally) older adults may have been more likely to forget the instructions on any particular trial sequence, and to default to a strategy of attempting to remember everything, leading to greater familiarity of to-be-ignored items.

Nonetheless, the study remains a powerful demonstration of the age-related decline that can be observed on tasks with high working memory demands, and is strongly suggestive of a age-related deficit that is specific to trials with inhibitory demands. The open question is whether these deficits reflect a core underlying “inhibitory” mechanism, or whether they rely on impaired “metamemory,” impaired strategy discovery, or impaired strategy use among older adults.

Comments

  1. #1 Mike
    June 29, 2009

    On the link below I mentioned the problems I had with the study. Why pick Abu Ghraib? How is disgust from torture related to the first part of the study (which was disgust from opposing party members)? Why make unnecessary democrats/republican comparisons when it could be done without that? Apples to oranges comparisons too, possibly.

    I’d just be curious to know what you think and why I might be wrong? Your obviously a smart person, so you could be right. I just thought the study could have been constructed better.

    There seems to be implied political stuff going on here, like fervant republicans are more likely to torture people. It seems a tad politically non neutral to me.

  2. #2 PhelpsErna30
    November 7, 2010

    When you’re in not good state and have no cash to move out from that point, you would need to receive the business loans. Just because that should help you definitely. I take consolidation loans every time I need and feel OK because of it.

  3. #3 cheap-prada.com
    December 27, 2010

    http://www.cheap-prada.com/ Online Sale Wholesale:Prada Shoes,Cheap Prada Shoes,Cheap Pradas,Prada Shoes,High Top Prada Sneakers,Cheap Prada Handbags,Prada Sunglass Wholesale.

  4. #4 IrisBerger30
    January 28, 2011

    Set your life time more simple get the loans and everything you require.

The site is currently under maintenance and will be back shortly. New comments have been disabled during this time, please check back soon.