Dispatches from the Creation Wars

The ID crowd just continues to push this ridiculous argument that the Understanding Evolution website, by pointing out that evolution is not necessarily in conflict with religion and that many Christians and other types of theists accept evolution without giving up their faith, violates the establishment clause. The latest is from our old friend Francis Beckwith. This argument has been completely shredded by Timothy Sandefur, in a piece that Beckwith has no doubt seen. Yet he continues to push this, on his blog and in print. I’m sure he made a few bucks with the article in the American Spectator, but I still think it’s kind of silly to keep pushing an argument this silly.

In fact, I think it’s time for a challenge. Frank, I know you read this blog. If you really think you have an argument here, take it to court. If you really think this is a violation of the establishment clause, file a suit. John West is making the same argument and the DI has lots and lots of money to cover the legal fees. You and David Dewolf can design the legal strategy. I predict that you won’t do it, because you know that this argument would be greeted with exactly the kind of response it is due, primarily laughter. I think you know how bad this argument is, but continue to push it, and ignore the criticisms that have been made of it, because it suits the DI’s public relations agenda.


  1. #1 Paige
    April 8, 2004

    Maybe we need an undercover operation. We develop a “faux creationist”, and have him file the lawsuit. And we then see if DI is willing to put its money where its mouth is.

    Nah, nevermind, that would mean we sink to the low level of the creationists. I take back my suggestion. But it was fun to think about.

The site is currently under maintenance. New comments have been disabled during this time, please check back soon.