Dispatches from the Creation Wars

Heisman for MSU?

Got to watch the MSU-Illinois game on TV and I think it’s time to start talking about MSU QB Drew Stanton as a serious candidate for the Heisman Trophy. His numbers this year have been phenomenal as he’s led the Spartans to a 4-0 start. In those 4 games, here are his numbers:

Kent State: 22 for 29 for 297 yards and 2 touchdowns.

Hawaii: 21 for 26 for 301 yards and 3 touchdowns.

Notre Dame: 16 for 27 for 327 yards and 3 touchdowns, plus 1 running TD.

Illinois: 20 for 26 for 259 yards and 5 touchdowns, and he didn’t play the last 20 minutes of the game.

Overall: 73.1% completion rate, 13 passing touchdowns and 1 rushing touchdown, and 2 interceptions. If he continues to put up numbers anywhere near those, he’s a legitimate Heisman candidate. The next two weeks will decide the whole season, with games against Michigan (at home) and Ohio State (away). If they win those two games, they probably win the Big Ten and will undoubtedly be ranked in top 5. And if that happens, Stanton will be talked about as a serious Heisman finalist. And he’s only a junior, so he’s sure to be hyped for a Heisman next year regardless.

Unfortunately, I don’t have much faith in the coaching staff or the defense to help them win tough games. John L. Smith is a great play caller and offensive innovator, but his teams tend to play undisciplined and he tends to freeze up in big games. Last year’s Michigan game and this year’s Notre Dame game are great examples. He got a big lead in both and then suddenly became very conservative, taking the ball out of Stanton’s hands and playing a soft zone on defense. It’s stupid. If you got a big lead by playing aggressively on both sides of the ball, then keep playing aggressively on both sides of the ball. If your defense got them in a 3rd and 12 situation by bringing an extra man on the pass rush, then don’t suddenly stop doing that on third down and give the QB time to find a receiver. If your QB is hitting on 70% of his passes and marching the team down the field, keep doing it until they show they can stop it. I was happy to see that today they didn’t let up on Illinois when they had them down big, they kept playing aggressively. I hope that’s a sign of things to come.


  1. #1 Sparkles
    September 24, 2005

    Spartans look great this year, but they won’t beat the Buckeyes. hehehehe

  2. #2 Jim Anderson
    September 24, 2005

    Right now USC is struggling against Oregon. Maybe this is MSU’s year to take it all…

  3. #3 Chris Berez
    September 25, 2005

    I haven’t seen any of the MSU games, so I’ll take your word for it, Ed. Personally, being the fan of New England sports that I am, I have to route for BC and Quinton Porter. He won’t get it, I know. But I cheer for BC all the way, and failing that, the Maryland Terps (but only because I live in this disaster of a state). I didn’t go to BC, I went to Marlboro College in VT. But it’s New England all the way for me. Red Sox, Patriots, Bruins, Celtics, and like I said above, BC. Hell, if Soccer in the United States wasn’t so boring, I’d even route for the Revolution.

    Anyway, since I know my guy won’t get it (and he’s out with an injury now anyway), I’ll go for your guy, Ed. Best of luck. Since you brought up how well he’s playing, I’m going to have to catch some of his games.

  4. #4 chrisberez
    September 25, 2005

    Oops, forgot the obligatory “Duke sucks, Yankee suck” comments.

  5. #5 chrisberez
    September 25, 2005

    Oops, forgot the obligatory “Duke sucks, Yankees suck” comments.

New comments have been disabled.