Official Comment Count: 1,026,342

Profile

brayton_headshot_wre_1443.jpg Ed Brayton is a freelance writer and speaker. He is the co-founder and president of Michigan Citizens for Science and co-founder of The Panda's Thumb. He has written for such publications as The Bard, Skeptic and Reports of the National Center for Science Education, spoken in front of many organizations and conferences, and appeared on nationally syndicated radio shows and on C-SPAN. Ed is also a Fellow with the Center for Independent Media.(static)

Search This Blog



Recent Comments

Sb/DonorsChoose Drive


Thanks!

Recent Posts

Blogroll


Science Blogs Legal Blogs Political Blogs Random Smart and Interesting People Evolution Resources

Archives

Other Information

Ed Brayton also blogs at Positive Liberty and The Panda's Thumb



Ed Brayton is a participant in the Center for Independent Media New Journalism Pilot Program. However, all of the statements, opinions, policies, and views expressed on this site are solely Ed Brayton's. This web site is not a production of the Center, and the Center does not support or endorse any of the contents on this site.

Ed's Audio and Video

YearlyKos 2007

Video of speech on Dover and the Future of the Anti-Evolution Movement

Audio of Greg Raymer Interview

E-mail Policy

Any and all emails that I receive may be reprinted, in part or in full, on this blog with attribution. If this is not acceptable to you, do not send me e-mail - especially if you're going to end up being embarrassed when it's printed publicly for all to see.

Read the Bills Act Coalition

My Ecosystem Details



My Amazon.com Wish List

Subscribe via Email

Stay abreast of your favorite bloggers' latest and greatest via e-mail, via a daily digest.

Sign me up!

« Vapid Celebrity Religion for Kids | Main | Virtual Martial Law in D.C. »

VA Supreme Court Unanimous on Miller-Jenkins

Category: Politics
Posted on: June 9, 2008 9:16 AM, by Ed Brayton

It looks like the end of the road, finally, in the Miller-Jenkins case. The Virginia Supreme Court ruled unanimously to uphold the appeals court ruling that Virginia has no jurisdiction over the visitation dispute between a former lesbian couple that was originally filed in Vermont.

This is the case where the couple had a child together, then the biological mother, Lisa Miller, later left and filed for dissolution of the Vermont civil union in the state of Vermont, calling Janet Jenkins the mother of the child and asking for child support. Then she became a born again Christian, decided that being gay was wrong and filed in Virginia to have all custody and visitation rights taken away from Janet.

The problem is that the Vermont court had primary jurisdiction and gave Janet visitation. Under federal law, once one state has issued a custody or visitation ruling, no other state may exercise jurisdiction in the case. The Virginia appeals court ruled that way and the Virginia Supreme Court has now upheld that ruling unanimously.

Naturally, the religious right media is furiously lying about the ruling. The Worldnutdaily claims:

The Virginia State Supreme Court whiffed today on an opportunity to preserve state sovereignty and solidify traditional marriage laws. Instead, the court upheld a ruling that may allow states like Massachusetts and Vermont to export homosexual marriage laws across the country.

Utter nonsense. This case has nothing to do with exporting anything, nor does it have anything to do with civil union laws. The Vermont court had jurisdiction because that's where Lisa Miller filed the case. Had she originally filed in Virginia and that court had issued a ruling, then Vermont would have no jurisdiction in the case under federal law. Expect much wailing and gnashing of teeth over this, all of it based on a flat out lie.

Comments

It's a good victory, but the Chief Justice has stated he believes the appeals court's decision was incorrect. I just don't understand that. It seems like the law is about as clear as it can be in this case, so I'm not sure how he disputes the decision of the appeals court.

Posted by: Gerlach | June 9, 2008 12:20 PM

The Virginia State Supreme Court whiffed today on an opportunity to ... solidify traditional marriage laws.

They say that like it's a bad thing.

Posted by: Dennis N | June 9, 2008 12:31 PM

Exporting gay marriage? Sounds good to me. After all, it is in short supply in 94% of the country.

Posted by: themadlolscientist | June 9, 2008 12:57 PM

To clear up a few things, first this was not an appeal of the Appellate Court ruling that PKPA applied; Lisa's lawyers committed apparent malpractice and failed to filed that appeal in a timely manner, so it was killed.

This suit came about when Janet attempted to file the Vermont Final Order with a Virginia Court to compel Lisa to allow visitation. Lisa used this opportunity to try to reopen the custody question, and was quite properly smacked down on the grounds that the matter was adjudicated in the prior case.

Thus, the VA Chief Justice is correct that the matter of how PKPA should be applied was not a future precedent for cases of this type: The VA Supremes could well decide that issues of multi-state custody could be governed by Virginia public policy, rather than PKPA. They would be wrong, and arguably in violation of the Supremecy Clause of the Constitution (there is a national version of PKPA, passed by Congress). Still, the VA Bar has to be dragged kicking and screaming into the 20th Century (they only got around to merging Courts of Law and Courts of Equity in 2006).

Posted by: kehrsam | June 9, 2008 1:48 PM

I half expect the fundie mom to go underground to avoid obeying the law.

I hope the mother in Vermont gets FULL custody if she attempts it!

Posted by: SharonB | June 9, 2008 4:00 PM

Post a Comment

(Email is required for authentication purposes only. Comments are moderated for spam, your comment may not appear immediately. Thanks for waiting.)





Having problems commenting? (UPDATED)

Blogs in the Network

Advertisement

Top Five: Readers' Picks

Search All Blogs