Dispatches from the Creation Wars

The blogger in Jacksonville, Florida whose identity was outed to the church he attended and criticized is suing the sheriff’s department and prosecutor’s office over having his name revealed to the church despite the investigation finding no wrongdoing on his part.

A formerly anonymous blogger who criticized his prominent Southern Baptist pastor has sued police and state prosecutors for revealing his identify to the church even though an investigation showed he had done nothing illegal.

Tom Rich and his wife Yvette, until recently members of First Baptist Church in Jacksonville, Fla., for about 20 years, filed a lawsuit April 27 claiming that involvement by government officials violated his rights under the First Amendment of the Constitution.


More details:

Rich started his blog after noticing differences in preaching style, fundraising and church administration between Mac Brunson, who became pastor of the Southern Baptist megachurch in 2006, and his predecessor, Jerry Vines, who retired in 2005.

Rich created the blog anonymously, he said, to encourage open and honest dialogue without getting into personalities.

Last fall Robert Hinson, a police officer and First Baptist member who also serves as a member of Brunson’s security detail, opened a criminal investigation into the blog at the request of church leaders. He subpoenaed Google and Comcast to find out who owned the blog.

After closing the investigation, Hinson told the church that Rich was the author. The church then issued trespass warnings against the Riches. Not allowed on church premises, the couple sought out a new church.

Rich claims the Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office investigation and subpoena issued by Assistant State’s Attorney Steven Siegel violated his right to free speech, which includes the right to speak anonymously.

He also alleges that the investigation violated the First Amendment clauses that prohibit the establishment of religion and guarantee free exercise of religious beliefs.

The lawsuit alleges the criminal investigation was “fabricated to create the illusion of legitimacy” but really was “a mere pretext for the discovery and disclosure” of Rich’s identity to the church.

By investigating the blog, the lawsuit says, Hinson, “acting under color of state law, spent taxpayer money and government time prosecuting an errand of the church and in so doing acted as an extension and enforcer for a particular religious entity.”

The lawsuit claims the actions were “deliberate and malicious” and served “no governmental interest.” It seeks damages in excess of $15,000.

I hope he wins and wins big.

Comments

  1. #1 出会い系
    June 30, 2009

    公式出会い系サイトで素敵な出会い探し♪
    公式家出掲示板の代わりによく使用されている出会いサイト!
    セックスフレンドの作り方は実際にセフレを作れたサイトを厳選して紹介してます。
    あなたの好みの恋人探しのお手伝い!!「公式恋人探し」で素敵な☆恋人見つけちゃお♪

  2. #3 人妻
    July 31, 2009

    出会い系
    ようこそ!!気軽にメル友を作って楽しんで下さい♪
    家出掲示板では出会い情報を提供しています☆気軽な出会いOK☆

  3. #4 出会いサイト
    August 5, 2009

    出会い系サイトベストであなたのベストパートナーを見つけよう!
    あなたの恋人探しのお手伝いをいたします
    メル友が欲しいならココでGETしませんか?

  4. #5 恋人探し
    August 6, 2009

    セックスフレンド出会い無料案内所でセックスフレンド募集♪安心サイトご紹介★
    家出掲示板-迷い娘-では無料で安心の家出掲示板を紹介★
    不倫をしたいなら不倫生活2009で決まり!退屈な毎日をここから変えよう

The site is undergoing maintenance presently. Commenting has been disabled. Please check back later!