Adventures in Ethics and Science

Elder offspring: Since soccer season is over, you should take us someplace fun on Saturday.

Dr. Free-Ride: Well, Saturday morning I’ll be at commencement, and I think I’ll need to spend at least part of Saturday afternoon grading.

Younger offspring: Aww, do you have to go to commencement?

Dr. Free-Ride: Yes, I have to. This year I’m a commencement marshal.

Younger offspring: A commencement Martian?! Oh no!

Elder offspring: Do you get to carry a ray-gun?

i-8da084b37e855702c85968370a5cab1b-MartianSmall.jpg

Younger offspring: Why does that Martian in the Looney Tunes cartoons wear a skirt?

Elder offspring: And why is his helmet so big?

Dr. Free-Ride: I don’t know. Why do you suppose creatures like him are what people imagine when they think of life on Mars?

Younger offspring: Because people watch a lot of cartoons.

Dr. Free-Ride: Seriously, though, what do you think Martian critters would be like if there were life on Mars?

Elder offspring: It would depend on the creature.

Dr. Free-Ride: Sure, but there are some pretty big differences between the conditions on Mars and the conditions on Earth. You’d figure those might make a big difference to what kind of features a creature would need to survive on Mars.

Younger offspring: A Martian would need dogs and cats and horses.

Dr. Free-Ride: What??

Younger offspring: To get milk.

Elder offspring: Wouldn’t that be cows?

Dr. Free-Ride: Back up a minute, kiddo. Before we worry about whether a Martian can get a glass of milk, I think there are some bigger issues to reckon with. How is Mars different from Earth?

Younger offspring: No oxygen.

Elder offspring: And because it doesn’t have an atmosphere like Earth’s, it can get much hotter and much colder, all in the same day.

Dr. Free-Ride: Yep. So, I’m trying to imagine a life form that can deal with big temperature extremes and that doesn’t need oxygen. We have anaerobic bacteria, but most of the critters we’re familiar with here on Earth depends on oxygen to keep them alive.

Elder offspring: Martian critters would have to use something else the way we use oxygen.

Younger offspring: Oxygen has to do with why we have blood, right?

Dr. Free-Ride: Uh huh. Remember you asked me last time you needed a bandage why we have blood?

Younger offspring: Yeah. It’s because we need the blood to take oxygen to all the parts of our body.

Elder offspring: Otherwise, each cell would have to find some way to get its own oxygen.

Dr. Free-Ride: It would sort of take the fun out of being multicellular, wouldn’t it?

Younger offspring: But why do our cells need oxygen?

Dr. Free-Ride: Well, they use oxygen in the chemical reactions they do to that keep us alive. I’m pretty sure the reactions that turn our food into energy to move our muscles, for example, all require oxygen.

Younger offspring: That’s why we’d need spacesuits on Mars.

Dr. Free-Ride: Now, maybe there are some other ways you could make a multicellular critter that don’t depend on reactions with oxygen, but as an Earthling, I have a hard time thinking what they’d be like.

Younger offspring: Also, what would they eat on Mars?

Elder offspring: Maybe Martian critters would eat stardust.

Dr. Free-Ride: OK, stardust might be in more ready supply to a Martian than strawberries or soybeans or cow’s milk, but I have no idea what a life form would need to be like in order to “metabolize” stardust.

Elder offspring: The universe is a big and mysterious place. It makes life forms go weird.

i-1a56ce08d2e69ed5c896d7e6807b3e98-MartianVarietiesSmall.jpg

Comments

  1. #1 tomS
    May 23, 2008

    You didn’t answer: Do you get to carry a ray-gun? :-)

  2. #2 Archivist $0.01
    May 23, 2008

    Because people watch a lot of cartoons…

    It would sort of take the fun out of being multicellular, wouldn’t it?

    I am wracking my brain to cleverly connect these two quotes and I just can’t. I guess that calls for a three-day weekend, so I can watch cartoons and have fun being multi-cellular!

  3. #3 Uncle Fishy
    May 23, 2008

    It’s like being an air marshal, right?

  4. #4 K. Signal Eingang
    May 23, 2008

    Hee. I’ve got a little one at home who’s just learning how to talk, I really can’t wait til he gets old enough to ask the really interesting questions (like “why do martians wear skirts and helmets?”).

  5. #5 Zarquon
    May 23, 2008

    Martians wear skirts and helmets because these guys do.

  6. #6 Martin Robbins
    May 23, 2008

    One of the things I’ve often argued with friends, at that stage of the evening when everyone starts talking about the meaning of life and suchlike, is that actually I don’t see life anywhere else being much different from that on Earth. I guess I feel that, regardless of the environmental specifics, any life form on any planet would have to achieve the same basic tasks, and obey the same basic rules. Maybe I’m just unimaginative though!

  7. #7 Alan Kellogg
    May 23, 2008

    Doctor Free Ride,

    Zarquon has it right. Chuck Jones, who created Marvin the Martian, gave him an exaggerated hoplite costume because he’s from Mars, which is named after the Roman god of war. Marvin has a big helmet because he has a big head (mostly ego). He wears a kilt made of leather strips with metal reinforcements because the hoplites of old wore kilts made of leather strips with metal reinforcement to protect ‘delicate parts’ from harm. Though in Marvin’s case the kilt design is a tad silly. :)

  8. #8 Abel Pharmboy
    May 24, 2008

    A ray-gun would certainly come in handy at many commencements as some speakers blather on saying very little while one is sweltering in dark garb under the California sun.

    Elder offspring: And because it doesn’t have an atmosphere like Earth’s, it can get much hotter and much colder, all in the same day.

    Just curious about what age I should expect the PharmKid to have such a grasp of heat transfer – not to divulge the age of Elder Offspring but I just wonder when one might expect any little person, even the child of a scientist with two PhDs, to have these sorts of milestones.

    Which also reminds me: have you ever posted your own list of best books for communicating science to kids at various age ranges?

  9. #9 Brian
    May 24, 2008

    So if there are Metal Martians, are there Punk and Country-Western Martians too?

The site is currently under maintenance and will be back shortly. New comments have been disabled during this time, please check back soon.