October 31, 2009
Category: Truth and Reconciliation in Group Selection
The haystack model (see T&R VIII) includes many assumptions but one was especially biased. Recall that each haystack is colonized by a single fertilized female bearing four genes coding for docility or aggressiveness--two of her own and two from her...
Read on »
Posted by David Sloan Wilson at 8:03 AM • 16 Comments • 0 TrackBacks
October 29, 2009
Category: Truth and Reconciliation in Group Selection
Group selection was decisively rejected on theoretical grounds, according to the patriotic history of individual selection theory. Richard Dawkins declared in 1982 that group selection had "soaked up more theoretical ingenuity than its biological interest warrants" and compared further inquiry...
Read on »
Posted by David Sloan Wilson at 10:40 PM • 16 Comments • 0 TrackBacks
Category: Truth and Reconciliation in Group Selection
One memorable Christmas morning, as our kids were gathering around the tree, I was on my way upstairs to get a sweater when I smelled something really bad. I knew that smell. Our cat had diarrhea and had deposited a...
Read on »
Posted by David Sloan Wilson at 7:52 AM • 8 Comments • 0 TrackBacks
October 28, 2009
Category: Truth and Reconciliation in Group Selection
Most people are prepared to admit that we are influenced by our cultures in ways that we don't understand. As a proverb puts it, the hardest thing for a fish to see is water. Part of the "water" of Victorian...
Read on »
Posted by David Sloan Wilson at 7:45 AM • 21 Comments • 0 TrackBacks
October 27, 2009
Category: Truth and Reconciliation in Group Selection
One reason that I don't spend a lot of time bashing religion is because there are so many other flagrant departures from factual reality to pick on.
Read on »
Posted by David Sloan Wilson at 7:25 AM • 24 Comments • 0 TrackBacks
October 26, 2009
Category: Truth and Reconciliation in Group Selection
By the 1960's, evolutionary theory had settled into a comfortable paradigm called the Modern Synthesis. With other major issues apparently settled (go here for an update on the Modern Synthesis), the issue of group selection began to occupy center stage....
Read on »
Posted by David Sloan Wilson at 10:12 AM • 6 Comments • 0 TrackBacks
October 25, 2009
Category: Truth and Reconciliation in Group Selection
In their book Darwinism Evolving, David J. Depew and Bruce H. Weber make the interesting point that pre-Darwinian notions did not come to an abrupt halt with the advent of Darwin's theory. Instead, they often became repackaged in superficially Darwinian...
Read on »
Posted by David Sloan Wilson at 8:11 AM • 10 Comments • 0 TrackBacks
October 24, 2009
Category: Truth and Reconciliation in Group Selection
Consider some standard examples of design in nature: the aerodynamic wing of the bird, the concealing coloration of the moth, the dense fur of the polar bear. Darwin's insight was to explain these adaptations as products of natural selection: individuals...
Read on »
Posted by David Sloan Wilson at 1:35 PM • 24 Comments • 0 TrackBacks
October 23, 2009
Category: Truth and Reconciliation in Group Selection
The phrase "truth and reconciliation" has been used to resolve bitter political conflicts and achieve national unity, starting with South Africa's Truth and Reconciliation Commission in 1995. I would like to initiate a similar process to resolve a bitter scientific conflict.
Read on »
Posted by Erin Johnson at 11:09 AM • 15 Comments • 0 TrackBacks
Thanks to the ScienceBlogs community for such a boisterous welcome. For those who object to my metaphor of science as a religion that worships truth as its god, I offer the metaphor of science as a contact sport. We try...
Read on »
Posted by David Sloan Wilson at 9:57 AM • 34 Comments • 0 TrackBacks