Framing Science

Shankar Vendantam’s story headlined “Climate Fears Are Driving ‘Ecomigration’ Across the Globe” runs on the front page at the Washington Post today. It’s not often that climate change is a front-pager at the NY Times or the WPost, making it important to understand the types of narratives that prompt editors to give the issue top attention.

For example, in January 2006, Andrew Revkin’s report that NASA political appointees were blocking James Hansen’s ability to make public statements ran as the lead story of the Sunday NY Times. For Times’ editors, who earned their stripes covering politics, the story was probably a classic whistle-blower tale. It also fit with a larger narrative about the Bush administration favoring ideology and cronyism over expertise, while featuring as a central character Hansen, the climate saga’s best known protagonist.

Vendantam’s article at the Washington Post is more difficult to figure out, though it is likely the human interest (and impact) element that pushed it to the front page. The article leads with a local-area NASA computer programmer who moved his family to New Zealand, fearing climate’s inevitable impact in the US (the web story includes a photo with his family, the print version does not). Vendantam then provides context by detailing statistics across the globe on climate-driven migration, quoting several experts on the topic. He closes the article by profiling several U.S. residents in hurricane zones who have moved or are planning on it.

For a review of the factors that shape journalistic decision-making, see this short article synthesizing previous research on what media scholars call “agenda-building,” written for the International Encyclopedia of Communication.

Comments

  1. #1 danny bloom
    February 23, 2009

    If an article like this draws thoughtful, interesting comments in New Zealand, maybe Mr. Fier is onto something in moving. and don’t forget POLAR CITIES, another good idea reported by the NY Times last year, Mr Nisbet

  2. #2 Mike
    February 24, 2009

    It’s pretty clear that the impact of econimic instability far outweighs any forseeable climate impact. If sea levels rise a few feet in a hundred years, so what? Venice Italy has been experiencing advancing waters for much longer, and far from being a disaster area, Venice is a major romantinc tourism getaway.

    Indeed, just under 50 Million Americans move EVERY YEAR. At that rate, America will move 5 Billion people in the next 100 years… so adapting to very slowly advancing waters is a minimal issue. People move for vastly more mundane purposes.

The site is currently under maintenance and will be back shortly. New comments have been disabled during this time, please check back soon.