Gene Expression

Bonobos, the “gentle ape”?

Check out a long piece on bonobos in The New Yorker. Now, I’ve read a fair amount of Frans de Waal’s work, and I think the piece is making him out to be a little more PC than he is. Nevertheless, I am a bit disturbed by the fact that hasn’t seen a Bonobo in the wild! I just happened to have missed that assumed that though most of his research was based on captive animals, there must have been some field research supplementing it. No. And de Waal’s response it pretty lame:

Captivity can have a striking impact on animal behavior. As Craig Stanford, a primatologist at the University of Southern California, recently put it, “Stuck together, bored out of their minds–what is there to do except eat and have sex?” De Waal has argued that, even if captive bonobo behavior is somewhat skewed, it can still be usefully contrasted with the behavior of captive chimpanzees; he has even written that “only captive studies control for environmental conditions and thereby provide conclusive data on interspecific differences.” Stanford’s reply is that “different animals respond very differently to captivity.”

Frans has to know about the problems that might occur because of a norm of reaction. Environments don’t always have the same linear effect on phenotype as you vary them across different genotypes. Bonobos are complex creatures, just like humans. Just as controlled psychological studies on colleges students are important in smoking out the nature of our own species’ cognitive apparatus, field work by anthropologists is also essential in documenting the extent of variation of behavior in the “wild.” It see no reason why the same principle wouldn’t apply to great apes, even if to a lesser extent.

Update: Here’s an interview with a Bonoboologist.

Comments

  1. #1 Leeda
    July 25, 2007

    you should read Chromosome 6, one of the best medical thrillers. Thats where i first heard about bonobos.

  2. #2 David B
    July 27, 2007

    I’m sure I’ve seen film clips of bonobos having promiscuous sex. But were they filmed in the wild?

  3. #3 The Primate Diaries
    July 27, 2007

    I’m a primatologist who just finished my master’s thesis working with bonobos. While I haven’t been to the field yet I have read a great number of field studies.

    Bonobos are clearly different from chimpanzees, particularly in regards to their sexual behavior. Bonobo females will have sexual behavior with other females by rubbing their sexual swellings together. I’ve personally witnessed males (in captivity, but in a three acre enclosure at the San Diego Wild Animal Park) engaging in sexual behaviors with each other. In the wild when two groups meet (an event that would have chimpanzees screaming, throwing sticks and could perhaps even result in violence) bonobos will frequently engage in sexuality rather than aggression.

    For more information you can read my recent article from Wildlife Conservation magazine here

  4. #4 The Primate Diaries
    July 27, 2007

    I’ve just posted an interview at The Primate Diaries with Frances White about bonobos. Dr. White is one of the leading bonobo field researchers in the world and is currently in DR Congo conducting a new bonobo study.

The site is currently under maintenance and will be back shortly. New comments have been disabled during this time, please check back soon.