Greg Laden's Blog
Evolution, Life Sciences, Science Education, Human Evolution, and Stuff
Recent Comments
- Christophe Thill on 2012: an actual review
- Christophe Thill on The Science in the Movie 2012
- Bill Beaty on The Science in the Movie 2012
- Sir Donald on The Irony of Henry Adams: The most misunderstood quote evah!
- Bill Beaty on Make Lava at Home: Don't try this with your good microwave
- Sir Donald on The Irony of Henry Adams: The most misunderstood quote evah!
- Formerly Apostate on 2012: an actual review
- Wanda on Let the War on Christmas Begin. Atheist style.
- Aaron Golas on Make Your Own "Liquid Nitrogen" at Home
- Greg Laden on The Science in the Movie 2012
Profile
Welcome to Greg Laden's Blog.
Search
Blogroll
I also blog at Quiche Moraine, where you will find interesting restaurant reviews, political trades, and tear jerking memories. Such as:
- - Strong Ideas and Exclusionary Thinking: Obama, Palin and Greek Food in Minneapolis
- - Midori’s Floating World Cafe
- - Dinner at Azia
- - The Black Forest Inn: Anarchists 2; Scientists 1
- - The Hurricane Lantern Effect
- - Maybe We Should Have Elected a White President After All
- - The Day the Right Wing Lost Its Last Shred of Moral Standing
- - My Journey Through Race and Racism (Part I)
- - Fashion at the West Bank’s Bedlam
Archives
- November 2009
- October 2009
- September 2009
- August 2009
- July 2009
- June 2009
- May 2009
- April 2009
- March 2009
- February 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008
- October 2008
- September 2008
- August 2008
- July 2008
- June 2008
- May 2008
- April 2008
- March 2008
- February 2008
- January 2008
- December 2007
- November 2007
- October 2007
Recent Posts
- California Condors
- Dogs & Physics
- Tiny Tim on Global Warming
- Let the War on Christmas Begin. Atheist style.
- Dems Win Senate Vote
- 2012: an actual review
- Make Your Own "Liquid Nitrogen" at Home
- The Science in the Movie 2012
- Who are better conversationalists. Cats or dogs?
- Which is more intense. Cats or Chipmunks?
« Blogospherics: Recommended reads | Main | Reduced Verbal Ability in African American Children »
Hitchens vs Souza
Category: Creationism
Posted on: December 19, 2007 4:49 PM, by Greg Laden
Find more posts in: 
Politics
Share this: Facebook Twitter Stumbleupon Reddit Email + More
TrackBacks
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://scienceblogs.com/mt/pings/58923
Comments
Hitchens really does seem to try to mess with the format here and he does seem to be really rude in this and his rudeness allows Souza to look better. Hitchen scores some good points but Souza does really come out ahead. Souza ignores Hitchen's point about how early facism was connected to Christianity, but does come out well with his comments on later dictatorships. Souza's comparison however to the Inquisition should strike anyone watching as immediately bad for one simple reason; the world population was much smaller then and humans were in many ways not as well organized.
Hitchens in general seems to be making what I would see as a critical error here that he seems to frequently miss (and PZ actually seems to get): the argument that religion causes evil isn't necessary. The argument that people are about as bad with religion as without is sufficient. It is a much easier argument to make and it has almost identical consequences.
All of that said, debating this sort of issue to a large extent at all implicitly accepts the fallacy of the appeal-to- consequences. Whether or not religion is good overall is not very relevant to whether or not some religion is correct (I say not very relevant rather than irrelevant due to a simply hypothetical- imagine if a certain religion believed that there was divine intervention to keep their true believers moral and the religion had a significant number of people and the fraction of that religion that was convicted of crimes was very tiny. Then the appeal-to-consequences isn't an appeal to consequences but a test of divine intervention).
Overall though I really think Hitchen's needs to work on his debate presentation and rhetoric.
Posted by: Joshua Zelinsky | December 19, 2007 10:55 PM