Continuing with our discussion of the Evolution 2008 conference ...
Karen Oberhauser talked about the "single species" approach to pedagogy. This involves focusing on a single species and using it throughout an entire course. Karen has taught classes on this approach for teachers' professional development programs.
The species she uses is the Monarch Butterfly.
Karen is a world class expert on this insect, and runs a major research project with them.
The idea of a single-species approach is that a student learns a great deal about one particular species, to the extent that this species becomes an organizing theme as well as a kind of living mnemonic device for all that is learned throughout the course. The individual seemingly disconnected aspects of biology and ecology can become seemingly connected by referring back to a single species. If there is something that this one species does not give you that you need to use in your class, there is almost alwasy a way to work it in.
Karen suggests taking the approach of working your way down from taxonomically more general to taxonomically more specific. By working from big picture to small picture there are a lot of opportunities to make interesting evolutionary points, with different opportunities at different levels.
At the larger scales, say, "insect," one can talk about patterns of global diversity, and generally, about phylogenetic trees.
At a somewhat smaller scale, when comparing across closely related butterflies, one can find examples of Batesian mimicry. (For the most part, most example of Batesian mimicry are probably in closely related species. Or at least, there are a lot of good examples at that level. I have no idea how many species of ants mimic spiders or visa versa ... probably a lot).
At the smallest level, of the species, one encounters such things as sexual dimorphsim and, of course, individual variation.
Of course, the classic example of "single species" pedagogy in biology is any course on human evolution. This is probably why Karen's talk went down real easy with me.
Karen went into some detail about experimental work investigating the paradox of the lek (more or less), and measuring heritability in her study specimens.
Teachers: Somewhere in your neighborhood is a University professor with a research project on a locally available species of something that you can bring into the classroom. I'm sure these folks are always happy to help. Go bug them for it!
Very incomplete list of Monarch Butterfly Resources:
Monarch Butterfly Sanctuary Foundation
Monarch Larva Monitoring Project
Monarch in the classroom
Discover Life Butterfly Page
Animal Diversity Web
Clocks and Migratory Orientation in Monarch Butterflies
Monarch Butterfly Mating Videos
More Posts on Evolution 2008
Education & Careers
Life Science
Comments
Ah, the Monarch! My 5 year old caught a Monarch catepillar, fed it milkweed until it formed a chrysalis, and was captivated as it emerged. The best part was when the butterfly climbed on his hand to dry its wings. Hmm, I have some photos that need uploading.
Posted by: Lorax | June 23, 2008 11:15 PM
According to my daughter's third or fourth grade teacher (can't remember) the monarchs that emerge too late to fly to Mexico are put in special envelopes and mailed there by the teachers.
Posted by: Greg Laden | June 23, 2008 11:38 PM