EneMan in danger?

I can understand wanting transparency regarding the gifts that pharmaceutical reps give doctors, particularly those of the more expensive variety, but this is ridiculous:

At least nine states are considering bills that would require drugmakers to publicly report how much they and their sales representatives give to doctors, hospitals and pharmacists each year. A few proposals go further: A bill under debate in Massachusetts would ban all gifts to medical professionals from the drug industry.

"If a doctor needs a Caribbean vacation or a mug or a pen, he or she is probably not very successful and needs to be in another business," says state Sen. Mark Montigny, D-Mass., who sponsored the bill.

Geez, he sure is lumping a lot together there. I'd fully agree that accepting a Caribbean vacation (or, in actuality anything costing more than maybe $20) is probably almost always questionable. I can see banning such gifts. But a freakin' pen? (Of course, the thought of politicians lecturing doctors about accepting small gifts from the pharmaceutical industry caused my irony meter to short-circuit and catch fire.)

I guess that's the end of one of the time-honored tradition that I and other doctors like to pursue at large national meetings: Trying to obtain pens and other tchtotchkes from drug rep booths without actually having to speak to the pharmaceutical reps themselves for more than a few seconds at most (or, better yet, without having to speak with them at all).

Worse, could this mean the end of my yearly EneMan calendars and Christmas decorations? That could be disastrous for this blog...

Fortunately, I think they're probably worth less than $10, certainly worth less than $20.

(Via Medpundit.)

Tags

More like this

By Lindsey Realmuto As of January 1, 2009 we can all rest assured that pharmaceutical companies may voluntarily stop barraging our physicians and nurses with free mugs, pens, and trinkets carrying drug logos. PhRMA, the pharmaceutical industry trade group, has updated their industry marketing…
By Peter Lurie, MD, MPH, Deputy Director, Public Citizenâs Health Research Group Dr. Lurie is a contributor to Public Citizenâs drug newsletter, available at www.worstpills.org. He will present testimony on state doctor gift disclosure laws before the Senate Special Committee on Aging on Wednesday…
Well, I'm home. As I've mentioned before, I attended the annual meeting of the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) in Chicago. Although one of the problems with ASCO, at least for surgeons like me, is that it is a meeting completely dominated by medical oncology. Quite frankly, not that…
With the latest Big Pharma debacle ("Hey, let's shoot ourselves in the other foot") from the Prozacasaurus' overmarketing of Zyprexa (see Grrl's, Jake's, and David's (addendum, 12/21) blog entries on the subject), this recent (and free access) article from PLoS Medicine: Educating Health…

I agree--pens & cups is clearly past the point of silly. On the other hand, anything that reins in drug companies and their sales reps above & beyond the tchotchke range seems a wise and prudent step. I have to wonder if these 9 states propose to punish doctors, or actually put some brakes on the pharmaceutical industry.

By Chris in STL (not verified) on 18 Feb 2006 #permalink

Fortunately, I think they're probably worth less than $10, certainly worth less than $20.

But surely you can't put a dollar value on the happiness that EneMan brings to all the children of the world? He's like a friggin' rectal Santa Claus. Or something.

By Sean Foley (not verified) on 18 Feb 2006 #permalink

Geez, I have mugs left over from my engineering days. I think that I have two engineering mugs and three doctor mugs. I doubt that I was influenced much in either capacity, but if they want to take away my cheesy pen supply, well then so be it.

Perhaps the best way for our beloved legislators to help us is to set a good example by accepting no money from PACs, go on no "fact-finding" tours at taxpayer expense, pay for their own health insurance, and make no pork-laden deals just to get their own legislation passed.

Perhaps the best way for our beloved legislators to help us is to set a good example by accepting no money from PACs, go on no "fact-finding" tours at taxpayer expense, pay for their own health insurance, and make no pork-laden deals just to get their own legislation passed.

They don't want the competition you give them.... :-)

They may be worth only $10, but they are priceless.

Yes, but what's it worth to actually show up on the front page blog list at Science Blogs. Woo-hoo!

By Scott Simmons (not verified) on 20 Feb 2006 #permalink

Hey, you are now linked on the front page.

By Kristjan Wager (not verified) on 20 Feb 2006 #permalink

It would be a real shame if I couldn't drink my coffee out of a mug marked "Haldol." Just seems so appropriate.