Respectful Insolence

A couple of days ago, I wrote about a particularly deceptive and idiotic article by David Kirby about the settling of a case of vaccine injury by the U.S. government. Fellow skeptical physician Steve Novella couldn’t resist taking a shot at Kirby as well and in doing so came up with one of the best lines about Kirby that I’ve ever heard in reference to Kirby’s attempt to bring AZT into the discussion:

Among stiff competition, this is perhaps the most absurd and scientifically ignorant thing Kirby has every written.

Damn. I wish I had thought of that line. However, I would say to Steve that he clearly hasn’t been reading David Kirby’s idiocy as long as I have if he thinks that’s the most absurd and scientifically ignorant thing that Kirby has ever written.

In the meantime, Left Brain Right Brain puts another nail in the coffin of the new antivaccination strategy of the mercury militia trying to link mitochondrial diseases plus vaccines as a cause of autism:

FYI…vaccines ARE recommended for children with mito! Some are advised to avoid a shot, ONLY if a history of bad reactions exists (which holds true for the general population). My friends whose children have mito ALL vaccinate their children and are mortified by people who opt to not give shots to their kids because of quack science (vaccines=autism). Those un-vaccinated children put my child and my friend’s children at risk for contracting serious diseases. Diseases that most certainly would land a child with mito in the ICU & possibly kill them.

Go here: http://www.umdf.org/site/c.dnJEKLNqFoG/b.3616911/apps/s/content.asp?ct=4211851 and read. I will also add, it is HIGHLY unlikely that a child with autism has mito, especially if that child has never been hospitalized, doesn’t have severe health issues, eats on their own, there is no muscle-wasting, vision impairment, heart defects, etc. Read more about mito at umdf.org & see how autism doesn’t equal mito, and how this case has nada to do with what Kirby is fighting for!

Moreover, mitochondrial diseases are serious diseases. As one mother put it:

Lastly, I might add, with hesitation, something about these parents who are now jumping at the bits about mitochondrial disease. Hope beyond hope that your child does NOT have it. If your child has never been hospitalized, has never had surgery, is able to walk, doesn’t need a tube in order to receive nutrition, be grateful. The injury you feel your child received–autism–from a vaccine, and I don’t mean to be rude, pales in comparison to what most families who battle mitochondrial disease have to contend with.

This new strategy by the mercury militia is far more perilous than David Kirby realizes. Maybe Steve Novella is right about this being the stupidest thing that David Kirby has ever written after all.

Comments

  1. #1 SLC
    March 3, 2008

    Dr Orac and interested readers might be interested in following a thread on a political blog containing a discussion of the subject of thimerisol in vaccines and autism. In particular, note the appearance of somebody named MaxGowan who sounds like a David Kirby sockpuppet.

    http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/03/02/AR2008030202217.html?sub=AR

  2. #2 SLC
    March 3, 2008

    From previous post, wrong link! Must be encroaching senility. This guy MaxGowan is really a piece of work.

    http://matthewyglesias.theatlantic.com/archives/2008/03/mccain_and_thimerosol.php