Respectful Insolence

It’s been a while since I’ve written about MMS. You remember MMS, don’t you? It’s an abbreviation for “miracle mineral solution,” a solution first promoted by a man who is inaptly named Jim Humble. Basically, as I’ve described in multiple blog posts, MMS is bleach, specifically chlorine dioxide (ClO2). I first became acutely aware of it a little more than a year ago, when I noticed that the antivaccine autism biomed quackfest known as Autism One featured a talk by a woman named Kerri Rivera, who advocated using MMS to “bleach autism away,” as I put it at the time. Of course, Jim Humble doesn’t limit his use of MMS to just autism, but, like all good cranks, touts it as a near universal cure-all that is good for just about anything that ails you. So what’s so bad about using it for autism?

What caught my eye (and horrified me to think about it) was that Kerri Rivera was advocating the use of MMS enemas to treat autism. Yes, Kerri Rivera advocated subjecting autistic children to bleach enemas and has made videos touting this as a biomedical treatment for autism. As I noted back then, even worse (if that were possible), Rivera advocated “fever therapy” and characterized fevers after bleach enemas to be a good thing, a sign that the treatment is “working,” much as Jim Humble gives MMS to treat adults in increasing doses until they start to feel ill. (Personally, as a physician, I would be very concerned at a child becoming febrile after having ingested bleach or had it shot up his rectum. Not Kerri Rivera, apparently.) Indeed, Rivera even exults about how much she loves “fever therapy” and how it “wakes up the immune system.” In addition to the bleach enemas, she recommends a “72-2″ protocol that involves making children drink dilute bleach every two hours for 72 hours.

If there’s one thing that Kerri Rivera appears to do that deceives parents (besides the rather obvious claim she makes that ingesting bleach or making enemas out of it will do anything but risk potential poisoning and injury to the rectum and the lining of the colon) is the claim that MMS eliminates “parasites.” Much as advocates of “colon cleanses” claim that what’s coming out represents years of accumulated waste that’s making you sick or, even more appropriately, as advocates of “liver flushes” try to convince their unwitting marks that the little lumps of saponified oil that come through the stool due to the cleanse are in actuality gallstones being “flushed” out of the liver. advocates of bleach enemas, it would appear, claim that what comes out in the stool are “parasites” and “worms.” I learned this from a particularly horrifying blog I came across a while back, thanks to a reader, known as A Drop At a Time: The CD Journey of a Child With Autism (the “CD” part stands for chlorine dioxide). It’s the story of a mother subjecting her child to MMS treatments, including both oral ingestion of MMS and MMS enemas.

The introduction sets the background. The boy’s name is Jojo, who is now nearly eleven. He was diagnosed with autism when he was three years old, and his mother has been subjecting him to “autism biomed” interventions since December 2005, beginning because, as she put it, “I decided to give it a go because my mother’s instinct told me that Jojo suffers from egregious tummy problems.”

Yes, the dreaded “mommy instinct” strikes again.

So apparently Jojo underwent a wide variety of “autism biomed” woo over the last seven or eight years, but in March 2013 the “biomed” treatment took a turn to the terrifying when Jojo’s mother discovered MMS and began to follow Kerri Rivera’s MMS protocol:

Jojo is given 1 oz of the mixture hourly, so effectively he is getting 1/8th of a drop each time. His first dose was given after school at 1 pm. He is now given 8 doses only although my reading tells me that it is a minimum. I suppose I could increase up to 9-12 doses a day but I’m kinda leery of the possible increase in die-off effects too.

As well she should have been leery, but apparently not leery enough not to undertake biomedical quackery. Even as early as day 1, she noted Jojo running a low grade fever and coughing, which, of course, could simply have been a coincidence. Similarly, she also noted JoJo to have increased hyperactivity, which could very easily have been due to confirmation bias. By day 2, Jojo continued to have fever, and his cough got worse. Somehow, his mother came to believe that “coughing after taking MMS could be due to parasites in the lung dying,” as incredible as it might be that anyone would believe something like that. Later entries describe Jojo developing constipation, and, when that resolved, his mother thinking that parasites were coming out in his stool. It is a theme that continues through the rest of the blog, as Jojo develops diarrhea, languidness, and flareups of his chronic eczema (blamed on parasites, of course).

Finally, Jojo’s mother decides that he needs to have MMS enemas after having had a text message exchange with Kerri Rivera. Jojo’s mother tells Rivera that he is constipated, and Rivera responds:

Do an enema. There is probably a worm in his intestine. And give more MMS doses orally if he is awake. More MMS now, please.

So Jojo’s mother did just that and administered the first enema on day 7.

So what happened? Well, here’s what I meant by comparing the claims of someone like Kerri Rivera to those of “liver flush” quacks. The very first example of this can be found in an entry called Worm. Here’s where the gross pictures begin. Now take a look at that link and the picture contained therein. It’s basically a stringy bit of something that looks a little bit like a worm. Jojo’s mom asked her mom buddies on the MMS Facebook group, all of whom were “pretty sure” it was a worm. It’s not. Any surgeon or doctor who deals with GI problems will recognize it as a bit of mucus, possibly with a bit of colon mucosa (the lining of the colon). We see this sort of thing all the time, and it’s definitely not a worm.

Over the month of April and into May, Jojo’s mother treats her blog to regular photos of things like this. For instance, in this post, she spreads a bunch of nasty stuff out and photographs it. Kerri Rivera, we are told, has informed her that this stuff is “worm INTESTINES. The outer skin is already digested and the inside (intestines etc) disintegrates like this.” No, it’s just more mucus mixed with colonic mucosa. Disturbingly to me as a surgeon, it looks like a fairly decent-sized chunk of colonic mucosa with mucus. I can’t say for sure how large it is because Jojo’s mom was, unfortunately, not kind enough to provide a ruler next to it. Oddly enough, the lower picture shows more mucus, and Jojo’s mother correctly labels it as such. Then, right after that, we’re treated to more pictures of mucus and sloughed colon mucosa, which Rivera characterizes once again as ” the intestines of the worm, the outer ‘skin’ having already been digested.”

Later on in the protocol, Jojo’s mother tells us:

It’s been a while since I wrote in this blog but I have been so busy. I have been poop-diving for quite a while now, started about a week before April’s Parasite Protocol. Getting to be more confident about differentiating between biofilm (translucent, clear, film-like gel), mucus (breaks up in water) and worm pieces (looks like layers of opaque tissue, when lifted with work it intertwines around itself like a rope).

Kerri says that the outer skin of the worm is usually totally digested by the time these worms are expelled and what we see, that rope-like, intertwined tissue are its intestines, the insides of the worm.

Later still, because the “worms” are still coming out, Rivera tells Jojo’s mom that she needs to treat her son not only with bleach but with Mebendazole, a drug used to treat worms, such as pinworms, roundworms, tapeworms, hookworms, and whipworms. The new protocol included:

With the parasite protocol, one will have more to keep track of:

  • Mebendazole / Combantrin
  • Diatomaceous Earth (DE) + Rompepiedras (RP)
  • Castor Oil
  • Neem

All the above are given in different combinations on different days, no real pattern to it so one has to be on the ball enough to know what is given on which days of the Parasite Protocol from Days 1 – 18. From Day 18 onwards it’s just the DE and the RP.

I have to say that I have seen a lot of worms only after starting the Parasite Protocol. So what I read about Andreas Kalcker saying that CD (read: MMS) alone will not kill the parasites and that mebendazole is required must be true. Whilst it does happen ~ parasites being killed by CD alone, best results are achieved with the Rivera CD protocol done in conjunction with the Kalcker Parasite Protocol.

Remember what I said about the liver flushes above? Basically, liver flushes involve taking Epsom salts, olive oil, and fruit juices, such as apple juice or lemon juice. As I pointed out before, these “gallstones” are nothing more than saponified oils, thanks to the acids from the juice and the salt from the Epsom salts or phosphate salts often used in these protocols. Similarly, what I suspect to be going on here is that the castor oil and neem (which is an oil as well), mixed with the diatomaceous earth, combine in much the same way that the Epsom salts, oils, and acid from the juices do in liver flushes, the difference being that, because the mixture probably doesn’t saponify in the same way. However, clearly, when enemas are added, what comes out, instead of looking like little stones, looks like the pictures we see.

Reading this blog depressed me to no end, just as reading Kent Heckenlively’s account of taking his daughter to a quack clinic in Costa Rica to have dubious “stem cells” injected into her cerebrospinal fluid through lumbar puncture. Autistic children, who should be able to look to their parents for protection, are being subjected to harmful quackery. Now, the MMS enemas are probably not quite as bad as injecting cells of dubious origin that are almost certainly not the stem cells they are advertised to be, but it’s plenty bad. On the other hand, children subjected to stem cell quackery are only usually injected once or occasionally, as it’s too expensive to do it more frequently. Jojo’s mother subjected him to bleach enemas every day, multiple times a day sometimes.

The horror boggles the mind.

Comments

  1. #1 Pris
    The Dark Side of the Force
    June 18, 2013

    This makes me sick. How can people do that to anyone, let alone their own children?

    The cognitive dissonance must be massive.

  2. #2 Renate
    June 18, 2013

    Poor poor Jojo, how can any child deserve a mother like his?
    Shouldn’t she be in jail, for child-abuse?

  3. #3 Lawrence
    June 18, 2013

    @Renate – yes, yes she should. She’s slowly liquifying her child’s intestines…..where the hell does she think these “parasites” are coming from?

    This is one of the main reasons that Quack kills – because these parents don’t have a freakin’ clue what they are doing to their children.

  4. #4 nastylittlehorse
    June 18, 2013

    This is child abuse. Shouldn’t some sort of child protection service be taking an interest here?

  5. #5 Adam
    June 18, 2013

    This really does count as abuse. I don’t understand why any developed country would allow parents to harm their children in this way regardless of whether they had a “feeling” it was doing good or not.

  6. #6 Sebastian Jackson
    June 18, 2013

    I do volunteer work for a group that tracks televangelism fraud and collaborates with investigative news programs. I sent an e-mail to my main contact in this group and asked if he could have one of these shows infiltrate the Autism One conference to watch Rivera’s talk and confront her. (I had already tipped off a couple of Chicago news stations, but they didn’t reply.) This group doesn’t normally solicit stories to the programs they work with, but they were horrified enough by MMS that they disregarded that policy and went to a certain syndicated newsmagazine with the story. The producer he knew was interested, but I never heard whether the executive producer felt the same way. I contacted them too short of notice for them to sneak into Autism One, but I definately did get Rivera onto their radar. I like to think I did what I could do.

  7. #7 Brittany
    June 18, 2013

    As a parent of a NT child, I have a question for those who might be more knowledged on the matter. It sprang into my head while reading this. (Before the disgust fully kicked in.)

    Could the “fever therapy” be attractive to parents because their child is easier to care for when they’re sick? I know that my daughter just lays about when she has a fever and we generally just park ourselves on the couch for the day and rest. If a child is generally hard to care for and a so-called “educated” person is telling them that these fevers are good, would that attract some parents to it if a fever meant an easy way to just sit back and relax and call it a treatment?

    Of course, I don’t really know and my curiosity has the best of me here. My daughter being ill scares me so much, but I have recognized that those are days when we both tend to rest a lot.

  8. #8 Chris Hickie
    June 18, 2013

    @ Renate, Lawrence, nastylittlehorse, Adam

    Definitely child abuse, just based on what is being given into the colon, but also on the picture at the top of http://jojosmmsjourney.blogspot.com/ , labeled “23 May 2013: PP2 Day 1″ there appear to be some flecks of red blood in these mucousy pieces (and you could be certain a occult heme testing would be positive as well). Ironically, there is a “report abuse” on the menu drop-down under “More” up at the top, but I suspect it is referring, more likely, to some sort of “blog abuse” and not child abuse. Reading the intro to this blog (http://jojosmmsjourney.blogspot.com/2013/03/intro.html), this “mom” is (a) not in the US, (b) has a link to Malaysia, and (c) uses the word “Mum”–so perhaps is somewhere in the UK but came/from or has strong ties to Malaysia.

    As a physician, I’ve recommended bleach baths for children with recurrent MRSA skin infections, but we’re talking not much higher concentration than hot tub chlorination levels, and definitely never for internal use. But putting an enema with bleach up a child’s rectum, as common sense should scream, cannot result in any good.

    A few years back there was an 8 month-old infant who presented to an ED here in Tucson weighing 9 lbs and severely ill. She was a home birth and had never seen a physician (until the ED) and was a victim of neglect–if not also abuse. Her amazingly neglectful parents did the authorities a favor by posting to their facebook account many pictures of their infant in the month between birth and going to the ED and helped CPS clearly show neglect (sadly I don’t know if these wretched parents were allowed to get their child back after her severe failure to thrive was corrected by physicians, nutritionists and foster parents). But I’d like to think wherever this mom is these pictures (and her detailed descriptions of what she’s done) could also be used for a neglect/abuse case.

  9. #9 Julian Frost
    Gauteng East Rand
    June 18, 2013

    @Brittany #7:

    Could the “fever therapy” be attractive to parents because their child is easier to care for when they’re sick?

    Quite possibly. Having said that, when I’m sick I make Oscar the Grouch look like a paragon of civility. Yet illness does make me want to sleep a lot, so I could be considered more docile when ill.

  10. #10 nastylittlehorse
    June 18, 2013

    @Chris –

    Yeah, it mentions autism groups in KL and that sort of stuff. If she’s malaysia based I have no idea what government body (if any) would care about it.

    Child protection in the UK, of she is here, should certainly take an interest.

  11. #11 elburto
    June 18, 2013

    Horrific. This woman needs to be tracked down, and exposed as the demented child abuser that she is.

    Enemas are horrible. The administration (by someone else) feels degrading and can make you feel so vulnerable. The sequelae can be agonising, with severe cramping, nausea, feeling flushed, and all manner of unpleasant things.

    To think of a child (especially one who may lack typical communication capabilities) having this done to him daily, makes me feel simultaneously murderous and utterly helpless, because I want to save him, but I can’t.

    She isn’t trying to “cure” JoJo. She’s punishing him.

  12. #12 elburto
    June 18, 2013

    It appears that she is in Kuala Lumpur. She has a ‘Sleepless in KL’ tag on a couple of posts, and she makes reference to Malay war songs.

    There’s a ‘KL Biomed’ (puke) Facebook page, so some detective work could probably figure out who they are. Apparently there’s a Suspected Child Abuse and Neglect team at Kuala Lumpur hospital.

    I believe action has recently been taken to make teachers responsible for flagging child abuse (mandated reporters in the US, I think) but from what I can gather from the articles I’ve seen, the results aren’t great, and UNICEF appear to be paying special attention to Malaysia.

    It was incredibly discomfitting to read that Malaysian Meddler Mum gives JoJo enemas in his lunch break. Shouldn’t he be coming home for lunch to, you know, EAT? She also mentioned that his teachers dish out his “medication” ( including bloody castor oil capsules) throughout the day, so they’re clearly in thrall to is mother.

    My thoughts are with you JoJo ‘ I wish I could help you.

  13. #13 elburto
    June 18, 2013

    One last comment for now*, and it’s a harsh warning:

    Do not play any kind of woo-spotting, biomeddling-detection drinking games while reading the following link. I love you all, and don’t want you to die from liver failure:

    thestar.com.my/health/story.asp?file=/2011/4/24/health/8513939&sec=health

    *I’m agitated by the whole thing, and my first meds of the day are due, and I haven’t had enough caffeine to slow me down, yet!

  14. #14 Stephan Brun
    June 18, 2013

    Malaysia is afaik British Commonwealth, so Britishisms like ‘mum’ might be expected, too.

  15. #15 Krebiozen
    June 18, 2013

    Though it’s rare, children have occasionally been killed by hypermagnesemia caused by Epsom salts (magnesium sulfate) enemas e.g.
    http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15759964
    I hate to think what chlorine dioxide enemas might do.

  16. #16 Dorothy
    Oz--the other one
    June 18, 2013

    My Mom used to give us enemas (soap, no bleach) if we didn’t poo for more than a day or two. I hated it and luckily, she stopped this practice as we got older (12 or so) although I’m not sure why, but perhaps we made a bigger fuss as we got older?

    My Mom was rather compulsive and had some kind of germ fear. She did use a lot of bleach for cleaning, but I guess I have to be thankful there was no internet then to further inspire her.

    At least we could protest, I cannot imagine what a non-communicative autistic child must go through.

  17. #17 Denice Walter
    June 18, 2013

    Unfortunately, obsessions/ delusions** about parasites are prevalent in woo-topia:

    TMR has had a few posts about bugs and worms- rifling through their archives of madness, I immediately found “Bugs, Moon Cycles and Lunacy” ( courtesy of Ms Poppy, June 2012), not only does she firmly believe that her child has parasites, she also believes that the parasites become more active – and the child more affected- during the full moon. Commenters agree ( Rivera pops up there).

    Recently, a PRN Talkback show featured the woo-bespoke host’s insistence that SBM doesn’t know anything about parasitical infestation in non-Third World countries- which is VERY common: these critters are under-the-radar and standard testing misses most of them. Of course, he has complicated herbal*** protocols and products to eliminate them. Obviously, *meat eaters* can pick up all sorts of horrible intestinal hitchhikers. ”
    “Go vegan”.

    Many alt med advocates link psychological and intestinal issues: perhaps in their case, it has somethig to do with those two areas being in closer proximity than is normal.

    ** and there’s always a woo-meister/ maitresse ready, willing and able to cash in on delusional thinking

    .*** Not sure if he still sells “Bug out!”

    Tierra’s “Way of Herbs” lists antiparasite herbs- including potentially harmful ones like chapparal and larkspur as well as garlic, rue, thyme, cinnamon oil and artemisia.

  18. #18 AllieP
    June 18, 2013

    Ugh, I had an enema once as a child for severe constipation. I can’t imagine getting them regularly!

    I think this is not only abuse of the child, but horrible abuse by the practitioner of the mother. I can’t imagine any woman, but especially a mom who already has so much on her plate dealing with the challenges of an autistic child, spending days upon days “poop diving.” The occasional stool sample for a pediatrician in my house is gross enough.

  19. #19 Nick Theodorakis
    June 18, 2013

    I’m not a psychiatrist, and would be reticent to diagnose over the internet in any case, but does the Jojo’s mom case sound to anyone like Münchausen syndrome by proxy?

  20. #20 Edith Prickly
    June 18, 2013

    Ugh. I had to skip over parts of the treatment descriptions above because it was upsetting me so much. One day this poor child is going to end up in the ER and a real doctor is going to have to try and repair the damage his demented mother has inflicted on him.

    I know a quack like Kerri Rivera is small fry to the regulatory bodies, but could the blog posts mentioning Rivera giving “treatment” advice be reported to some authority as evidence that she is trying to practice medicine without a license? We know the autism quacks are completely impervious to shame, and their enablers in the biomed camp are never going to publicly criticize them either – because admitting that one treatment is bogus opens up the uncomfortable possibility that all of them are.

  21. #21 Eric Lund
    June 18, 2013

    If a child is generally hard to care for and a so-called “educated” person is telling them that these fevers are good, would that attract some parents to it if a fever meant an easy way to just sit back and relax and call it a treatment?

    I think you may be on to something here. Caring for an autistic child is difficult, and may well be too much for some parents. They hear about this so-called treatment, and in their desperation they overlook the obvious signs that this would be a Bad Idea. So when the people advocating the treatment say that fever and other symptoms we normally think of as bad are actually good, these parents push onward.

    That’s assuming that the parents actually have the best of intentions, which is not always the case. Some people have a martyr complex, and there is such a thing as Munchausen by proxy.

  22. #22 Denice Walter
    June 18, 2013

    As an aside-
    I adopted a small cat ( really a giant kitten) several years ago: he immediately began producing awful-smelling liquid poo and became weak and morose-looking, not wanting to eat or do much at all- nothing subtle about it.

    A simple test revealed coccidia and liquid antibiotics helped quickly. Shouldn’t a child get as much help?

    Shouldn’t an adult be able to understand that sometimes you need a professional to test and identify the problem?
    IF any problem indeeed exists..
    These woo-besotten parents want to attribute ASDs to external sources like vaccines, meds or parasites, not accept them as being the pathway of development that their child is taking.

  23. #23 Calli Arcale
    June 18, 2013

    Brittany — possibly it’s attractive because the child is more compliant, but I think more significant is the sense of accomplishing something. A treatment is administered, a change is observed, therefore it’s working! So they keep doing it, and soon they start seeking the change that shows its working rather than worrying about the end point. It could be a little pavlovian — sort of like clicker training a dog, you train them to associate the click with a treat and praise, and fairly quickly you don’t need to do the treat and praise because the click is all it takes to make the dog feel rewarded. Even though the dog didn’t get the thing they’d actually been wanting; they come to substitute the signal for the reward.

    Combine that with the “warrior mommy” thing and it all becomes disturbingly attractive. They want to be Doing Something to help their child, because that is what warrior mommies do. Anything less is a sign of failure. So they really want to see signs of progress. This “treatment” doesn’t work, but it *does* produce symptoms that the unwary can be deluded into thinking are signs of progress. So rather than these side-effects discouraging them, it actually encourages them instead.

    My paternal grandfather was a general surgeon, but practicing in a small* town on the high prairies which meant he was often the only doctor on duty at their tiny hospital. Sometimes patients would come in and he could tell they were the “worried well”. So he’d patiently listen to them, and then prescribe a medication. He warned that it might make them sick to their stomachs, but that would just mean it was working. Well, it was a sort of a placebo, really; he was prescribing them a mild emetic, with the intention that this would make them think it was working. And they were all satisfied, so it certainly *seemed* to work. Ethical? Certainly not by modern standards. But it’s an illustration of how potent an “active placebo” can be in deluding someone (whether the patient or the caregiver) into thinking its working.

    *Well, for a certain value of “small” — what’s small to a New Yorker is downright urban to a North Dakotan in the sixties.

  24. #24 Nashira
    somewhere full of nausea and tears
    June 18, 2013

    Oh god. I read this before open of business at work and I’m still having a hard time not crying (or, um, stimming too openly) because of it. My husband has an ASD, and I have major issues with sensory overload, looking at people, and being touched by anyone not said husband.

    The idea of having this done to a child is horrifying. I keep involuntarily imagining having this happen to me as a kid, when even a hug could melt me down, and I… it feels scary and nauseating and makes me feel powerless. I wish they lived in a county with better child protection services, so Jojo could be rescued. :(

    (Also, hi elburto! I believe we knew each other on LJ, where I was kaowolfie. Chick with the migraines, trigeminal neuropathy, and a tendency to clue by four people about ableism and sexism?)

  25. #25 Brittany
    June 18, 2013

    Calli #23,

    Ugh, you’re probably right about the reinforcement. I just cannot imagine anyone thinking a fever in a child is a “wanted” thing.

  26. #26 Spectator
    June 18, 2013

    Chemical —-> Oooh, eeebil!

    Natural chemicals —–> Mmm, nature!

    Hippie logic ====> Where reality goes to die.

  27. #27 Renate
    June 18, 2013

    @ Elburto
    Is that a newspaper-article, or an advertisement for some group, that is so deep into woo, that I don’t understand it?
    “Parents seeking effective treatments”? I don’t think anything on that list is effective and some of those sound a bit dangerous. I don’t see MMS listed, but every other woo in the book is.

  28. #28 Krebiozen
    June 18, 2013

    Some years ago a (real medical) parasitologist told me about the “worms” people brought to him, that they had found in their feces, all of which turned out to be bits of undigested food. He also told me that a patient once brought him some actual worms. They had been given them by their colonic irrigation therapist, who had told them these worms had washed out of their colon. On examination he found they were the type of worms you can buy to feed tropical fish, and that could not possibly survive in a human GI tract. I don’t know how common this practice is, but it does seem a good way of keeping the marks happy.

  29. #29 elburto
    June 18, 2013

    Air hugs for Nashira. I hope you’re feeling better now.

    I’m not ashamed to admit that I cried, and I almost vomited thinking about that poor kid. It’s left me feeling distinctly anxious and triggered, especially coming so soon after the Alex Spourdalakis case.

    In my former job I’ve made child protection referrals for so much less, and not being able to help is so frustrating.

  30. #30 The Smith of Lie
    June 18, 2013

    When, for once, a dash of homeopathy would be a positive thing – homeopathic bleach is infinitely preferable to higher concentrations of it – the quack is not signed up for this One Woo…

  31. #31 The Smith of Lie
    June 18, 2013

    Sorry for double post, I was catching up when this gem caught my attention.

    Obviously, *meat eaters* can pick up all sorts of horrible intestinal hitchhikers. ”
    “Go vegan”.

    So we have the assertation – eating meat gives you parasites, eating plants does not.

    But wait a minute! The animals we eat are of the herbivore variety, id est they eat plants. The same plants that are not considered a risk factor in catching a parasite.

    Wherefore come the parasites in the meat of those herbivores than?

  32. #32 Sullivanthepoop
    June 18, 2013

    The really ridiculous thing is that getting a parasitic infection in the US is so rare these days that our children will likely never have one in their lives if they stay here and things continue as they are. Why worry about something like that?

  33. #33 janet
    in a pasture somewhere
    June 18, 2013

    @ Smith of Lie
    Most of the parasites that our meat animals can be infected with have incredibly complex life cycles (that fortunately I’m not required to know anymore.) Sometimes (often) there is a larval form that lives in the soil (or in other inhabitants of soil) that can be ingested during grazing. Or it’s as simple as having a parasite egg-containing pasture. And there you have it–intestinal parasites. Veganism doesn’t protect you from gastrointestinal disease–just ask anybody who’s had salmonellosis from some unwashed lettuce or sprouts.

  34. #34 kruuth
    June 18, 2013

    God this is sad. The defense these parents use is also very disconcerting to me. I still don’t understand the whole “gut flora” issue people keep bringing up, especially since old Andy’s been discredited.

    On a side note, does anyone else find the mms home page a little weird? Why is he standing there with a tiger?

  35. #35 The Smith of Lie
    June 18, 2013

    @Janet

    Yeah, I am pretty aware of that. I lack the vocabulary to describe the parasite I am thinking about, but I remember learning about ones most often contracted by eating unwashed veggies. I was just pointing out the wholes in the supposition that meat eaters are just asking to get infested up to the nose with parasites while vegans are immune to that (aside from other superpowers they boast, at least as long as they stay on the good side of Vegan Police).

  36. #36 Mark Thorson
    June 18, 2013

    No, no, no! Parasites are secondary to toxins! You’ve got to get rid of the toxins first, otherwise the parasites will keep coming back. The most powerful detoxifier is asparagus. The toxins come out in the urine, and boy do they stink! You’ve got to keep eating asparagus until all of the toxins come out. This could take a long time. I’ve been detoxifying for 5 years, and they’re still coming out.

  37. #37 Todd W.
    http://www.harpocratesspeaks.com
    June 18, 2013

    @elburto and Nashira

    This may help.

  38. #38 Todd W.
    June 18, 2013

    Gah. Broken link. Let’s try that again.

  39. #39 Calli Arcale
    June 18, 2013

    Mark — a good start, but you really need to be chelating naturally. Oxalic acid is a chelator, so I recommend strawberry-rhubarb pie with every meal. No exceptions. ;-)

  40. #40 Chris Hickie
    June 18, 2013

    @ #28, Krebiozen-

    As a resident I saw a toddler in the ER who had a “worm in her butt” (that was the exact chief complaint). When I looked, it did resemble a rather large, red translucent worm. I gloved, pulled it out (it was an in out with another 2-3 inches inside but came out easily). It reminded me of an artificial worm used in fishing. I asked the parents if she’d gotten into a tackle box and they said she hadn’t but she had eaten a large amount of gummy worms the day prior–so I’m guessing if she swallowed some, at least one made it through relatively undigested. The worm was clear on cross sectioning (grossly-this wasn’t anything like needing to look a GMO fed piglet tummies), and I did consider sending it to pathology for a laugh. I did not, however, taste it to prove it was a gummy worm (ugh).

  41. #41 lilady
    June 18, 2013

    It is child abuse…pure and simple. This utterly vile creature has been *treating* her autistic child for 8 years, with gawd knows what other invasive, painful *biomedical treatment protocols*, because she views her child as being a dirty infected/infested being.

    If she does reside in Malaysia and her child’s “therapist” at school is dosing JoJo with castor bean pills…it speak volumes about the non-existent safeguards in place, to protect little kids from their abusers.

  42. #42 AdamG
    June 18, 2013

    Somewhat OT, but have you all seen this article yet?

    http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2013/06/18/book-raises-alarms-about-alternative-medicine/2429385/

    Surprisingly reasonable, although there’s a slight hint of false balance. The comments, as usual, are a cesspool.

  43. #43 elburto
    June 18, 2013

    @lilady – Yeah,UNICEF voiced concerns about how seriously Malaysian teachers will take their reporting duties. Poor JoJo.

    @Todd – fabulous, thanks! Puppies, sloths, kittens, the whole shebang. A guaranteed cheerer-upper.

    @Chris Hickle – Before our elderly dad (my father in law) died he was obsessed with his um… evacuations. For some reason he was convinced he had, or would get, stomach cancer.

    Tummy ache after eating a pound of Cheshire cheese? Cancer!

    Diarrhoea after downing litres of milk? Cancer!

    The high point was the shrieking call, 5am when we’d been asleep for an hour with all of our lovely medications kicking in and taking us to dreamland. Picture it, strident ringtone (yeah, Doctor Who theme), then howls of “IT’S BLACK OMG IT’S BLACK, THIS IS IT, I’M FINISHED!”

    It took twenty minutes to convince him that the cramps and black stools were. the result of him eating the half birthday cake we’d left him in one sitting. Half of Other Mrs elburto’s cake, a Tardis cake that was covered in blue royal icing. The cramps? Well who would get mere crampy, after wolfing down more than a kilo of birthday cake and blue icing, than a 75 year old man with diverticular disease?

    He found ‘worms’ too (grape skins), ‘blood’ in his urine and faeces (he’d eaten a jar of pickled beetroot, the results terrified him!), ‘blood clots’ (cherries, and all manner of delights. We miss him, but not the middle of the night calls to get to the hospital because he’d had a ‘heart attack’* after a weird bowel movement, and thought he’d die of cancer. Poor old thing. He never got cancer yet, and died at 77.

    *Usually a panic attack which then triggered his AF, and required three days of attempted cardioversion by any means possible.

  44. #44 Speak21
    June 18, 2013

    Re: gut flora, studying the human microbiome (not only gut but all the interesting little groups of beasties that live in or on us) is a hot area of basic science at the moment, and there is early evidence to suggest that they can play a role in many normal biological processes and potentially pathologies as well, including some intriguing hints on a role in emotion regulation. However, the difference is that the researchers in the field know it is actually very complex and we are still at the earliest stages of understanding it, nowhere near being able to tell how (or whether) an individuals microbiome could or should be manipulated to improve health. And I am pretty sure that not one of them would recommend bleach as a therapeutic strategy!
    That poor child – it breaks my heart a little to think he is, in essence, being tortured by the one who he should be able to trust most will protect him.

  45. #45 janet
    June 18, 2013

    @ elburto
    Thanks for the laugh–I had to clean off the keyboard very quickly since I had a mouthful of water! Reminds me of my Dad who died a few months ago, in his sleep, at age 80. Ye gods and little fishes, could that man complain!

  46. #46 kruuth
    June 18, 2013

    Anyone seen this crap yet:

    http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-06-18/autism-tied-to-air-pollution-brain-wiring-disconnection.html

    Please tell me this has been debunked already.

  47. #47 kruuth
    June 18, 2013

    Oh, from the abstract:


    We estimated associations between U.S. Environmental Protection Agency modeled levels of hazardous air pollutants at the time and place of birth and ASD in the children of participants in the Nurses’ Health Study II (325 cases, 22,101 controls). Our analyses focused on pollutants associated with ASD in prior research. We accounted for possible confounding and ascertainment bias by adjusting for family-level socioeconomic status (maternal grandparents’ education) and census-tract-level socioeconomic measures (e.g., tract median income and percent college educated), as well as maternal age at birth and year of birth. We also examined possible differences in the relationship between ASD and pollutant exposures by child’s sex.

    So basically they guessed….classy.

  48. #48 Denice Walter
    June 18, 2013

    @ AdamG:

    Dr Offit’s recent book, the excerpt @ The Guardian and his NYT commentary have already been taken down briefly by Gary Null ( Friday’s show, PRN/ 17 minutes in) – more is forthcoming I’m told..
    Promises, promises.

    Basically, he argues that Dr O is an ignorant pharma shill, the studies he cites are garbage and supplements are purity and the divine life force coalesced into conveniently-sized, easy to swallow tablets/ capsules.

    Oh, and there’s a paradigm shift of tsunamic strength about to engulf SBM and wash it clean..

  49. #49 Narad
    June 18, 2013

    Oxalic acid is a chelator, so I recommend strawberry-rhubarb pie with every meal. No exceptions.

    Is potage germiny mandatory as a starter?

  50. #50 Rumtopf
    June 18, 2013

    I saw this linked in the Alex thread, ugh it makes me sick.
    On the rare occasion that my brother or I got threadworms as kids, all we had to go through was taking a chalky, orange flavoured pill from the chemists(the whole family did), with a repeat dose a week or so later, and everything was completely sorted. Seriously, what the hell? If it’s taking months or years to treat supposed parasites, it’s not working!
    Of course, the sick thing is that the quack who sells this “treatment” knows very well what the results, the stripping of the colon lining, looks like and uses it to fearmonger and string these parents along into injuring their children even more, like a vicious cycle. Ugghh*vomit*

  51. #51 Sebastian Jackson
    June 18, 2013

    @kruuth: I know some people tried to link autism to coal-fired emissions, but I think that has been debunked.

  52. #52 AllieP
    June 18, 2013

    Kruuth @#34, I think part of the drumbeat for ‘gut flora’ is that it’s a popular subject even in mainstream circles now, with patients being advised by doctors to keep up consumption of yogurt, etc. during antibiotics courses. Like a lot of woo, it’s a good idea (diet, stress reduction, cleanliness) taken to a ridiculous extreme.

  53. #53 kruuth
    June 18, 2013

    The whole yogurt thing is a load of crap. It’s just an urban legend that was never really proven. I had cancer sores for years and the only thing my mother ever did was tell me to “eat yogurt” all the while I was in agony. Never gave a damb to take me to a real doctor about it. 20 years later I’m in my oral surgeon’s office and he sees one of these monstrosities in my mouth, gives me chlorhexidine and they almost stop completely. I get a few flare-ups but nothing like before.

    I still haven’t forgiven ma for that.

  54. #54 herr doktor bimler
    June 18, 2013

    children have occasionally been killed by hypermagnesemia caused by Epsom salts (magnesium sulfate) enemas

    Showing once again that for any really stupid way of killing a child, there is a parent somewhere who will find it.

    does the Jojo’s mom case sound to anyone like Münchausen syndrome by proxy?

    Rivera’s entire operation is basically Munchausen-by-proxy-by-proxy.

    Half of Other Mrs elburto’s cake, a Tardis cake that was covered in blue royal icing

    Why does that not surprise me?

  55. #55 Narad
    June 18, 2013

    Surprisingly reasonable, although there’s a slight hint of false balance.

    “In the letter, Burzynski wrote that, ‘based on the results of the phase 2 trials, the FDA has granted permission to proceed into two Phase 3 clinical trials in brain tumors.'”

  56. #56 lilady
    June 18, 2013

    @ Adam G. I must be “missing” the spot to comment on that USA Today link you provided about Dr. Offit’s book. Could you provide it?

  57. #57 Calli Arcale
    June 18, 2013

    Narad:

    Is potage germiny mandatory as a starter?

    Well, for the fruit-reluctant, potage germiny could be an alternative to the strawberry rhubarb pie. Though heaven knows there’s nothing better than rhubarb and strawberry. ;-) (Except maybe if you add chocolate.)

    My husband is one of those who loathes cilantro, so I have found a couple of substitutes. One is lemon thyme. The other is wood sorrel, which grows in abundance around here, even if you don’t want it to. It’s a bit like dandelions in that regard. Though I don’t think it’s at all related to sheep sorrel, it also gets its tart flavor from oxalic acid, and is very tasty.

  58. #58 elburto
    June 18, 2013

    @kruuth- I feel your pain, literally. Not only on the mouth ulcers, but the mother. Mine “trained” as a homeopath. Any symptom (other than asthma attacks) was met with a proffered sugar pill, or a muttered “Buck up kid”.

    I’m glad you discovered the miracle of swilling chlorhexidine around your mouth! I adore pharmaceuticals in their many and varied forms, especially those which zap pain. They certainly beat having a manky sugar pill shoved under my tongue

  59. #59 kruuth
    June 18, 2013

    Thanks elburto. My mom can’t understand why I’m so curt with her on so many health things and then I remind her of the hell I went through with her bs diagnoses and yogurt to cure everything. I would go weeks where I couldn’t eat anything because of that and she’d just laugh and claim it was a “swollen taste bud” and I just needed some yogurt. I can’t even count how many times I lost weeks of school for getting sick from something she deemed wasn’t that important. She sent me to school with strep more than once.

  60. #60 elburto
    June 18, 2013

    @hdb – We are almoSt painfully geeky. For her 40th birthday my friends made her a chocolate Dalek cake. Our entire belief system is essentially “If you’re going to be weird, be really weird”. Luckily for us our friends aren’t exactly paragons of normality either!

    @Calli – our garden is loaded with rhubarb, giant rhubarb. We sometimes get three foot long stalks. Unfortunately neither of us can eat it, I mean we can, but the side-effects are catastrophic, I’m sure I don’t have to elaborate!

  61. #61 Trends
    June 18, 2013

    A few years ago, the Age of Autism folks were very upset about a mother who killed her child with bleach, but now that bleach treatment is part of the antivaccine memespace, it is vgorously defended. How long before current tragedies are transmuted into novel treatments that are flogged at antivax festivals, and defended just as strongly? Might MMS be replaced with MSS (miracle stabbing solution (how dare you show your ignorance by noticing that MMS is bleach, or that MSS is a knife!)?

  62. #62 Mephistopheles O'Brien
    June 18, 2013

    elburto – send the rhubarb my way.

  63. #63 Mephistopheles O'Brien
    June 18, 2013

    I’ve said it before, but I think it bears repeating for tone….

    I’ve drunk bleach in reasonable dilution. Sodium hypochlorite bleach works fine to sanitize drinking water if you dilute it to a safe concentration. This is useful in some circumstances when camping or otherwise out in the wilds. The problem with MMS is not just that people are making their children drink bleach (or giving them enemas with it) – it’s that the bleach doesn’t do what they say it does.

    If there were good evidence that chlorine dioxide mixed with a weak acid and used as an enema actually did something useful, I’d be in favor of it. As there isn’t and it appears it tears up the intestines, that’s abuse.

  64. #64 Peebs
    Once again back in the clouded part of my mind called memory.
    June 18, 2013

    I’ve known about the idiocy that is MMS for a couple of years and I still look upon the imbeciles who use it with incredulity. But the talk of intestinal worms got my reminiscence gland secreting vague memory hormones.

    It’s a long time since I’ve mentioned my training in the RN but the mention of anthelmintics reminded me of one treatment which was taught (but never to my knowledge, prescribed);

    Male Fern Extract.

    Anyone else heard of it?

    Apologies for the slight off topic detour.

  65. #65 Carolyn
    Reality
    June 18, 2013

    Dr. Offit was on the CBS Morning News: http://www.cbsnews.com/video/watch/?id=50149140n

    OT, I had pinworms as a kid 60+ years ago, and I remember taking pills that made your mouth purple if you didn’t swallow them quickly. We were living in Alaska in a house without running water. I assume that had a lot to do with it.

  66. #66 Sebastian Jackson
    June 18, 2013

    @Trends: When Kerri Rivera first appeared at Autism One a year ago, Julie Obradovic defended her on AoA. She was forced to furiously packpedal when she was called out on it by a “HuffPo” (!) contributor. This year, AoA completely ignored Rivera, probably because they knew discussing her would arouse negative publicity for Autism One and themselves.

  67. #67 Dangerous Bacon
    June 18, 2013

    Chris Hickie (#40): “The worm was clear on cross sectioning (grossly-this wasn’t anything like needing to look a GMO fed piglet tummies), and I did consider sending it to pathology for a laugh.”

    Well, a gummy worm would be better than some of the foreign objects that docs fish out of various orifices and bodily organs and send us in Pathology. My favorite was the steel girder that a construction worker impaled himself on after falling from a great height (as I recall, he was fine after they extracted it from him, or vice versa).

  68. #68 herr doktor bimler
    June 18, 2013

    “Oh, gird your loins. I could have sworn you said ‘girder’.”

  69. #69 Lara Lohne
    June 18, 2013

    I went to that blog after Liz Ditz posted the link a couple days ago in a previous post here. I tried to read it but I just couldn’t continue. The arrogance and ignorance of that woman and what she is inflicting on her son! And then boasting about her torture online for all the world to see? Why is Child Protective Services not beating down her door and removing him from her ‘care’ immediately? What state and county does she live in? I’ll call them and make a report and give them the link for them to read for themselves that she’s systematically giving her son a chemical colectomy. She has self diagnosed him with something she imagines is true and really she’s just dissolving his colon. This makes me truly sick and ache with pain for the children subjected to this by their ‘parents’.

  70. #70 Bonnie
    June 18, 2013

    I have an almost completely off-topic question, but don’t know where else to ask. I have just been told that amber teething necklaces “work” because they produce succinic acid when the beads rest against the skin. As far as I can tell from Wikipedia, what the mother probably means is spirit of amber – butanedioic acid – which used to be used topically for rheumatism.

    I’m pretty sure I know the answer to my question, but you are educated, which I am not. My question is: would either butanedioc acid or succinic acid be produced by resting amber to the skin & would either be able to ease teething pain? Is there someplace on-line I can reference (besides here) when I give her my reply?

    I truely appreciate any help you can give me – and thanks so much for the free education I’m getting! :)

  71. #71 Thomas
    June 18, 2013

    Bonnie: This article http://autismum.com/2012/10/29/amber-teething-necklaces/ has some of the information you want

  72. #72 Bonnie
    June 18, 2013

    :( Self teaching is hard! I reread the wiki article & I think the two acids are the same thing.

  73. #73 Narad
    June 18, 2013

    Is there someplace on-line I can reference (besides here) when I give her my reply?

    This seems like a reasonable summary at first glance.

  74. #74 Denice Walter
    June 18, 2013

    @ Bonnie:

    Amber appeals to those who believe in the power of the natural world and the wisdom of the ancients:
    going back to the Romans, it was coveted as protection against evil and witches and as a healing substance; later European folklore involved making tinctures from amber.
    TONS of lit on amber.

    In other words- woo- but it can also be nice worn as a necklace FOR AN ADULT who won’t eat it.

  75. #75 Narad
    June 18, 2013

    Amber appeals to those who believe in the power of the natural world and the wisdom of the ancients

    A quick scan of the MDC forums quickly reveals that a good number of even this self-selected population thinks amber teething trinkets are a load of crap.

  76. #76 Chemmomo
    Please note the beginning of my screen name
    June 18, 2013

    Bonnie

    I think the two acids are the same thing.

    You are correct. They are the same compound. Succinic acid is the older, “common” name. Butanedioic acid is the systematic name – the one assigned by the folks who set standards for things like completely unambiguous names for chemical compounds (the International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry). The “but-“ means 4 carbon atoms, “-ane-” in the middle means each carbon in the center has 2 hydrogen atoms attached to it, and “-di-“ before the acid part of the name means there are two of those (one at each end).

    Food for thought: the skin is an organ designed to keep things out of your body. There aren’t that many substances which are effective via topical application.

  77. #77 Bonnie
    June 18, 2013

    Thank you all SO much! It may not convince the mom – she’s a true believer – but hopefully it will alert her to the strangulation/choking hazards.

    It’s amazingly difficult to explain placebos to people. I even know a vet who uses homepathy & accupunture on animals – he says it works. Those poor animals! :(

  78. #78 Calli Arcale
    June 18, 2013

    The thought that always goes through my mind when I think of amber teething things is that amber is not the most structurally sound of substances; wouldn’t there be a risk of it shattering in a child’s mouth? I don’t know how sharp the bits would get, but it really just doesn’t seem like my first choice. Oh, and a lot of the necklaces are rather small beads (since big pieces of amber can get a bit spendy for a teether). So “choking hazard” was my first thought with these.

  79. #79 lilady
    June 18, 2013

    Autismum’s “friend” Martine at Skeptoid also wrote about amber teething beads and the choking hazard. Her second blog with links to her first blog is here. That Martine O’Callahan is just as feisty as Austismum, when it comes to child advocacy and safety. :-)

    http://skeptoid.com/blog/2012/12/31/amber-for-teething-update/#comments

    My daughter, when she was a few days before entering kindergarden, managed to swallow a penny. (She had “never” put a teething toy or any other toy in her mouth, before). She was hoarse and just to be cautious (toddlers manage to completely swallow quarters), we took her to the E.R. We were assured by the doctor that the coin was in her stomach, but the penny was lodged in her esophagus, according to x-ray. She was sedated and the doctor tried to extract it, but couldn’t because she was a very petite little girl and the esophagus was swollen from the irritation. After an overnight stay in the hospital under mild sedation, a repeat x-ray located the penny at the juncture of the stomach and small intestine.

    Yeah, I had to “retrieve” the penny.

  80. #80 THS
    June 18, 2013

    I railed about the amber teething things – in particular, necklaces – in a previous thread here sometime ago – but I never did write Harriet Hall et al. at SBM to try to alert more people (American Academy of Pediatrics, etc?) to this woo-fad. There is some other commentary on the net – autismum had an excellent post on this, as did Jean Mercer. Dig it – parents wrap their babies’ necks in choker necklaces. The rationale ranges from nonsense “biochemistry” (succinic acid) to complete woo of magnets & amber & folk wisdom. My stepson’s wife is an associate professor of early child education and she does this amber crap – it’s a crunchy-yuppie-hip fad. The amber necklace on the baby is a placebo for the parents. I think it’s a strangulation hazard.
    I’ve mentioned this to a few docs I know & they’ve not encountered it. But it’s an established & growing fad.

  81. #81 lilady
    June 18, 2013

    @ Kruuth: I saw that study and other studies about exposures to traffic fumes, while living close to major highways, and exposures to herbicides and pesticides, increasing the risk for fetuses to be later diagnosed with ASDs. I’m not extremely impressed with those studies.

  82. #82 Alain
    June 19, 2013

    Offtopic: a new blog post with an advices for bookworm like me:

    http://www.securivm.ca/2013/06/amazon-you-sometime-amaze-me.html

    Alain

  83. #83 Shay
    the state PHEP conference
    June 19, 2013

    Veganism doesn’t protect you from gastrointestinal disease

    No kidding. The last FBI outbreak I read about was traced to a frozen “organic” berry mix.

    kruuth, my mother was a yogurt-for-canker-sores zealot as well. I wonder where that particular bit of folk wisdom originated.

  84. #84 Alain
    June 19, 2013
  85. #85 Guy Chapman
    June 19, 2013

    Amazon sells a number of books advocating MMS, and a number of products which reference MMS while pretending to be something else.

    http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_sb_noss?url=search-alias%3Daps&field-keywords=MMS

  86. #86 Chris,
    June 19, 2013

    Bonnie, here is something even better than amber necklaces for teething:
    frozen bits of terry cloth

    Take cheap terry fabric washcloths, get them wet, then put them in the freezer. When a teething baby fusses, give them one straight from the freezer. The cold numbs the gum a bit, and the rough terry cloth helps make the teeth break through the gums.

    Make sure you have a few in reserve. The fabric is thin, so it thaws quickly.

    Unfortunately it is not perfect. One child preferred to “teeth” on the breast. This one child took the longest to wean. Even as a college student she is still quite annoying, she refuses to take calculus. On the plus side she is the most reliable with finances. Go figure.

  87. #87 AdamG
    June 19, 2013

    The thought that always goes through my mind when I think of amber teething things is that amber is not the most structurally sound of substances; wouldn’t there be a risk of it shattering in a child’s mouth?

    Oddly enough, there seems to have been an attempt to study this (or rather, study if parents know this):

    http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=22925538

    It’s in French so I can only interpret what Google Translate’s giving me, but it seems the parents they interviewed didn’t care at all about the choking risks.

  88. #88 elburto
    June 19, 2013

    @Chris and Bonnie – a few people I know swear by mesh feeders filled with frozen fruit or vegetables.

    Apparently, one of the babies in question will lay on the “OMG what is this? I’m dyyying mammy!” routine, until she is offered some frozen fruit or veg. Howling, flailing, eye-rubbing, and fist-gnawing that stops within. a millisecond of the stuff appearing. Peas, chunks of banana or apple, chunks of carrot, and the most hilarious (to me) – broccoli florets.

    That’s one way to get kids to eat veg I suppose, as something they associate with feeling better. Well that, or making vegetables verboten!

    http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B000GK5XY2/

  89. #89 Chris,
    June 19, 2013

    Elburto, remember we must introduce food sequentially, just to make sure their tummies are ready. The under one year age teething bit is before most of this happens. I don’t think it is a coincidence.

    It would be interesting to make a rice cereal popsicle. Though I suspect that frozen fruit and veg would be fun. Something like frozen apple, pear or even green beans. Though they do no have the abrasive qualities of a terry cloth bit of fabric.

  90. #90 herr doktor bimler
    June 19, 2013

    Peas, chunks of banana or apple, chunks of carrot, and the most hilarious (to me) – broccoli florets.

    No batter? No deep-frying? Madness!

  91. #91 kruuth
    June 19, 2013

    Has anyone tracked this woman down and called protective services?

  92. #92 Krebiozen
    June 19, 2013

    Amber teething beads also carry the risk of the child ingesting small amounts of dinosaur DNA. If traces of HPV DNA can kill, who knows what dinosaur DNA might do? ;-)

  93. #93 Krebiozen
    June 19, 2013

    Chris Hickie,

    The worm was clear on cross sectioning (grossly-this wasn’t anything like needing to look a GMO fed piglet tummies), and I did consider sending it to pathology for a laugh.

    OT, but some years ago I was working in clinical biochemistry in my favorite ‘special functions’ section, which did all the odd tests that didn’t fit in anywhere else, including renal calculi analysis, which I especially loved – grinding things up in a pestle and mortar and doing chemical tests on them made me feel like a medieval alchemist.

    One day I received a small stone that a patient had passed. The first step was to measure it and describe its appearance. It was at this point I realized that the ‘stone’ looked remarkably like a Rice Krispie. Further investigation, including a starch test, definitively confirmed my hypothesis. Sadly my boss censored the biting comment I put on the report.

    I don’t think this was a joke, I suspect that someone had dropped the stone and picked up the Rice Krispie instead by mistake.

    I did not, however, taste it to prove it was a gummy worm (ugh).

    Thankfully Benedict’s solution replaced the old test for diabetes mellitus (and insipidus) before I started working in pathology.

  94. #94 Krebiozen
    June 19, 2013

    elburto,

    It took twenty minutes to convince him that the cramps and black stools were. the result of him eating the half birthday cake we’d left him in one sitting.

    I used to volunteer to help out in the welfare tent at hippie festivals, which involved looking after lost children (and parents), giving minor first aid, talking down people having bad trips etc., which was often a lot of fun. On one occasion someone managed to blag us our own Turdis (chemical toilet), to avoid us having to use the public ones or the compost toilets.

    Taking a leak in the said Turdis I noticed what looked like a huge amount of fresh blood, as if someone had just had a massive gut bleed. Realizing that if I was right, the person responsible required urgent medical attention, I returned to the tent and asked the assorted waifs and stray, and other volunteers, who had last used the Turdis as I was concerned they needed to see a doctor. Eventually a young woman sheepishly explained that she had eaten a very large amount of beetroot earlier that day.

    It was a little embarrassing, not for me, as poking about in other people’s poo is part of my job, but to her. I was relieved that was all it was, but I was later given a dressing down by one of the volunteer organizers, who told me I had behaved in a very unprofessional manner, embarrassing the poor woman like that. I asked her if it would be better for someone to bleed to death or face some minor embarrassment, for which she had no answer.

  95. #95 Passerby
    June 19, 2013

    @elburto
    Enemas are horrible. The administration (by someone else) feels degrading and can make you feel so vulnerable. The sequelae can be agonising, with severe cramping, nausea, feeling flushed, and all manner of unpleasant things.
    -snip-

    While I completely, completely agree with you about what that woman is doing being horrible, and about her likely motivations (I think a lot more of these autism ‘treatments’ are punishments than anyone wants to admit), I do take a bit of an issue with your characterization of enemas as universally horrible things. I don’t think any kid should be subjected to regular, let alone daily, ones without a sound medical necessity, these aren’t horrible to everyone, and whoever’s administering it really shouldn’t make you feel degraded, (Though I admit, that’s probably hard to avoid when you’re talking about a child who doesn’t to take their medicine, so to speak. I utterly, utterly despised taking suppositories as a child, but frankly the meds I needed weren’t available orally, and it maybe saved my life. But I digress.)

    I’m just struck by remembering that when we covered klismaphilia in school, the textbooks were pretty explicit that most klismaphilia had its’ roots in regular enemas administered during childhood, and how the person associated the sensation of being loved and cared for with the enema. It was highlighted as one of the few paraphilias that we actually know how it develops. I can’t see how this would be the case if childhood enemas were routinely horrible things.

    tl;dr: I agree this woman is horribly abusing that poor kid, but we shouldn’t conflate enema-as-punishment with enema-as-beneficial-treatment

  96. #96 MIRose
    June 19, 2013

    Even more OT, do moms who want all natural to prevent allergies know that the natural rubber teethers they give their babies are made from latex?

  97. #97 Bronze Dog
    June 19, 2013

    Yes, the dreaded “mommy instinct” strikes again.

    That’s one thing that irritated me since I started arguing with anti-vaxxers and autism quack followers: The deification of parents. Most of my life, it’s been a relatively subtle meme. Only a foo doesn’t respect his mama. Then it came into focus when trolls expected me to take a parent’s memory as if it were as objective as a camera’s recording. Some people have good parental instincts and intuition, but those things are not a substitute for medical or psychological knowledge, nor do they immunize parents against cognitive biases or bad memory.

    It’s in French so I can only interpret what Google Translate’s giving me, but it seems the parents they interviewed didn’t care at all about the choking risks.

    Along with the horrors of the main post, it’s parents like that who scare me. And they’re much more common. I’m not a parent, but I know that infants are especially vulnerable to things like that. It reminds me of a version of “sharks at the beach” issue of human estimation of risk: Which is more dangerous to an infant? A teddy bear with button eyes or a real bear? One encounter with a real bear would be deadly, but pretty unlikely to happen with most people. The teddy bear’s button eyes, however, are a choking hazard and the infant is going to be around the teddy bear on a much more regular basis. There’s a reason why so many toys have those warning labels.

  98. #98 Lawrence
    June 19, 2013

    @Bronze Dog – as there are whole sections of my childhood that I either don’t remember or through the haze of time, don’t know events actually occurred, I don’t trust memories very much any more…..at least not as some concrete timeline of fairly subtle events.

  99. #99 Edith Prickly
    June 19, 2013

    Then it came into focus when trolls expected me to take a parent’s memory as if it were as objective as a camera’s recording. Some people have good parental instincts and intuition, but those things are not a substitute for medical or psychological knowledge, nor do they immunize parents against cognitive biases or bad memory.

    My memories of Son of Prickly’s infant/toddler years are mostly a blur now, and he’s only six. I recall the few episodes when he was seriously ill, but what happened before and after? Pfft! That’s why doctors keep medical records. Parental recall cannot be trusted, and I say that as a parent.

  100. #100 Andreas Johansson
    June 19, 2013

    the woo-bespoke host’s insistence that SBM doesn’t know anything about parasitical infestation in non-Third World countries

    Because it makes perfect sense that mainstream doctors and big pharma – well known for their aversion to money – would concentrate on providing for the bits of the world were patients are generally poor.

    Also, why’s this nonsense called “biomed”? There’s nothing particularly biological about bleach, is there?

  101. #101 Sebastian Jackson
    June 19, 2013

    @Kruuth [#91]: Some clues point to the woman living in Malaysia. I don’t know what authorities could bust in on her.

  102. #102 woot
    woot
    June 19, 2013

    You guys are an utter disgrace to intelligence. MMS has never ever killed anyone – and Rivera has so far recovered over 93 children COMPLETELY of their autism symptoms.

    Here is a video testimonial showing a kid and his mom that used Riveras method, which also involves pharmaceuticals like Mebendazole, not just MMS. Diet is also a huge part of her protocol.

    http://mmsautism.org/index.php/Menu/miraculous-video-testimonies.html

  103. #103 Jay Gordon, MD, FAAP
    June 19, 2013

    @elburto

    “@Chris and Bonnie – a few people I know swear by mesh feeders filled with frozen fruit or vegetables”
    http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B000GK5XY2/

    That’s exactly what I recommend over age five months or so. Safe, tasty and easy.
    Amber necklaces give me pause because I can’t imagine how they might help and I worry about foreign body ingestion. I really dislike necklaces of any kind around babies’ and toddlers’ necks.

    @Chris: I also like frozen wash clothes for teething babies. Add a little breast milk to make them taste familiar. Works better than whatever amber might do.

  104. #104 Mephistopheles O'Brien
    June 19, 2013

    woot – if you have any valid studies that show that MMS provides significant benefit for some medical condition, please share. From what’s been discussed above and in previous discussions on this site, it sounds like it tears up the digestive tract for no good purpose.

    Has Rivera published the results of her efforts including the healing protocol and success rates?

  105. #105 Mephistopheles O'Brien
    June 19, 2013

    Dr Gordon – those sound like great recommendations. A frozen washcloth sounds very old fashioned, yet effective.

  106. #106 Edith Prickly
    June 19, 2013

    Here is a video testimonial showing a kid and his mom that used Riveras method, which also involves pharmaceuticals like Mebendazole, not just MMS. Diet is also a huge part of her protocol.

    http://mmsautism.org/index.php/Menu/miraculous-video-testimonies.html

    And what do I find on the site’s home page? A big ol’ Quack Miranda warning:

    Medical Disclaimer:
    The information presented on this website is not intended or implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. All content, including text, graphics, images and information, contained on or available through this website is for general information purposes only. Kerri Rivera, Autismo2 and affiliates make no representation and assume no responsibility, legal or otherwise, for the accuracy of information contained on or available through this website, and such information is subject to change without notice. You are encouraged to confirm any information obtained from or through this website with other sources, and review all information regarding any medical condition or treatment with your physician.

    You are ultimately responsible for your own choices surrounding your health and the health of your children.

    Sounds like she’s really confident about the effectiveness of the “protocol,” doesn’t it? Nice try woot, but video testimonials are marketing tools, not scientific evidence.

  107. #107 Calli Arcale
    June 19, 2013

    The only thing that worked for our kids when teething was what my grandpa liked to call Tincture of Time. Or, as my wonderfully blunt great-aunt says, “This too shall pass.” She’s particularly fond of using that phrase when discussing digestive upset, due to the double entendre, but it works for most of the things parents have to deal with. Kids not sleeping, kids wetting the bed, kids wetting their pants, kids teething . . . most of these things pass on their own. It gets harder, not easier, as they get older; I think we intuitively understand that teething pains go away when teeth are done erupting, but remembering that adolescent angst is also temporary and not a permanent condition is rather harder — especially since the child is old enough by then to notice you’re just waiting them out rather than doing taking away their pain.

    BTW, my great-aunt also likes to point out that bourbon is a great treatment for teething. Not for the child, but for the parent. :-D

  108. #108 Roger
    June 19, 2013

    Orac,

    I’d like to hear your take on the latest Harvard study linking areas of higher pollution to rates of autism incidence two- to three- times higher.

    Sample size? Subgroup analysis? Higher pollution areas typically being urban, therefore higher education rates, therefore higher awareness and ultimately higher rates of diagnoses? Or, finally, is there something to it?

    The link to the report was on cnn.com, although I know SB doesn’t favor hot-linking.

  109. #109 Narad
    June 19, 2013

    You guys are an utter disgrace to intelligence.

    And this sentence is an affront to the English language.

    MMS has never ever killed anyone

    What happened to Silvie Fink?

    – and Rivera has so far recovered over 93 children COMPLETELY of their autism symptoms.

    So Rivera is practicing medicine without a license? Thanks for the tip.

  110. #110 lilady
    June 19, 2013

    “Here is a video testimonial showing a kid and his mom that used Riveras method, which also involves pharmaceuticals like Mebendazole, not just MMS. Diet is also a huge part of her protocol.”

    Holy Sh!t woot,…Rivera, who is not a doctor, is using a prescription antihelmintic drug to treat her patients for imaginary worms, before she prescribes industrial bleach enemas.

    http://www.rxlist.com/vermox-drug.htm

  111. #111 Chris,
    June 19, 2013

    Dr. Gordon:

    @Chris: I also like frozen wash clothes for teething babies. Add a little breast milk to make them taste familiar. Works better than whatever amber might do.

    I actually winced in pain when I read that. If I were still breastfeeding, the last thing I would want associated with chewing would be breast milk! It was bad enough that the youngest caused me to get several breast infections, but I would hate to think about her biting and chewing, especially as a two year old. (she is now a college student, and now prefers lattes)

    Lurkers: you will note that both who thought that was a good idea do not have the capacity to breastfeed. I think I would still suggest just water on the terry cloth.

  112. #112 herr doktor bimler
    June 19, 2013

    What happened to Silvie Fink?
    According to Jim Humble, her husband murdered her and is using MMS as a scapegoat.

  113. #113 Narad
    June 19, 2013

    According to Jim Humble, her husband murdered her and is using MMS as a scapegoat.

    Thank goodness he’s using secure channels: “From his location in Africa, Jim Humble sent me, in encrypted form, his own assessment of Mr. Nash’s accusations….”

    I’d like to think that this involves a one-time pad.

  114. #114 Mephistopheles O'Brien
    June 19, 2013

    Chris,

    To be clear, I left the concept of milk on the washcloth out of my comments on Dr. Gordon’s recommendations. I don’t know if it would have the effect you describe or not.

  115. #115 Mephistopheles O'Brien
    June 19, 2013

    BTW – I find the term “breast milk” to be ambiguous. Wouldn’t “human’s milk” be more accurate and a clear parallel with sheep’s milk, goat’s milk, or cow’s milk?

  116. #116 Chris
    June 19, 2013

    Fair enough, M O’B!

  117. #117 Chris
    June 19, 2013

    M O’B, sheep, goats and cows have teats.

  118. #118 Mephistopheles O'Brien
    June 19, 2013

    Chris – very true. However, other primates have breasts.

  119. #119 Mephistopheles O'Brien
    June 19, 2013

    Chickens and turkeys also have breasts, but as birds they do not produce milk.

  120. #120 Mephistopheles O'Brien
    June 19, 2013

    BTW – almond milk, soy milk, and milk of magnesia do not count.

  121. #121 sheepmilker
    See your teats and raise you a bag!
    June 19, 2013

    Actually, the analogous ruminant organ to human breasts is an udder. Teats are the things on the end.

  122. #122 Sebastian Jackson
    June 19, 2013

    I don’t think Kerri Rivera was the only MMS pitchman at Autism One last month. I just found a slide show on the Autism One website for a presentation by an associate of hers, Andreas Kalcker. It is horrifying and the subject of a blog post in itself: http://www.autismone.org/sites/default/files/kalcker.pdf

  123. #123 Chris,
    June 19, 2013

    My vocabulary has been expanded, and corrected. There were times when I felt too close a kinship to dairy cattle. It did not help that I had the short story “In the Barn” in Again, Dangerous Visions by Piers Anthony.

  124. #124 Jay Gordon, MD, FAAP
    June 19, 2013

    Human mammary gland nutritional secretion.

    Or not.

    I miss you all. I’ll read David’s notes about Paul’s new book and come back tonight.

    Best,

    Jay

  125. #125 lilady
    June 19, 2013

    Scroll on down Sebastian Jackson’s link to see the slide show featuring the butt and thighs of someone with a string in her rectum.

    http://www.autismone.org/sites/default/files/kalcker.pdf

    “What is in the gut?

    Mucus in the stool?

    Wait a moment

    What mucus gland is
    able to produce this?

    Mucus is hydro soluble

    At least it should be

    If it is not mucus it can
    be…”

  126. #126 Mephistopheles O'Brien
    June 19, 2013

    lilady – that’s just sad, and validates all the bad things that Edward Tufte says about PowerPoint.

  127. #127 Narad
    June 19, 2013

    Scroll on down Sebastian Jackson’s link to see the slide show featuring the butt and thighs of someone with a string in her rectum.

    The depiction of the liver in the “Ammonia” slide is, ah, impressive. It’s also a combination of two Wikimedia images.

  128. #128 Roger Kulp
    June 19, 2013

    OT (sort of) Jenny McCarthy likes to crunch the nuts in her salad commercial.

  129. #130 Chemmomo
    Mine used to do that. . . .
    June 19, 2013

    Jay Gordon @124

    Human mammary gland nutritional secretion

    I just have to say: thank you! Reading that gave me a much needed laugh.

  130. #131 Christine (the public servant Christine)
    June 19, 2013

    @Passerby, #95:

    @elburto
    Enemas are horrible. The administration (by someone else) feels degrading and can make you feel so vulnerable. The sequelae can be agonising, with severe cramping, nausea, feeling flushed, and all manner of unpleasant things. — SNIP —
    I do take a bit of an issue with your characterization of enemas as universally horrible things.

    I don’t recognise your moniker, Passerby, and I’ll assume you aren’t a regular contributor. If you were, you would know elburto is extremely qualified to speak about the nature of enemas. I’m also left wondering if you’ve ever actually had one yourself. Although elburto is more than capable of defending herself, left me enlighten you on both points.

    elburto, like me, suffers from Crohn’s Disease. This is a painful, debilitating condition where part of the digestive tract becomes inflamed and ulcerated, and if it’s bad enough, the ulcerated bit has to be cut out (I’ve had this twice). Sufferers get to manage a lifetime of gut cramps, nausea, weight loss, severe lack of appetite, diarrhea… and severe constipation. I categorise it as “severe” because we’re not talking a couple of days, we’re talking several days or even weeks.

    And when the constipation is severe, enemas get employed. And I assure you, elburto is entirely correct in categorising them as horrible and degrading.

    An enema is a liquid that’s injected up the backside via a syringe or pipette device. It liquifies and flushes out whatever’s up there, and if constipation is severe, several might be required.

    What, I ask you, is not humiliating about someone shoving something up your backside to make you poo? If you’re lucky, you can get the thing up there yourself. More often though, it’s lying on your side with backside bared while someone else shoves the enema in.

    And because enemas are designed to liquify whatever’s up there, yes, the results are explosive, painful and disgusting.

    I’m glad you at least recognised the appalling abuse this mother is subjecting her child to. For elburto, and me, who’ve had to endure these things quite a bit, they are bad enough. At least we know why it’s happening, and have given consent. For a child who may not have the verbal skills to question, and probably doesn’t know why…. trust me, the horror we feel is unbelievable.

  131. #132 Calli Arcale
    June 20, 2013

    Christine,

    I’ve certainly been here long enough to know about elburto’s situation, but I got what Passerby was saying. Though for a lot of us, even the *idea* of an enema is profoundly disturbing (to say nothing of actually receiving one), it cannot be denied that there are people who actually do enjoy them. Indeed, Rule 34 being what it is, I’m sure one can find rather more evidence to this fact than any of us really would care to see. People are just plain weird sometimes….

  132. #133 accidie
    June 20, 2013

    Actually, Mephistophes O’Brien, some birds (and according to my friend who did this research, there may be many more) DO produce ‘milk’. http://www.australiangeographic.com.au/journal/birds-produce-milk-similar-to-mammals.htm

  133. #134 t.
    June 20, 2013

    Please, tell me CPS can be involved. Please.

  134. #135 dingo199
    June 20, 2013

    May just be mucus but Jojo’s happy :) Better out than in!

    Our friend needs educating on what the normal physiological role of mucus is.
    It’s there to protect the bowel, and lubricate the stools.
    Why would it be “better out than in”?
    How “un-natural” can you get.
    Might as well bleed out someone’s circulation by slitting their wrists, joyfully shouting “Better out than in!”

    And is Jojo happy? Really, really happy? Harsh to say, but if Jojo is getting a real kick out of these enemas, then I don’t hold out much hope for sexual normalcy in future relationships. Indeed, a pattern of repeated child enemas might leave Jojo open to future exploitative abusive relationships and abnormal behaviour.
    However, IANAP, so what do I know.

    PS: I see she has tagged her pics as “Ascaris lumbricoides” (round worm). These clumps of mucus and colonic mucosal casts are not round worms, any more than bits of vomited, semi- digested spaghetti are round worms.

  135. #136 Mephistopheles O'Brien
    June 20, 2013

    accidie,

    Well, that just changed my entire world. Thanks.

  136. #137 SkepticalSlug
    June 20, 2013

    #133 – accidie

    Are the milk producing birds members of the Paridae family?

  137. #138 lilady
    June 20, 2013

    About those awful Autism One PowerPoint presentation slides….

    http://www.autismone.org/sites/default/files/kalcker.pdf

    Dr. Andreas Ludwig Kalcker’s day job is working with Kerri Rivera and Rev. Jim Humble…

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ItXb6yXntNY

  138. #139 lilady
    June 20, 2013

    Kalcker’s blog; knock yourselves out…

    http://andreaskalcker.com/index.php/en/health/autism

  139. #140 Alain
    June 20, 2013

    Is there anything I can do to land these criminal in jail? I’m dead serious.

    Alain

  140. #141 Alain
    June 20, 2013

    @ Denice,

    You survey these blogs and websites about practitioners of woo and also, parents (TMR spring to mind) who subject their child to woo. Do you have a list these websites? Mailing list and groups would be useful too.

    Thanks
    Alain

  141. #142 Denice Walter
    June 20, 2013

    @ Alain:

    Right now, I’m only regularly surveying a select few ( AoA, TMR, Natural News. Progressive Radio Network/ Gary Null.com)…
    but I often look at Mercola, Gaia Health, Green Med Info, ANH, Natural Solutions Foundation, Bolen, hiv/aids denialists.. and others which presently escape me.

    I might suggest looking at some of the anti-vax sites’ facebook pages/ blog comments- which often lead to websites belonging to their readers- some who sell products and advertise services..

    I see a few dynamic players emerging from the crowd @ TMR- MacNeil, Goes, Jameson- all of whom are pushing hard against the stony walls of reality.

  142. #143 Alain
    June 20, 2013

    I called the RCMP and the local police department and regarding the local police did not want to do anything regarding that. the RCMP was more forward looking. I will also consult with the sister of my best friend; she’s a police officer.

    Alain

  143. #144 Christine (the public servant Christine)
    June 20, 2013

    Agreed, Calli. There are some *interesting* people in this world (asexual myself so I really don’t get it).

    My later thought was Passerby might be an advocate of colonic irrigation, which is basically one prolonged enema… which would really earn my wrath. If you have a healthy bowel, you don’t *need* a colonic, no matter what their advocates say. And if your bowel ain’t healthy, a colonic can make things worse.

  144. #145 Alain
    June 20, 2013

    Regarding the local police, every time I had a complaint to fill, they never were interested. Never. Matter of fact, I was vastly more often interrogated by the police than the reverse situation (having a complaint taken seriously) and it’s frustrating.

    Alain

  145. #146 ebrillblaiddes
    June 21, 2013

    WRT what the “worms” really are: The problem with the phrase “colonic mucosa” in this context is that most people don’t know right off whether you would want to keep that in or get it out. While the phrase “shreddy bits of intestine” is less precise, it’s horrifying in proportion to the reality with fewer A&P credits.

  146. #147 LW
    June 21, 2013

    I think you’re being a bit hard on Passerby. I reread the comment, and I don’t think s/he was advocating enemas or colonic irrigation, just observing the interesting fact that some people really do enjoy them, specifically mentioning klismaphilia as a paraphilia.

    The curebies inflict them on defenseless children, but there are adults who willingly seek them out. That was an observation, perhaps not all that relevant here but not advocacy by Passerby.

    Passerby also mentioned that whoever administers an enema *shouldn’t* make the patient feel degraded, which applies as much to enemas as to all the other things medical personnel do to patients. I’m sure professionals do their best not to make the necessary treatment degrading. Curebies, though — I suspect they have less desire to avoid making the victim feel degraded.

  147. #148 Trends
    June 21, 2013

    @Sebastian: “When Kerri Rivera first appeared at Autism One a year ago, Julie Obradovic defended her on AoA. She was forced to furiously packpedal when she was called out on it by a “HuffPo” (!) contributor. This year, AoA completely ignored Rivera, probably because they knew discussing her would arouse negative publicity for Autism One and themselves”

    I’m delighted to hear that AoA is distancing itself from the MMS folks – maybe they’ll continue the policy of distancing themselves from disgraceful people and eventually become an organization that does good for autistic people and their families, but I don’t expect such a radical change in approach anytime soon, I’m afraid.

  148. [...] Via Rob Breakanridge: Bleach enemas for autistic children. Yes, there are those who advocate this and those who do it. [...]

  149. #150 Captain Quirk
    five parsecs from nowhere
    June 25, 2013

    #95, I get what you’re saying, but I’d think it’s WAY less likely for an autistic child to like (or just not be completely miserable) getting an enema. I haven’t gotten an enema myself, but I am autistic and going to the salon for a haircut (water sprayed on my head and clips put in my hair) was agonizing. I was crying and in lots of pain and at first my parents thought I was acting up (not diagnosed yet), so it was awhile before they called it off, and by then I was crying and crying. So even if the person performing the enema is extremely kind and loving and respectful, it would still be highly likely to cause a great deal of pain and anxiety.

  150. #151 Broken Link
    June 28, 2013

    While there is still no video of RFK’s speech at Autism One, there are testimonials about MMS working. I haven’t looked at these – I’m not sure I could stand it.

    http://www.youtube.com/user/MMStestimonials?feature=watch

    Also, please note that it seems that MMS is sometimes known as CD treatment.

  151. #152 Yaf
    United Kingdom
    July 8, 2013

    My son has autism.

    He’s cute and incredibly violent, but you know, he’s cute and also he can read very nicely so most people overlook his occasional punches to the face. As I sincerely doubt that this gentle forgiveness from strangers will last longer than his milk teeth, I find myself reading everything I can about autism.
    It’s clear that there are many unscrupulous folks making a fine living from the mild to severe torture of children and desperate parents. I am fortunate in that I possess a few nicely laid out boundaries concerning how I approach the more unacceptable aspects of my lovely lad’s reasoning system and precisely when the ‘cure’ is completely disgusting and unethical. Although I know full well that there are vile people out there who would (and do) induce sickness in their own offspring for the sake of manageability , it did break my heart that few commenting here realised that the mother was also suffering from some kind of crazygodawfulproblemsofherown.
    Having a child with few visible symptoms, no sleeping pattern to speak of and the occasional wash of euphoric fully capable interactions is very, very hard on any parent. The uncertainty of the future is particularly difficult to bear. Hating on a sleep deprived, desperate parent will only send that person running to their (actually very evil money making quackeriffic) ‘friends’ for comfort and validation.
    No good person wants that.
    Don’t be enemies, you bold, brave, reason filled science bods! Be soothing to the victims, even the very stupid ones, it will bring more people to their senses (I know, I know that sticking bleach up your child’s bottom should be fairly counter intuitive – but some people swear by dolphin brain wave repatterning exercises and the like – humans are broken). The quacks deserve the prison sentences and the rage. They deserve plenty of things I might consider quietly and yet eventually decide against because I am not some monster-god with acid spurting digits.

    But. Someone needs to point out that the parents need help too.
    It’s very painful and confusing and full of guilt, this process of finding the right way to open up all the glory of the world to a disabled child.

    Clever, rational people of the world, we need you! Desperately! You wonderful thinkers – you are our heros, don’t you know?

  152. [...] blekmedellavemang. Du läste rätt, som vanlig länkar jag till den stora Orca på scienceblog: No matter how often I read about treatments like this, I still can’t believe parents actually subj… Men jag varnar er, det är otrevlig [...]

  153. #154 Mary
    July 30, 2013

    This just popped up in my Facebook feed from a company that sells flavored coconut butters asking people to share as the project is promoting gluten free, soy free, etc diet to cure autism. Ugh! http://www.indiegogo.com/projects/the-road-to-recovery-healing-the-symptoms-known-as-autism

    This is my number 1 pet peeve with so called “healthy food” people as they seem to throw science out the window. Tired of sites that are supposed to be about food touting anti-vax and no this! I don’t see what the point of feeding your child healthy is if you are going to then feed them bleach.

  154. #155 Stacey Kirkland
    mesa az
    August 14, 2013

    Say what you will, but the protocol works. It’s not bleach. It’s got a dioxide molecule attached, making it benign to our tissues, and lethal to pathogens. Not child abuse at all. I’ve taken MMS, my liver enzymes are fine, my skin cleared up, my foot fungus is gone and my toothache went away with MMS. Chlorine Dioxide, not bleach. Sodium chloride is table salt. Not bleach either. Learn some chemistry, and learn about oxidation, the magnetics and Ph of chemicals. Then it will make sense. Suffer with all your ailments and keep telling us who have experienced wellness and are recovering our sick kids that we are hoodwinked. Take some Tylenol (which hospitalizes 26,000 people a year and kills nearly 500 a year taken as prescribed), it’s legal, so it must be OK. Drink the FDA cool aide, go to a doctor who knows medicine (but not health, thanks to the AMA, The Rockefeller Foundation, and big Pharma). http://youtu.be/FrwZN1cPfX8

  155. #156 Julian Frost
    Gauteng East Rand
    August 14, 2013

    @Stacey Kirkland:

    It’s not bleach.

    Just because it’s not the stuff you buy at the store doesn’t mean it’s not bleach. Napalm is soap, even though it’s not sodium stearate.

    It’s got a dioxide molecule attached, making it benign to our tissues…

    “The EPA has set a maximum contaminant level of 1 milligram of chlorite per liter (1 mg/L) in drinking water.” Also “Sodium chlorite is a strong oxidant and can therefore be expected to cause clinical symptoms similar to the well known sodium chlorate: methemoglobinemia, hemolysis, renal failure.” As for Chlorine Dioxide:
    “The EPA limits exposure to 0.8 mg/L for chlorine dioxide in drinking water and the Occupational Safety and Health Administration sets maximum exposure at 0.1 ppm in air for a maximum of 8 hours.” Harmless? I don’t think so.

    I’ve taken MMS, my liver enzymes are fine, my skin cleared up, my foot fungus is gone and my toothache went away with MMS.

    And what is your proof that the MMS was responsible for your improvements in health? All your symptoms can clear up over time unassisted.

    Learn some chemistry, and learn about oxidation, the magnetics and Ph of chemicals.

    You’re adorable.

  156. #157 JGC
    No patience for liars
    August 14, 2013

    Sally, none of your claims are true. Chlorine dioxide is bleach (industrial-grade bleach at that), it isn’t benign to human tissue, and forcing a child to injest it or recieve it as an enema is abuse.

  157. #158 lilady
    Not in la-la-land
    August 14, 2013

    @ Stacey Kirkland: Citation via a You Tube video…featuring “Reverend” Jim Humble. How quaint:

    Cripes you are ignorant about the properties of MMS:

    http://www.fda.gov/NewsEvents/Newsroom/PressAnnouncements/ucm220747.htm

  158. #159 Krebiozen
    August 14, 2013

    Stacey Kirkland,

    It’s not bleach.

    If you are truly convinced of this, please take your favorite piece of colored clothing, activate 15 drops of ‘MMS’ with citric acid, pour this over your much-loved clothing and leave it for a few minutes. Then come back here and tells me this stuff isn’t a bleach. Also, consider that if this does that to your clothing, what does it do to your body?

    It’s got a dioxide molecule attached, making it benign to our tissues, and lethal to pathogens.

    Like fluorine dioxide, sulfur dioxide and nitrogen dioxide, all of which are lethally toxic? If chlorine dioxide is benign to our tissues, I suppose you would be happy putting the activated ‘MMS’ in our previous experiment undiluted on some sensitive skin, or inhaling the gas. Dropping a few crystals of vitamin C into a few ounces of ‘MMS’ will generate lots of brown chlorine dioxide gas, and I can assure you that inhaling a lungful will instantly convince you it is not at all benign. If you inhale enough you will permanently damage your lungs and might even die, so I don’t recommend this, I’m just pointing out how foolish it is to claim that chlorine dioxide is benign.

    I’ve taken MMS, my liver enzymes are fine, my skin cleared up, my foot fungus is gone and my toothache went away with MMS.

    Your liver enzymes are unlikely to be affected by MMS, even if you take enough to make yourself sick. It is a gastrointestinal irritant which will nauseate you and give you diarrhea in small doses, and cause methemoglobinemia in higher doses. Methemoglobinemia is the result of oxidation of hemoglobin which happens when people drink powerful oxidizing agents such as bleaches like chlorine dioxide. It can be fatal in extreme cases, and babies under 6 months of age are particularly susceptible.

    As for foot fungus, you can also get rid of this with a blowtorch, or by soaking your feet in domestic bleach, but you are risking damage to your health by doing so, just as you are by using MMS. Why not use a fungicide which is designed to be more harmful to fungus than health human tissue?

    Chlorine Dioxide, not bleach. Sodium chloride is table salt. Not bleach either.

    You apparently don’t understand the difference between hypochlorite, chlorate, chlorite and chloride, and actually believe it when people tell you that chlorine dioxide is not a bleach, when by every chemical or layperson’s definition it is.

    Learn some chemistry, and learn about oxidation, the magnetics and Ph of chemicals. Then it will make sense.

    You should really have learned some chemistry yourself before coming to a science blog and embarrassing yourself by asserting such nonsense about chemistry.

    I have worked for more than two decades in clinical biochemistry, so I know more than enough about “oxidation, the magnetics and Ph of chemicals” to know that what passes for “chemistry” touted on MMS websites is almost entirely nonsense designed to convince the ignorant and gullible to drink bleach.

    I also have a rule never to take chemistry advice from anyone who can’t spell pH, since that strongly suggests they don’t have a clue what it means. Hint – pH relates to hydrogen ion concentration.

    Take some Tylenol (which hospitalizes 26,000 people a year and kills nearly 500 a year taken as prescribed), it’s legal, so it must be OK.

    That’s not true. In the US acetaminophen causes 450 deaths and 56,000 emergency-room visits a year due to accidental or deliberate overdose. It is a very safe drug and certainly doesn’t kill hundreds of people each year “taken as prescribed”, though labeling could certainly be improved.

    Consider that 19% of the US population use acetaminophen at least once a week, that’s billions of doses each year. If billions of doses of MMS were taken each year I would be willing to bet their would be thousands of deaths, since it has no demonstrable benefit, and poses very serious risks.

  159. #160 lilady
    Still not in la-la land
    August 14, 2013

    See my post at # 139 above and the activities of Andreas Kalcker promoting MMS for autism treatment:

    He’s run into the long arm of the law and there are multiple change.org petitions up on the internet. It couldn’t happen to a nicer guy:

    http://dotmedia.ning.com/profiles/blogs/sweet-revolution-conference-after-the-arrest-of-andreas-kalcker-f

  160. #161 Krebiozen
    August 14, 2013

    Sigh. Hopefully the blockquote fail is obvious.

  161. #162 Krebiozen
    August 14, 2013

    Apologies for misspellings and errors in my next to last comment. In an indignant rush.

  162. #163 AdamG
    August 14, 2013

    Stacey, it appears you joined the MMS for Autism discussion board a few weeks ago. I urge you, for the child’s sake, to read Krebiozen’s post above with an open mind and seriously consider whether you want to inflict MMS on a child.

    Learn some chemistry, and learn about oxidation, the magnetics and Ph of chemicals.

    Says the Art major to the chemists!

  163. #164 Calli Arcale
    August 14, 2013

    She says dioxides make it safe, and then goes on to lecture us about learning chemistry?

    Good gracious.

    Wanna taste some fluorine dioxide? Never mind, you can’t — it ate through the container and then set the floor on fire. (It’s actually got the insane quality of being able to set *ice* on fire.) “Having a dioxide attached”, as you so quaintly put it, does not magically make a molecule safe. It really only means it has two oxygen atoms.

    “Bleach”, Stacey, is not a single chemical. It is a class of chemicals which can be used to remove pigment. Most do this through oxidation; one popular bleach is hydrogen peroxide, which has absolutely no chlorine at all in it. Some people try claiming that will cure all your ills too, but apart from some effectiveness as an antiseptic (and there are safer choices for that), it’s really pretty nasty because it is so happy to oxidize things. (So happy you can even use it in rocket propellant. But I digress.)

    Chlorine dioxide, meanwhile, is most definitely used as a bleach. That is its main use, worldwide — bleaching wood pulp at paper mills, mainly, but also bleaching flour. The second most common use is disinfection of swimming pools (which is where most MMS users get it from) and treatment of drinking water to kill pathogens. It is very effective at killing pathogens, after all. At sufficient concentrations, its good at killing almost everything. Which is why you maybe should consider whether or not it’s a smart thing to put in your body. It’s certainly no better than unnecessary antibiotics — and, if you care to look at more than just what the sellers are telling you, you’ll see it might actually be a good deal worse, depending on how much of it you’re taking.

  164. #165 JGC
    August 14, 2013

    Stacey (apologies for getting your name wrong above) you sugest we learn some chemistry. I suggest you do so, by examiningg the Material Safety Data Sheets for sodium chlorite (which can be found at http://www.cleartech.ca/msds/sodchlorite.pdf) and for
    chlorine dioxide (which can be found at http://www.puremash.com/pdfs/MaterialDataSheetCIO2.pdf)

    Clearly actuall, trained chemists don’t agree that it’s ‘benign to our tissues’.

  165. #166 Krebiozen
    August 14, 2013

    I have said this before here, but it bears repetition. When you are looking at a substances that will kill pathogens, which is the main use for MMS (unsubstantiated and implausible claims about “immune system stimulation” notwithstanding), the important things are:

    1. How toxic the substance is to the target pathogen.

    2. How toxic the substance is to the patient.

    1. For chlorine dioxide the minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) for Staphylococcus Aureus is about 200 mg/l. For ciprofloxacin the MIC for S. Aureus is less than 4 mg/l.

    2. Ciprofloxacin is also far less toxic to mammals than chlorine dioxide. LD50 for chlorine dioxide in rats is 165 mg/kg, LD50 for ciprofloxacin in mice and rats is in excess of 5,000 mg/kg. Assuming humans are equally susceptible, a lethal dose of MMS in a 70 kg human would be 12 grams, a lethal dose of ciprofloxacin greater than 350 grams.

    In summary, MMS is 50 times less toxic to S. Aureus than Ciprofloxacin, but 30 times more toxic to humans. In terms of therapeutic index, MMS is 1,500 times less safe and effective than ciprofloxacin.

    This is not surprising since chlorine dioxide is a powerful oxidizing agent, like all bleaches, that specifically attacks the electron-rich centers of organic molecules, those comprising normal, healthy cells as well as pathogens. Any drug company would throw this out as a potential antibiotic, preferring to look for chemicals that target structures or processes that occur only in pathogens, not in healthy human cells as well. It seems insane that some people are claiming this non-specific toxic, cytocidal substance is a natural medicine.

    All figures are from reputable sources, and can be provided should anyone dispute them – I don’t want to send this comment into moderation by including them.

The site is currently under maintenance and will be back shortly. New comments have been disabled during this time, please check back soon.