Earlier today Dr. Isis received an email from the powers-that-be at ScienceBlogs asking for a response to a brand, spanking new "Ask a ScienceBlogger" question. This one comes from two ScienceBlogs readers who will also be moderating a session on science fiction at ScienceOnline'09. Here's the question:
What do you see as science fiction's role in promoting science, if any?
This is an amazing question and Dr. Isis thinks that, not only is science fiction totally hot, but that science fiction is crucial in inspiring young scientists. At least, it was for Dr. Isis. Allow me to explain:
Dr. Isis grew up a huge Star Trek fan. I mean, massively huge. She started out watching The Original Series and all but lost her junk when The Next Generation started. While Dr. Isis prefers to pretend that Deep Space Nine and Enterprise never happened, she is one of the few who enjoyed Voyager (yes, even when Seven of Nine showed up). Dr. Isis might own the three complete serieses on DVD and consider an ideal night to be a glass of wine, an Aveda clay mask, and the tribbles episode.
Figure 1: An ideal evening in the Isis house -- at least for Dr. Isis.
So why did these particular shows have such an impact on Dr. Isis? There are two reasons. First, each series demonstrated a progressive inclusion of women and minorities in science and technology. I mean, sure Uhura was kind of a secretary, but she was also one of the first regularly featured female African American characters that was not someone's servant. She was considered to be a major minority female role model. In TNG the ship's doctor was a woman and I remember being thrilled by the idea of an overtly feminine woman in a labcoat. By the time we get to Voyager, Janeway is the captain. I was an adult by the time this series ran, but I found it fascinating to watch how her femininity was dealt with and, at times, stifled. I identified with her internal struggle with her femininity and her attempt to appear to be a strong leader and with the sense of responsibility she felt for those she was charged to care for...and the fact that she often made decisions at the expense of herself.
Figure 2: Intelligent female characters in positions of authority in "the future" made Dr. Isis hopeful that women would continue to be included in science, engineering, math, and technology.
Second, Dr. Isis appreciated the idea of the pursuit of science as a means to fulfill one's own curiosity -- the mission to explore where no totally hot domestic and laboratory goddess had gone before. I totally dug when they would stop at some planet just to check out something they were curious about and things would descend into shennanigans. I loved that their discoveries were used to make life better -- that they had found solutions to poverty and hunger and (largely) disease. As a girl I wanted this to be my life; I wanted to pursue the things I was interested in because I was curious and then use my findings to make my corner of society a little bit better. I think this is largely what I do now as a scientist.
So, I suppose Viriginia, the role I see for science fiction in science is to offer us a vision of how the future might be and to give us something to dream about. It has inspired me to think about what my place in the future might be and to hope that the future would continue to be even better for my daughters. It made me want to explore and discover. And, finally, it taught me the importance of not going to a major meeting in a red shirt.




Comments
Eeek! Tribbles episode is the BEST EVER!
Posted by: scicurious | November 24, 2008 1:28 PM
Ohhh... this is exactly why the great goddess rocks. :D
I'm a wee bit of a trekkie myself (I too have to admit to being a Voyager fan, though I've been ridiculed for it), and I don't think Star Trek's appeal, or connection to inspiring creative exploration could be better put.
I'll just add a "hear, hear" to that.
(and yes the skirts were short, but hot damn those women still did their jobs)
(oh, and I hung that poster in the lab I work in... I tell the newbies that they are Ensign Ricky... teehee.)
Posted by: physics*chick | November 24, 2008 1:55 PM
You didn't like Deep Space Nine!!!! WTF!!!! I am sure Voyager was good, I wouldn't know b/c as much as I wanted to watch, Janeways voice drove me nuts. Enterprise had potential, but again making the Quantum Leap dude the captain was just plain wrong. I will go mourn for deep space nine. BTW Troy and Beverly rock!
Posted by: ScientistMother | November 24, 2008 2:04 PM
Ensign Ricky LOLzies....until, um, you realize that that's "the black guy" in so many other cinematic traditions. zoikes.
Posted by: DrugMonkey | November 24, 2008 2:04 PM
I always thought Troi was totally hot, I just wish every plotline didn't revolve around her getting violated in some way. Then again, there's a whole feminist discourse about this particular topic.
Buzz hill.
Posted by: Isis the Scientist | November 24, 2008 2:14 PM
I was definitely a fan of the Mars trilogy by Kim Stanley Robinson. Much more of a book person than a TV person, yet science fiction spans both genres nicely.
Posted by: Academic | November 24, 2008 2:36 PM
I'll see your Buzz hill and raise you +100:
+
=
What's Wrong With Science, episode #39027
(not meaning to imply this is you, physics*chick; my mind just combines comments oddly sometimes).
Also, the Mars trilogy is pretty sweet- Kim Stanley Robinson has some great lines: "Science was many things, Nadia thought, including a weapon with which to hit other scientists."
Posted by: Becca | November 24, 2008 3:19 PM
I totally agree that science fiction can be inspiring. How many times have I sat down to watch an episode of Stargate: Atlantis instead of studying for that midterm two days away and ended up just feeling guilty that I wasn't after telling everyone in earshot I want to be Dr.McKay/Keller/whoever is being the most awesome.
Have you seen the trailer for the new Star Trek movie? I am not even a Trekkie and I'm pretty damn excited. Maybe it's because I'm not a fan?
Posted by: LJ | November 24, 2008 5:13 PM
I talked to a HUGE star trek fan at the weekend who has not only never seen Galaxy Quest, but had never even heard of it! I thought it was required viewing for all Trekkers.
Posted by: Cath@VWXYNot? | November 24, 2008 6:46 PM
GalaxyQuest is so awesome, though I think its also sorta star warsy. The other totally awesome sci-fi series I want to purchase is Battlestar glatica.
Posted by: ScientistMother | November 24, 2008 7:08 PM
/lurk
Omgomgomg tribbles! Dangit, Dr. Isis, you found the one thing that is sure to get me out of lurking.
+10000 to Star Trek being an inspiration to become a scientist--i got into psychology partly because I thought Troi was way cool. *thumbsup*
Posted by: Nekohime | November 24, 2008 9:33 PM
Any Firefly fans?
Posted by: BugDoc | November 24, 2008 11:02 PM
Welcome from lurkdom, Nekohime. I hope you'll stay around.
And BugDoc, do you not think Dr. Isis saw Serenity in the theater the day it came out AND owns Firefly on DVD? Do you think Dr. Isis didn't weep like a little girl when Shepherd Book met his maker? I mean, dude....
Posted by: Isis the Scientist | November 24, 2008 11:31 PM
The "Who's hotter - Dr. Crusher or Troi?" debate ain't goin' away anytime soon.
Posted by: csrster | November 25, 2008 4:56 AM
OMG, I was a total trekkie in my youth, and while I never really thought about it, I think that you're right in that the female cast served as role models for us. Troy and Beverly were my absolute favs!
Posted by: Jenn | November 25, 2008 5:01 AM
We I certainly have to agree with you here:
I remember being thrilled by the idea
of an overtly feminine woman in a labcoat.
Come to think of it, that still works for me. ;-)
Jim
Posted by: Jim | November 25, 2008 10:18 AM
I LOOOOOOOOOOOOVE TNG!!!! Beverly was freakin awesome and I would do a circa 1992 Jean Luc Picard in a heartbeat. I love, love, loved that show.
Does anyone like the Ender books?
Posted by: PhizzleDizzle | November 25, 2008 11:19 AM
Jim- I think overtly feminine woman in lab coat thing is the Magritee effect.
+1 to Firefly/Serenity and Ender. Duh. Anyone for Bujold?
Posted by: Becca | November 25, 2008 11:37 AM
PhD, the Ender books, and everything by Orson Scott Card, are my absolute faves - except for Star Trek TOS, TNG, DSN, Voyager, and movies, of course. Great to hear someone else reads them.
Posted by: Silver Fox | November 25, 2008 11:47 AM
Fuck people I think we have a tribe right here. Someone better tell Drugmonkey.
Posted by: kiwi | November 25, 2008 12:00 PM
You don't care for DS9? I'm rather surprised. I always thought Kira and Dax (1-6) were two of the best Trek characters ever (and while I loathed Voyager, I adored Kes--her psionic combat with the body-jumping dictator is one of my all around favorite Trek episodes).
And come now, Trials and Tribblations actually managed to meet if not surpass the original. Worf's explanation of TOS Klingons lacking brow ridges was classic and note perfect. The corollary being episode that made Enterprise dead to me was the horrid and unnecessary multi-part episode why Klingons may or may not have brow-ridges at any given time.
Posted by: usagi | November 25, 2008 7:56 PM
I don't remember which episode of voyager, but I particularly remember noting 7of9 in her classical curt manner asking Janeway to help her because her task required "solving several complex calculations." Where else but Star Trek do you have two women doing complicated math as a matter of fact?
Posted by: Jason W | December 30, 2008 6:46 AM