Yesterday I received my review copy of Grave Secrets of Dinosaurs: Soft Tissues and Hard Science by Phillip Manning (supposedly all about the hadrosaur mummy "Dakota"), and while I usually try to keep quiet about my thoughts on a book until I've finished it I just can't keep my trap shut this time. I will write a full review very soon (I'm more than halfway through the book), but I am extremely disappointed with this piece. The book contains no index, no bibliography/references, and there are virtually no pictures of the dinosaur the book is supposed to focus on (save for a scan of a segment of tail). Aside from a small section in the middle of the book the title is practically devoid of illustrations, and I really have to wonder why this book was printed in such an incomplete fashion. Even though I am not finished with it I doubt if the book will mention what species Dakota is and I've already mentioned that there are essentially no photographs, reconstructions, or diagrams of the animal beside the art on the cover and one picture of the tail, and I can't imagine why this dinosaur was not described first in the scientific literature so fuller disclosure could be given in the book. I'm sure that Manning is so tight-lipped because the dinosaur has not made its "proper" appearance in the peer-reviewed literature yet, but while the story of the discovery/excavation of the dinosaur is interesting (even though such discussion doesn't start until more than 1/3 of the way into the book) I was hoping for a bit more detail about the fossil and its implications for paleobiology. Indeed, contra to my expectations the book seems more like a teaser or a promo for the National Geographic show "Dino Autopsy" and whatever upcoming papers there may be, and while the second half of the book may contain some content that mitigate my issues with the first half (including an abuse of the "survival of the fittest" concept) there really is no excuse for a popular science book not to have an index or contain a bibliography.
Laelaps
The trouble with having an open mind, of course, is that people will insist on coming along and trying to put things in it. - Terry Pratchett
Profile
Laelaps is the blog of Brian Switek, a freelance science writer based in New Jersey. This blog frequently features his musings on paleontology, evolution, and the history of science. Switek also blogs for Smithsonian magazine's Dinosaur Tracking.
Switek's first book, Written in Stone, will be published next year by Bellevue Literary Press.
Facebook
Twitter
Search
Recent Posts
- Photo of the Day #757: Rock squirrel
- Photo of the Day #756: American avocets
- Photo of the Day #755: Dire wolf
- Where's My Elephant?
- Photo of the Day #754: Giant bison
- The March of Progress Has Deep Roots
- Photo of the Day #753: Goniopholis
- Photo of the Day #752: Skeletonized trees
- Chipping Away at Written in Stone
- Photo of the Day #751: Bison
Recent Comments
- Jim Thomerson on Photo of the Day #757: Rock squirrel
- The Ridger on Darwin's Darkest Hour
- Daniel J. Andrews on The March of Progress Has Deep Roots
- David on Photo of the Day #755: Dire wolf
- jck on Photo of the Day #755: Dire wolf
- Zachary Miller on Where's My Elephant?
- Adrienne Mayor on Where's My Elephant?
- Christophe Thill on Where's My Elephant?
- Amanda on Chipping Away at Written in Stone
- Ian on Where's My Elephant?
Archives
- November 2009
- October 2009
- September 2009
- August 2009
- July 2009
- June 2009
- May 2009
- April 2009
- March 2009
- February 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008
- October 2008
- September 2008
- August 2008
- July 2008
- June 2008
- May 2008
- April 2008
- March 2008
- February 2008
- January 2008
- December 2007
- November 2007
- October 2007
Blogroll
Paleo
- Dinosaur Tracking
- The Coastal Paleontologist
- Aquatic Amniotes
- SV-POW!
- Afarensis
- The World We Don't Live In
- Paleo Errata
- Archosaur Musings
- Gombessa Girl
- Diagenesis
- Chinleana
- Ediacaran
- The Life of Madygen
- Dracovenator
- The Ethical Palaeontologist
- Dots in Deep Time
- Bond's Blog
- Paleo Dude
- Dinochick
- The Open Source Paleontologist
- The Disillusioned Taxonomist
- Ask Dr. Vector
- Everything Dinosaur
- Hairy Museum of Natural History
- John Hawks
- Mark Witton
- microecos
- The Dragon's Tales
- When Pigs Fly Returns
- The Great Dinosaur Mystery and the Big Lie
- Self-Designed Student
- Palaeoblog
Zoology
- The Loom
- Photo Africa Blog
- Catalogue of Organisms
- Endless Forms
- Primate Diaries
- Rigor Vitae
- The Lord Geekington
- Bonobo Handshake
- The Daily Coyote
- Here Be Dragons
- Cephalopodcast
- The Other 95%
- Deep Sea News
Ecology
History of Science
- A Simple Prop
- Evolving Thoughts
- Skulls in the Stars
- Archy
- Ether Wave Propaganda
- FCD: The Red Notebook
- Millard Fillmore's Bathtub
- The Dispersal of Darwin
- Thoughts in a Haystack
- The Beagle Project Blog
- Transcribing Tyndall
Geology
Miscellany
- The Olive Tree
- Paw-Talk
- The Sandwalk
- Genomicron
- Migrations
- Gurney Journey
- Skepchick
- Tangled Up in Blue Guy
- SECular Thoughts
- Dispatches from Carbon Nation
- Cocktail Party Physics
- Peculiar Beauty
- The Digital Cuttlefish
- The Flying Trilobote
- Brummellblog
- Migrations
- The Panda's Thumb
- De Rerum Natura
- Quintessence of Dust
- RedMolly Picayune Democrat
- The Ethical Husband
Fellow Sciblings
- Highly Allochthonous
- Neurotopia
- Not Exactly Rocket Science
- Science After Sunclipse
- ERV
- A Blog Around the Clock
- Bioemphemera
- Greg Laden
- Living the Scientific Life
- Thus Spake Zuska
- Neurophilosophy
- Pharyngula
- Cognitive Daily
- Zooillogix
- The Island of Doubt
- Thoughts From Kansas
- Aardvarchaeology
- Tetrapod Zoology
- Adventures in Ethics and Science
- Terra Sigillata
« I wish I could be there | Main | A new genus of self-destructing palm tree »
Quick gripes about Grave Secrets of Dinosaurs
Category: Books • Dinosaurs • Paleontology
Posted on: January 17, 2008 8:01 AM, by Brian Switek
Share this: Facebook Twitter Stumbleupon Reddit Email + More
TrackBacks
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://scienceblogs.com/mt/pings/61581









Comments
Interesting, I'm glad you posted about this, I saw it while killing time in the campus bookstore last week and made a mental note to buy it after my next paycheck, now I may reconsider that, at least wait for the used/paperback price to get it and critique it myself...when I see you this weekend, remind me to tell you about a book I would love to see you review/dissect/demolish.
Posted by: Anne-Marie | January 17, 2008 10:23 AM
Here's a tip: Don't read a book (especially a popular one) about an animal that hasn't been formally described. I would not doubt that the book forms a "companion piece" to the Discovery Channel show. And how can there be few or no good illustrations of a freaking hadrosaur MUMMY? That boggles the mind. SHOW ME THE MUSCLE TISSUE!
Posted by: Zach Miller | January 17, 2008 3:23 PM
I was similarly disappointed in the Web site for which a link was provided on one of the blogs talking about the hadrosaur. It just didn't seem to be very informative about the specimen.
Posted by: mark | January 18, 2008 12:53 PM