Mike the Mad Biologist

While criticizing someone who does not understand the difference between artificial and natural selection–something I’ve successfully communicated to high school students and undergraduates–is like picking on the slow kid, his repeated nitpicking of ScienceBlogling Mike Dunford‘s post about the topic is illustrative of how creationists, whether they be young earth or intelligent design, operate.

Instead of dealing with Orac’s or my response, Egnor quibbles with Mike over exactly what he meant. It’s trolling, masquerading as intellectual discussion (and I had the same style of idiocy show up in the comments of my post, even though it’s quite obvious what I meant).

If Egnor were serious, he would offer a serious response to Orac or me.

He can’t.

But what’s more pathetic is that Egnor is at Stony Brook University, which has one of the perennially top-ranked Ecology and Evolution departments in the country. In five minutes, he could walk over to the Life Sciences Building, and discuss the issue. I’m sure the faculty, including Dan Dykhuizen, Walt Eanes, Doug Futuyma, or Jeff Levinton, might be able to help him out*. In particular, Dan Dykhuizen, who has been studying experimental evolution for over three decades, just might be able to clarify for Egnor the difference between artificial and natural selection.

But, of course, Egnor won’t do this because any of the mentioned faculty (or for that matter, any of their colleagues, including the students) would flatten him in seconds. Instead, he quibbles with graduate students about word choice in blog posts.

Next: Egnor and the Creationists: Partying Like It’s 1859.

*I like them, and have no desire to inflict an arrogant, pompous ass like Egnor of any of them, so I hope he doesn’t actually do this….


  1. #1 Umlud
    March 19, 2008

    In five minutes, he could walk over to the Life Sciences Building, and discuss the issue.

    But Mike, on his webpage, Egnor lists his address as: 24 RESEARCH WAY, EAST SETAUKET, NY. Consulting Google, this means a roughly 11-minute drive from his office to the life sciences building, which would be much further if walking. (He could walk through all the fields, but I think that it might be to much for the man.)

    Still, with all the transportation headaches that he must consider, it’s no wonder he could never make his way all the way over (the roughly 4.6 miles) to the life sciences building. And then he would have to figure out how to get to where he was going. No, you’re right: for Egnor’s sake, he should probably refrain from making the journey.

  2. #2 mirc
    March 19, 2009


The site is currently under maintenance. New comments have been disabled during this time, please check back soon.