Neuron Culture

A Must-See: Mirror Neurons in yo’ face

I opened my feature on mirror neurons for Scientific American Mind by telling how my son Nicholas imitated me sticking out my tongue in his first hour. I regret I can offer you no film of that.

Thanks to PLOS Biology, however, I can now offer you videos of a baby macaque monkey essentially doing the same — that is, imitating lip-smacking and sticking-out-of-the-tongue — in these video clips from “Neonatal Imitation in Rhesus Macaques” in PLOS Biology.

lipsmacking.jpg

Monkey see, monkey do.

On the left, imitation of mouth-opening; on the right, of “tongue protrusion”

______________________________________________

The photos above (not much, I admit) pale next to the videos of this little macaque watching and imitating the nattily garbed researcher. There’s also a video clip of a baby macaque in a more naturalistic setting, apparently imitating some mouth movements its mother makes during a break in nursing. (Nursing mothers, or mothers who have nursed, will flinch, as did my wife, when the monkey rather roughly releases the nipple to look up at the mother.)

The paper itself is a nice study of how imitation — the kind presumably driven and enabled by mirror neurons — takes particularly literal and robust form in the first hours and days of life. This quick, attentive imitation had largely disappeared by the time the monkeys were a week old; they paid close attention but didn’t necessarily imitate. Chimps and people tend to imitate these actions longer — possibly, the authors say, because “motor and cognitive development in macaques is much more rapid than in humans and chimpanzees.” They will leave their mothers to explore starting at a week, and they seem less interested in gazing at goofy faces at 2 weeks than people or chimps do.

I found it a particularly interesting paper — with a high fun factor, which never hurts. When you’ve absorbed the considerable neurosci interest you can take pleasure in the cute monkeys (though not as cute as our Nicholas!*) — and there’s an extra geeky pleasure in seeing how glamorous life in a neuro lab is.

*Bonus photo: My son Nicholas, 4 weeks old, imitating his dad’s smile:

nicksmiles.jpg

Comments

  1. #1 John Wagner
    September 12, 2006

    As a non-expert, just curious if mirror neurons are the same neurons /family of neurons that enable “visual tracking” by such animals as baby ducks.

  2. #2 David Dobbs
    September 12, 2006

    I don’t believe anyone has investigated mirror neurons in ducks. But as I understand it, the issue of tracking and visual attention is considered largely separate from that of imitation or of mirror neurons, which are actually premotor neurons (that is, neurons that fire early in a sequence of orders that cause you to open your mouth, stick out your tongue, or what not) that fire both when we perform an action and when we watch someone else perform an action. You have premotor neurons for tongue protrusion, in other words, that fire not only when you stick out your tongue but when you watch the monkey video, even if you don’t then stick out your tongue.

    More, of course, is the my article on mirror neurons as well as other literature.