In the saturation coverage right after the events, the "expert" talking heads are compelled to offer theories about the causes and consequences. In the following days and weeks, newspapers and magazine will have their theories too. Looking back, we can see that all such efforts are futile. The shootings never mean anything. Forty years later, what did the Charles Whitman massacre "mean"? A decade later, do we "know" anything about Columbine? There is chaos and evil in life. Some people go crazy. In America, they do so with guns; in many countries, with knives; in Japan, sometimes poison.We know the emptiness of these events in retrospect, though we suppress that knowledge when the violence erupts as it is doing now. The cable-news platoons tonight are offering all their theories and thought-drops. They've got to fill time. I wish they could stop. As the Vietnam-era saying went, Don't mean nothing.
Neuron Culture
David Dobbs on science, nature, and culture.
Search
Profile
I write on science, medicine, nature, culture and other matters for the New York Times Magazine, The Atlantic, Slate, National Geographic, Scientific American Mind, and other publications. (Find clips here.)
I've also written three books, including Reef Madness: Charles Darwin, Alexander Agassiz, and the Meaning of Coral, which traces the strangest but most forgotten controversy in Darwin's career — an elemental dispute running some 75 years. Oliver Sacks found Reef Madness "brilliantly written, almost unbearably poignant." Check it out.
If you'd like, you can subscribe to Neuron Culture by email. You might also want to see more of my work at my main website or check out my Tumblr log.
My Google Shared links
Recent Posts
- Best blog post title of the day: "I will suck your gruyere"
- Roz Chast's "finite filing cabinet model" of memory confirmed
- The Neurocritic: Genomarketing!
- Senator Asks Pentagon To Review Antidepressants
- Raymond Tallis trashtalks some "Neurotrash"
- I'm not vulnerable, just especially plastic. Risk genes, environment, and evolution, in the Atlantic
- Fallows on the Fort Hood shootings: "Don't mean nothing."
- Gorgeous thing of the day: Sky's-eye view of the Maldives & other islands
- "The male approaches with his thumbs (like the Fonz) and mounts the female (like the Fonz.)"
- Quick dip: Healthcare reform, conflicted profs, and the vaccine shortage
Recent Comments
- Jason Seidel on I'm not vulnerable, just especially plastic. Risk genes, environment, and evolution, in the Atlantic
- Meat Robot on I'm not vulnerable, just especially plastic. Risk genes, environment, and evolution, in the Atlantic
- Neelu Chitrapu on I'm not vulnerable, just especially plastic. Risk genes, environment, and evolution, in the Atlantic
- Tsutsugamushi on Roz Chast's "finite filing cabinet model" of memory confirmed
- Polonius on Roz Chast's "finite filing cabinet model" of memory confirmed
- Charles Jonassaint on I'm not vulnerable, just especially plastic. Risk genes, environment, and evolution, in the Atlantic
- tbell1 on Raymond Tallis trashtalks some "Neurotrash"
- Jeff on Senator Asks Pentagon To Review Antidepressants
- bsci on Raymond Tallis trashtalks some "Neurotrash"
- julia on I'm not vulnerable, just especially plastic. Risk genes, environment, and evolution, in the Atlantic
Categories
- Art
- Books
- Brains and minds
- Culture of science
- Digital culture
- Economics
- Education
- Environment/nature
- Evolution
- Food and Drink
- Healthcare policy
- History/philosophy of science
- Interesting if true...
- Journalism
- Matters military
- Media
- Medicine
- Music
- Neuroethics
- Nota Bene
- Orchids & Dandelions (behav genetics)
- PTSD
- Pharma
- Politics
- Psychiatry
- Reading
- Science
- Science policy
- Sports
- Swine flu
- Writing
« Gorgeous thing of the day: Sky's-eye view of the Maldives & other islands | Main | I'm not vulnerable, just especially plastic. Risk genes, environment, and evolution, in the Atlantic »
Fallows on the Fort Hood shootings: "Don't mean nothing."
Posted on: November 7, 2009 5:18 AM, by David Dobbs
Share this: Facebook Twitter Stumbleupon Reddit Email + More
TrackBacks
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://scienceblogs.com/mt/pings/124248




Comments
I just heard on the news that Fort Hood is upping security to make it difficult for 'just anybody' to come on base.
What?
Right. After a trusted insider, an Army lifer, goes on a killing spree, the correct response is to deter civilians from coming on base.
Security theater. It's like a Punch and Judy show, only without the humor, and at a phenomenal cost.
Posted by: CRM-114 | November 7, 2009 10:54 AM