The Quantum Pontiff

Monte Hall and Cognitive Dissonance

Did the Monte Hall problem, trip up a huge number of psychologists? So claims this New York Times article. For a good detailed explanation see here. For even more detail see the actual paper.


  1. #1 Pieter Kok
    April 8, 2008

    The money quote: I doubt that his critique will be all that influential for the field of cognitive dissonance more broadly.

    Independent proof of CD?

  2. #2 Joshua Zelinsky
    April 8, 2008

    Pieter, there are a variety of other lines of evidence for the existence, nature and extent of cognitive dissonance so it isn’t like that this point will that large an influence on matters. It doesn’t take any cognitive dissonance to think that. Indeed, I suspect that if this phenomenon were not confirmed by other lines of evidence someone would have noticed this problem already.

  3. #3 Michael Bacon
    April 8, 2008

    What’s interesting about the article is that the answer goes against our intuition that, with two unopened doors left, the odds are 50-50 that the car is behind one of them. Your first guess has a one in three chance of being right, but the second happens 2 out of 3 times.
    What do you think?

New comments have been temporarily disabled. Please check back soon.