1. purepedantry
  2. ScienceBlogs Must-Read: Nisbet on Framing in Terms of Economic Competitiveness

ScienceBlogs Must-Read: Nisbet on Framing in Terms of Economic Competitiveness

By purepedantry on August 13, 2007.

If you haven't read this post by Matthew Nisbet at Framing Science, you really, really should. It shows how framing scientific issues in terms of jobs and economic competitiveness is much more likely to pass funding bills:

As I've noted here many times, major funding initiatives for science are mostly likely to be successful in winning support from policymakers under conditions where they can be exclusively defined in terms of economic competitiveness and growth. If opponents are unable to recast elements of the proposal in terms of public accountability (funding in the public vs private interest) or elements of the funding bill in terms of morality (specific to stem cell, reproductive research etc) then a bill is most likely to pass.

Read the whole thing.

Tags
Funding
Other People's Work

More like this

It's the Economy, Stupid! Framing Propels Major Science Bill
As Science reports, the big news this week is that Congress passed a bill that adopts almost all of the recommendations of the 2005 National Academies report Rising Above the Gathering Storm: Energizing and Employing America. The bill was signed this morning by President Bush. The unprecedented…
National Academies: Framing & State Policy Advice
Over the summer I addressed by video conference a meeting by the National Academies on state science policy advice. They've now produced a report based on that meeting and it is free as a PDF download. Chapter Five of the report focuses on the communication of science advice at the state level…
A Reply to Former House Science Chair Sherwood Boehlert
On May 3, as part of the annual AAAS Forum on Science & Technology Policy, retired Congressman Sherwood Boehlert (R-NY), the former chair of the House Science & Technology committee, gave the keynote William Carey lecture (full text). In his address, he devoted several pages of his speech…
How Hillary Frames Science: Social Progress, Economic Development, and Public Accountability
Without necessarily intending to, in her speech last week Hillary Clinton demonstrated just how irrelevant some criticisms of the "framing science" thesis have been. Consider: Hillary is a politician, and she wants to deliver a message about science--a vastly complex subject with many diverse…