Seed Media Group

Reality is always more complicated than you think.

Profile

jake-head-shot.jpgJake Young is a MD/PhD student at Mount Sinai School of Medicine focusing in Neuroscience. He is due to graduate in 2032. He received a BS and a MS in Biological Sciences from Stanford University -- where he spent most of his time drinking heavily and building vegetable catapults instead of learning information that would now be eminently useful. When he is not failing terrifically to perform his sworn duties, he enjoys watching bad movies, ethnic food, and running.

Pure Pedantry is a blog about science -- social sciences and otherwise -- as well as academic and scientific culture. No one can live on science alone, so I also like to dwell on pop culture, periodically explore the humanities, and indulge in other types of geeky goodness.

Jake is joined periodically by two wonderful guest bloggers: Kara Contreary and Kate Seip. See the About Page.

DISCLAIMERS: 1) Jake Young is not a licensed physician (yet). He is merely a medical student. The information published on this site is not intended for use in medical decision making. Please seek advice from a licensed, medical professional before making any health decisions. 2) The opinions expressed are my own or those of my co-bloggers. They do not represent the views of SEED magazine or the educational establishments we currently attend.

Search this blog

Archives

Blogroll


raptor.jpg

« Drew Carey of Kidney Donor Sales | Main | On the list of the singularly most ridiculous things that have ever happened... »

Say It Ain't So: Beer Consumption Lowers Scientific Productivity

Category: Alcohol
Posted on: March 20, 2008 1:33 PM, by Jake Young

I refuse to accept the results of this study:

After years of argument over the roles of factors like genius, sex and dumb luck, a new study shows that something entirely unexpected and considerably sudsier may be at play in determining the success or failure of scientists -- beer.

According to the study, published in February in Oikos, a highly respected scientific journal, the more beer a scientist drinks, the less likely the scientist is to publish a paper or to have a paper cited by another researcher, a measure of a paper's quality and importance.

The results were not, however, a matter of a few scientists having had too many brews to be able to stumble back to the lab. Publication did not simply drop off among the heaviest drinkers. Instead, scientific performance steadily declined with increasing beer consumption across the board, from scientists who primly sip at two or three beers over a year to the sort who average knocking back more than two a day.

As they point out later in the article, this study may has several limitations. The first is that the results may not generalize. Czechs have a high rate of beer consumption, and the correlation may not apply elsewhere. Also, correlation does not equal causation. The heavy beer drinkers might have some other factor in their lives that accounts for poor performance which is also related with high beer consumption -- perhaps marital stress or difficulty in dealing with people. Finally, it could that beer consumption is the effect rather than the cause of poor performance -- the article refers to this as the "drowning your sorrows" effect.

In spite of those caveats, I have a solution to make everyone happy. Want to increase your scientific productivity? Drink more vodka.

Hat-tip: Slashdot

Comments

I agree with the study completely. I was to have been the next Richard P Feynman. At the age of 19, I worked out a way to contain the heat from a controlled fusion reaction in order to obtain useable energy. Then came the service and a mind numbing series of beer drinking sessions (lasting from 1963-2002). Alas I've forgotten how I did it.

Posted by: Edward Ingram | March 20, 2008 1:50 PM

Read the actual study. It's pretty weak and the line-fit is atrocious. I posted about it too (under almost the exact same title).

Posted by: MarkH | March 20, 2008 2:54 PM

Sounds like a reasonable way to escape the burden of publishing. I'll drink to that.

Posted by: JohnQPublic | March 20, 2008 8:47 PM

Post a Comment

(Email is required for authentication purposes only. Comments are moderated for spam, your comment may not appear immediately. Thanks for waiting.)





Having problems commenting? (UPDATED)

Blogs in the Network

Advertisement

Top Five: Readers' Picks

Search All Blogs

Top Science Stories

powered by SEED - seedmagazine.com