SciencePunk

i-11bc9a33c8ea9cb1161dac6f04a3ab1d-texastower.jpg

On January 15, 1961, the US coastguard raced through the darkness toward a tiny point 84 miles southeast of New York City. There, 28 crew members of Texas Tower 4 were waiting desperately to be evacuated from their station. As huge swells and high winds pounded the hull of the ship, their radios picked up a frantic transmission from the tower: “We’re breaking up”. And with that, Texas Tower 4 and all of its occupants were pulled beneath the waves.


Built in 1957, the five Texas Towers were intended to become part of the USA’s advanced early warning system against Soviet bombers. Named for their resemblance to oil platforms found in the Gulf of Mexico, the towers were radar platforms designed to be placed out to sea. Towers 1 and 5 were never built. Towers 2 and 3 were situated on the rocky seabed off Nantucket and Boston respectively. Tower 4 posed a much greater challenge, as it needed to be placed in waters twice as deep and on a soft bed of sand and mud. Nevertheless, engineers described the final design as a “triumph”. The 3,200 ton triangular structure stood on three legs, each 100m long and 4m thick. These were supported by cross braces and were hollow so that they could be used to store fuel and freshwater. It cost $21 million, and would be manned by 50 Air Force officers and enlisted men.

However, floated out to location in 1957, things went wrong immediately. Foreshadowing what was in store, the tugs towing the structure were hit by a vicious gale. During the storm, two of the huge leg braces were torn off. Engineers decided it would be better to fix the rig at sea rather than tow it back to shore for repairs. Divers attached new braces to the legs, but the first crew members found the entire tower unstable, rolling and bucking in the swell. In August of 1959, Hurricane Daisy battered the isolated base, causing severe damage. The crew were evacuated while $500,000 of repairs were carried out.  You can see the modifications for yourself – in the video and illustration three slender legs are above the waterline; while the other pictures show a skirt of metal reinforcements added at a later date. The following year, Hurricane Donna pounded the tower with 130mph winds, weakening the legs further. By this point, Texas Tower 4 had acquired a new name: Old Shaky, told with grim humour. As well as rocking from side to side, the platform twisted and leaned, creaking horribly as it did. The hollow legs amplified the sound of waves slapping against them, creating a constant booming cacophony. Visitors were warned not to shave with straight edged razors lest a sudden lurch cause them to slit their throat. Texas Tower 4 was an unpleasant, scary place to live, with the crew in constant fear that they would be pitched into the freezing ocean.

i-567edf0be6b787a77b739f939e0f89b4-texastower3.jpg

In November 1960, all but 14 crew members were evacuated from the tower and 14 civilian workers were brought in to carry out emergency repairs. They attempted to fill the legs with sand and concrete, hoping to stabilise the platform. Conditions worsened throughout winter. The tower bucked and heaved, throwing the airmen and contractors to the ground. The movements were so violent the welders couldn’t work on the damaged legs. Commanding officer Captain Gordon Phelan made repeated requests to have the platform evacuated, in vain. Air Force heads refused to abandon the tower, fearing that nearby Russian trawlers harboured spies eager to steal the radar technology. Commander Sheppard later wrote “you don’t just walk off and leave millions of dollars of radar equipment lying around untended”.

i-93b0ad3152ae6bed1a08c70e8be88318-texastower2.jpg

On January 14, weather forecasts warned of squalls developing with winds reaching 60 knots. On board Texas Tower 4, a deafening crack echoed across the platform, and Old Shaky began to sway horribly – another brace had snapped. An evacuation order was finally granted at 4pm, too late. Coastguard and Air Force rescue helicopters were grounded, waiting for a lull in the storm. Nearby vessels rushed to the stricken tower’s aid. At 6:45pm, Texas Tower 4 made its final transmission. From the bridge of the Navy supply ship T-AKL 17, just a few miles away, Captain Mangual watched the radar image of Tower 4 fade from view as the structure crumbled into the sea. When the rescue ships arrived, just one body was pulled from the water. The remaining 27 had been dragged to the bottom with the remains of Old Shaky.

The regional commanding officer in charge of the Texas Towers faced a court martial but was acquitted. A subsequent Senate investigation found serious errors and lapses in judgement along the entire command chain. To make matters worse, almost as soon as they were built, the Texas Towers had been rendered obsolete by the advent of Soviet long range missiles. Towers 2 and 3 were decommissioned and dismantled in 1963. The wreck of Tower 4 still lies under 60m of frigid water, inhabited by sharks, dolphins, turtles, and the occasional visiting diver. In 1999, a plaque was fixed to the submerged leg of the tower. It lists the names of the 28 victims who perished on that cold January night, victims of military and engineering hubris.

Comments

  1. #1 Katie Lunn
    May 4, 2010

    How tragic and in the end it was just the greed and stupidity of business that caused those 28 to loose their lives.

  2. #2 Cain
    May 4, 2010

    @Katie Lunn
    Umm…What?

    Texas Tower 4 was a US military radar station. Nether the greed nor the stupidity of business had anything to do with it. If I had to guess, the tragedy would be properly attributed to fear of a sworn enemy along with a healthy dose of pride and ass saving from general officers….along with mother nature.

    I would add a link to my source but all you really need to do is read the post you are commenting on.

    : )

  3. #3 Michael Firstman
    May 4, 2010

    Amazing story. What futility. Especially in light of the fact that the towers were almost instantly rendered obsolete by ICBM technology…yet they struggled to continue using them anyway. What a waste of manpower and resources. I can hardly imagine the struggle and hardship of the workers, like the welders, as they attempted repairs in such highly dangerous conditions, ultimately in vain. Another fascinating chapter in the annals of military history.

    Michael Firstman
    Publisher
    http://www.welders360.com

  4. #4 John
    May 4, 2010

    True enough that neither greed nor stupidity of business were at fault. The engineering was flawed and untested for the most part and the military was trying to get it done on the cheap, as the cost increased due to the greater water depth of the site where it was placed. The result was predictable and warnings were most likely unheeded, and after all was said and done, the generals pointed fingers until confusion resulted and the investigations stopped due to the confusion.

    That is the case today with Major Hasan, the butcher of Fort Hood. Neither the Army nor the White House are allowing Senate inquiry as to how Hasan, a known malcontent, was allowed to continue serving, let alone be promoted.

    Basically, when it’s your hind end you’ve got to cover, you and your cronies will point the finger until no one can know what really occurred and the matter can never be sorted out.

  5. “Loose their lives”????
    What is wrong with English education?

  6. #6 John S. Wilkins
    May 6, 2010

    Perhaps they were slackers?

  7. #7 F.M.Chilcott
    January 18, 2011

    There is a record of the congressional investigation of
    the TT4 debacle which makes for great reading and sheds
    much light on the failures of AF high brass. Unfortunately there were several dedicated and honest, and highly capable officers whose careers were ruined by the mistakes of their superiors. I left the tower 368 days before it failed after serving a year aboard it.

  8. #8 Frank the SciencePunk
    January 19, 2011

    @7 F. M. Chilcott
    Thanks for the comment, interested to know what your experiences of TT4 were like. I wonder where the division lay between those who thought it should remain and those (with a first hand experience most likely) who thought it should be abandoned.

  9. #9 Downeasta
    June 29, 2011

    Saw Don Slutsky Lecture tonite at the NAS (Naval Air Station) in Wildwood, NJ. Am glad for those who perished finally got closure from the higher Ups.
    Thank you Sen Kerry

    Downeasta,
    Merrimack River

    PS would like more info on the USCG Cutter W127 that was there; Where did she originate berth from ?? (history lesson)

  10. #10 Donald Rio
    August 4, 2011

    I was in the USAF stationed at Stewart AFB New York when Texas Tower 4 went down. That evening I was in the Communications Center and was taking calls at the telephone switch board. A few days before I knew the tower was in trouble and I would call them via the switch board and talk to some of the Airmen. If my memory serves me right, some of them were from Bristol CT. I was then from New Britain CT and very interested in their problem.
    The evening the tower went down, a call from the Captain came into the switch board asking for Col. Banks. I plugged into Col. Banks port and rang his phone. The Captain asked permission to evacuate. Col. Banks gave him the OK but stated all material and equipment must be destroyed before evacuation. By this time it was too late. A few hours later I was told Texas Tower 4 went down.

  11. #11 Frank Gorman
    March 5, 2012

    Downeasta: The OLD USCGC Alert (W127) was a “buck and a quarter”, i.e. “125 footer” She’s still afloat as a museum! See video:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vGcnjqV6vMU

    A recently deceased friend of mine was on a CG 95′ Patrol Boat that also responded. The Alert was either homeported in Cape May, NJ or St. George Staten Island at the time.

    Frank Gorman
    MCPO, USCGR

  12. #12 Barry Crawford
    USA
    July 25, 2012

    I was out in that horrific storm that night, very near that area where the tower went down. I was aboard the “Atlantis” out of Woods Hole and we were on our way to San Miguel in the Azores. I was taking a break from college (UNH) and It was my first trip aboard the beautiful old 142 ft Woods Hole Oceanographic sailing ketch. What a baptism for a 20 year old kid from Cape Cod! I was aboard as a member of the deck crew assigned to sail the vessel and we spent that night in absolute fear of losing our own ship. The seas were frightening and the winds were hurricane force with the rain and sleet stinging right through our foul weather gear. The “jumbo”, a storm jib used to stabilize the boat while she was “hove to” (abeam of the seas) , broke free from her clew and in the violent wind, the heavy canvas sail shredded like it was a kleenex tissue. After we managed to get it under control, we saw that the spliced eye on the sail had completely turned within it’s splice 180 degrees! That was one powerful storm!
    There was no GPS, or modern navigation aids or radio contact so we did not know about this tragedy until much later on in the voyage.

  13. #13 Lee Jackson
    Pennsylvania
    September 14, 2012

    I was closely involved with one of the families whose loved one was lost at sea that night and none of the explanations or excuses served to help at that terrible time.

  14. #14 Jerry Sinanian
    shelton connecticut
    January 14, 2013

    Tomorrow marks the 62nd anniversary of the loss of USAF TEXAS TOWER #4 and lives of the airman and civilians lost at sea. May God have mercey on their souls. These men have not been forgotten by the close family of the 4604th Support Sq. families. I had the honor to serve aboard Texas Tower #3 from Jan 1960 to Apr 1961.

  15. #15 Scott Denman
    Belmont, Maine
    March 23, 2013

    I was in the 5th grade when the Texas Tower 4 went down. My neighbor and friend Mark ?? was the son of one who served on that deathtrap. Mark moved away soon after the disaster. I never knew what happened to him and his family until I saw a video about the Tower and Mark’s brother was prominent in the film.

    My mother and father organ ized a fundraising drive by making small replicas of the Towers and distributing them all over Cape Cod at diners, convenience stores, shopping markets, and other places. I remember seeing a picture in the Falmouth Enterprise of myself and my brothers in our Cub Scout uniforms painting the miniature Towers in preparation for the fundraising effort. I think a decent amount of money was raised, but can’t remember how much or how if was distributed to the families of the dead service men and contractors.

    Does anyone know the names of those who died? I’d like to track down my friend even though we are both 60 years old now.

    Thanks,

    Scott Denman