More offsetting woes

A colleague told me about an interesting article I’d missing in the grauniad: The inconvenient truth about the carbon offset industry. Which I fear merely confirms my lack of trust of these things.

The main point was that a number of companies are doing offsetting by buying up EU emissions credits and then retiring them. However, since these things are in surplus the prices are very low and retiring them does nothing useful. Other than make money for the middleman, presumably. And, if you don’t inquire to closely, allowing you to wipe away your guilt.

An amusing side-issue in the article concerned British Airways attempts: because of a conflict between those who wanted to promote offsetting, and those who would rather not mention climate change at all, the scheme has hardly had any take-up.

And lastly The British government itself has been caught out over emissions from its presidency of the G8 in 2005. The then environment secretary, Margaret Beckett, said that all carbon emissions from all meetings and travel linked with the one-year presidency would be neutralised. Delegates to the Gleneagles summit in July 2005 were given certificates declaring that all their carbon emissions were being offset. But it hasn’t happened. Because of foul-ups in setting up the scheme. So you can’t even trust the govenment (whats new?) on something as basic as “yes we’ve managed to at least in theory offset your emissions”.

Comments

  1. #1 SCM
    2007/06/19

    I hope you’ll forgive an off topic reply to point out another newspaper article in that herald-of-doom otherwise known as the Independent. It is a front-pager featuring a paper (Phil Trans R. Soc. A) by Hansen et al talking about collapsing ice-shelves and the possibility of scary sea-level rises of metres in a century.
    Newspaper article: The Earth today stands in imminent peril
    The Hansen paper is here. The “imminent peril” quote comes from the paper itself (in subsection (d)):

    (d ) Planet Earth today: imminent peril
    The imminent peril is initiation of dynamical and thermodynamical processes
    on the West Antarctic and Greenland ice sheets that produce a situation out of
    humanity’s control…”

    Anyway I’d be interested to hear the collective views on this. Are Hansen and Co at odds with what other scientists are measuring/predicting or are they raising a reasonable concern?

    They are certainly going for fairly strong language by scientific standards.

  2. #2 Zeke
    2007/06/19

    At least in theory, offsets are not a bad idea, but in the absence of any uniform standards or regulation you run into a lot of problems with the authenticity of various schemes. For example, I’ve heard through the grapevine about a few VER (voluntary emissions reduction) projects here in India that have sold the same reductions to multiple offset companies. The absence of a strict additionality standard for VERs means that a lot of projects that would have been done anyway get passed off as actual emissions reductions.

    The current offset market is also extremely underpriced, as its picking the proverbial low-hanging fruit of emissions reductions. As more countries begin to adopt a carbon price (via taxes or tradable permits), and as more methodologies are approved for certifying emission reductions (CERs) for CDM markets, we can expect voluntary prices to rise accordingly.

    Frankly, if an organization wants to make a real gesture today, given the problems with the voluntary markets, they should just buy CDM CERs or phase two EU ETS credits.

  3. #3 mz
    2007/06/19

    Offsets should be very toughly regulated and supervised.
    They are not fundamentally flawed.

  4. #4 Luna_the_cat
    2007/06/19

    One of the things they don’t mention as a problem with the tree-planting schemes such as ClimateCare run, but which I’m sure I’ve seen flagged up in Science, is the fact that carbon credits are granted for planting trees, but not currently for preserving them. It is possible to create and sell carbon offset credits by clear-cutting existing forest and replanting with pine monocultures, which is just a bit crap.

  5. #5 Luboš Motl
    2007/06/19

    You can now buy carbon debits to offset the impact of carbon credits.

    http://carboncreditkillers.com/

  6. #6 fergus
    2007/06/19

    There is no chance of carbon-offsetting having any impact whilst governments ‘grandfather’ the allowances to emitters. Making them pay, however, for their credits, would be seen as restrictive and ‘recessionary’. In any case, as things stand, a market in carbon is not, and is unlikely to result in actual reductions in emissions.Arguably, the offsetting mechanisms will also fail to contribute (a tree must live in the right part of the world for 100 years to offset the relevant amount of carbon dioxide). If offsetting is merely a mechanism for the transfer of funds from developed to developing nations, with conditions attached, I am sure some other mechanism would be more effective and reliable.

    In the meantime, I recommend the purchase of sections of rainforest and the use of such ownership to prevent any deforestation exercise in that area. If enough of us bought enough of the land/forest, and set it aside, it might make some useful impact. it might also encourage our governments to do the same. In the end, we have to make it economically more worthwhile for developing nations not to cut down forests, one way or another. Then we need to increase our own energy efficiency (especially in power generation) by 50% or better; these will result in a slowdown of CO2 emissions.

  7. #7 Zeke
    2007/06/20

    Actually, fergus, the decision to grandfather or auction permits has no real bearing on voluntary emissions markets (other than by lowering consumer discretionary spending, but that a negligible effect). Permit systems are interesting in that the explicitly separate efficiency and equity criteria. The efficiency of the system is solely determined by the number of the permits in the system, while the equity of the system is determined by the initial distribution of permits. Changing the initial distribution can make the system less regressive, but cannot do much to change its efficiency in generating actual emissions reductions.

    That said, in light of the windfall profits to regulated power producers in the EU ETS phase one, many systems are moving toward auctioning more permits.

  8. #8 Adam
    2007/06/20

    Sort of off-topic, but Monbiot does answer questions about this in his Guardian Q&A today:

    http://environmenttalk.guardian.co.uk/WebX?128@757.llJtcavuKqn@.775eaab4

  9. #9 Magnus W
    2007/06/21

    I don’t agree with all of it but this is interesting to read, http://www.carbontradewatch.org/pubs/carbon_neutral_myth.pdf

  10. #10 Hank Roberts
    2007/07/06

    Buried at the bottom of the article:

    “the very idea of offsetting relies on what is known as additionality – evidence that a carbon reduction would not have occurred in the natural order of commercial life. …

    “One measure of the crisis is the progress of the gold standard scheme, which is backed by Greenpeace and other environmental groups as a particularly rigorous process to ensure that emission reductions are verified, additional and consistent with sustainable development. …. has registered seven projects, two of which have so far produced some 350,000 tonnes of verified gold standard carbon reductions. And suddenly, as so many other projects struggle with uncertainty, it has unfilled orders for eight million more.”

  11. #11 KaseyHaley
    2011/09/18

    The home loans are very useful for guys, which are willing to organize their own career. In fact, this is easy to get a auto loan.

  12. #12 EllenBartlett30
    2011/09/24

    Do you acknowledge that this is high time to get the business loans, which will make you dreams real.

  13. #13 Bettye18Nichols
    2011/10/26

    Buildings are not cheap and not every person is able to buy it. However, business loans are created to aid people in such situations.

  14. #14 AugustaHouston23
    2011/10/29

    If you are in not good state and have got no money to move out from that point, you will have to take the home loans. Just because it should help you for sure. I take small business loan every time I need and feel OK because of that.

  15. #15 Summer27GUERRA
    2011/10/30

    Different people in every country receive the home loans from various creditors, because it is simple.

  16. #16 Justine31Schwartz
    2011/11/02

    The credit loans are very useful for people, which would like to organize their company. By the way, that’s not very hard to receive a student loan.

  17. #17 Meredith18Cook
    2011/11/03

    I received 1 st loan when I was not very old and that aided my family very much. However, I need the consolidation loans once more time.

  18. #18 BaileyEricka23
    2011/12/21

    Specialists tell that loan aid people to live the way they want, because they are able to feel free to buy needed goods. Moreover, banks present sba loan for different persons.

  19. #19 Rosie29Mccullough
    2012/01/12

    It’s great that we are able to receive the loan moreover, it opens up new opportunities.

  20. #20 MARQUITARusso19
    2012/02/11

    Lots of guys just are talking about high quality! I claim that to buy an essay supposes to be reasonable.

  21. #21 ROACHLourdes24
    2012/02/13

    Would like to satisfy your essay writing requirements and don’t understand in what way? Take it easy and just find essay writing service.

  22. #22 Barber22Gena
    2012/02/19

    Do you opine that’s very easy to check your academic papers? It can be more difficult than you opine. Furthermore, you should surely utilize online plagiarism checker to assure that everything is OK with your texts.

  23. #23 SantiagoFreda34
    2012/02/22

    Are you able to complete the literary essays overnight? Not exactly? Thus the essay writing service would make it for you.

  24. #24 OrtizORA
    2012/02/23

    My attention is always focused on students’ writing plagiarism. I opine that people need to utilize the essay writing services when they are pressured by time and cannot to write term essays by their own but not when they are indolent!

  25. #25 GATESShelly
    2012/02/29

    Want to find cheap music and movies essay paper? That is not a problem, just check custom writing services, which propose the essay.

  26. #26 LINDSAYCarolyn23
    2012/03/10

    Here are some suggestions about the correct way to get the academic grade. Therefore, you require read through the knowledge and compose the superior sports essay. The other way is to look for the professional custom essay writing service and just order essay online. Hope that would help people.

  27. #27 JBL
    2012/03/12

    Hmm, your anti-spam software seems to have been outwitted by an army of spambots. :(

    [The anti-spam stuff here is junk. Moderation is back on. Oddly, about the only spam I get is thesis-writing stuff -W]

  28. #28 SteinDora35
    2012/03/14

    That’s very important to make the good europe essays and just essay to reach the excellent mark at the university.

  29. #29 FerrellLynda18
    2012/03/16

    How will you say that to buy term papers is right or not right If you don’t even try to visit the essay writing service? You have to try something before you say about it!

  30. #30 FRAZIER34Robyn
    2012/03/19

    I attempt to write all my academic papers writing assignments by my own. I can get Term papers for money only when I am short of time.

  31. #31 RochaSHERI
    2012/03/20

    College students try to search for easy paths. For example, college students want to buy Term paper samples online. that can make people otiose and it is not good for development of writing skills.

  32. #32 HANSENCarolyn26
    2012/03/21

    Make your own life time more easy take the business loans and everything you want.

  33. #33 Velazquez31MABEL
    2012/03/21

    If you try to find place where you can get buy resume here is very absolute place for you about this good post, which contribute examples and gives an occasion to learn how make great CV resumes . But this site is more captivating, and more important.

  34. #34 Williams35Virginia
    2012/03/29

    Often occupied guys are not able to manage optimization. Therefore, their business sites usually don’t get high PR. The social bookmarking submission services can definitely resolve that problem rapidly!

  35. #35 Nannie27Morgan
    2012/03/29

    I’m usually glad, just because I have got a possibility to buy essay. That supported a lot of times.

  36. #36 ClariceTanner34
    2012/04/04

    I generally find experts who work for the directory submission sites and submit my website to directories with the highest page rank! Therefore, I realize that my web business will become better!

  37. #37 MollieEngland19
    2012/04/05

    Statements of masters are very extremely important for me. I Order essay online utilizing the hints of experts.

  38. #38 MCCARTYEmilia
    2012/04/08

    People spend long time to reach the top of career. I state that it is more simple to purchase management thesis at dissertation writing service and relax. I opine, that will be a correct solution.

  39. #39 Kemp34Margie
    2012/04/08

    Fantastic article just about life! No doubts everyone approach whatever problems with buy dissertation. It is specially ambitious when you have got another benefit in life. I have had the aforesaid troubles until I have observe a company offer skilled writing services.

  40. #40 BenjaminLacey
    2012/04/19

    I would like to propose not to wait until you earn enough money to buy different goods! You should just get the business loans or credit loan and feel free

  41. #41 JoanLogan
    2012/04/20

    A lot of specialists tell that personal loans aid a lot of people to live their own way, because they can feel free to buy needed things. Moreover, a lot of banks present credit loan for young and old people.

  42. #42 Padilla33Mindy
    2012/05/07

    That’s great that people can get the loans and it opens up completely new opportunities.

  43. #43 CARMELLAMorin19
    2012/05/16

    Some time ago, I really needed to buy a building for my firm but I didn’t have enough money and couldn’t purchase something. Thank heaven my colleague proposed to get the credit loans at reliable bank. So, I acted so and used to be satisfied with my small business loan.

  44. #44 TrudyVelazquez
    2012/05/20

    Don’t you understand that it’s high time to receive the credit loans, which will make you dreams real.