Please Note! ScienceBlogs is taking a break while we upgrade the system. Read on for more...

Who am I?

jml07.jpg

John M. Lynch is an Honors Faculty Fellow at Barrett the Honors College at Arizona State University. He's also affiliated with ASU's Center for Biology & Society. When he's not an historian of anti-evolutionism, he's an evolutionary morphologist. Much to his surprise, in 2007 he was named the Arizona Professor of the Year. No doubt his students were surprised as well.

Search

Social Networking

Currently Reading


cover

cover

cover

cover

Always Reading

Recent Posts

Recent Comments

Categories

Archives

Bloggers I have met

Fighting the Good Fight

Other Stuff

Subscribe via Email

Stay abreast of your favorite bloggers' latest and greatest via e-mail, via a daily digest.

Sign me up!

« Crack open a can | Main | Don't eat the yellow snow »

Rainbow and Lightning

Category: Bits and Pieces
Posted on: July 14, 2006 7:30 AM, by John Lynch

Click for bigger version

This is cool. A rainbow and lightning in Arkansas (source). But the comments appear to miss the point of basic physics:

Incidents like this make we wonder how some people say there is no God.

The pictures are truly amazing!! Proving outright the power and existance of a higher power.

I, too, witnessed the rainbow in the sky last night. It was an awesome experience. It reminded me that God is really in control.

While the newspaper running the story is British, the comments about God are American. No surprises.

Comments

#1

God is in control ... because of a strange weather phenomenon?

Is there anything that doesn't validate "god is in control"? And thus anything that's the slightest bit meaningful about the statement?

Posted by: The Ridger | July 14, 2006 9:01 PM

#2

There's nothing like an overly religious justification to take some of the pleasure out of a beautiful natural phenomenon. As for proving the existence of a higher power, it certainly did. We call it electricity.

As for the picture, it really puts my one and only successful lightning-and-rainbow photograph to shame.
http://static.flickr.com/34/122816315_32bf99236d_o.jpg

Posted by: PaulM | July 15, 2006 7:30 PM

#3

Even when God misses, his failures receive praise:
Lightning zeros in on teenager's tunes


Article Launched: 07/06/2006 01:00:00 AM MDT
By Felisa Cardona
Denver Post Staff Writer
.
Castle Rock - Jason Bunch was listening to Metallica on his iPod while mowing the lawn outside his Castle Rock home Sunday afternoon when lightning hit him.
...
Bunch's mother recalled the death of a motorcyclist who was hit by lightning on U.S. 36 last month and expressed relief that her son's life was spared.
.
"It's a miracle," she said. "He should not have lived through it."

Posted by: wamba | July 16, 2006 4:24 PM

#4

Uhm. Let's see. You need rain and sun for a rainbow. For the retroreflectors to work, you need the sun to your back. A thunderstorm will work.

I've seen four rainbows this year. None have been during thunderstorms. That's probably because i'm not usually outside during thunderstorms. Now that i have a cheap digital camera, i snap lots of pictures of rainbows. Often, they're shot from inside the car. I generally only actually see rainbows about half the time i notice both rain and Sun.

This is a really cool photo.

Posted by: Stephen Uitti | July 17, 2006 10:42 AM

#5

Here are some other idiotic comments:

Incidents like this make we wonder how some people say there is no God.

Awesome pictures, looks like a cross in one of the photos. He is coming!

My children and I were leaving our Bible study last night as the light show you reported was taking place over our heads. We were completely amazed, having never seen such a sight. We actually saw the most vibrant rainbow, its mirror image, and a very faint partial rainbow near the first. We just knew that God was rewarding us with that beautiful sight and we knew we might never see anything like it again. Thanks for sharing your pictures.

Yeah, that's pure creationist thinking. "OH, it so beautiful, complex, I can't understand how natural forces could have produced this! Therefore, (the triune) GOD must have done it!" I guess in Arkansas' schools, basic physics courses don't involve a discussion of electricity. They must do bible study when they get to anything complicated.

Posted by: Chad | July 17, 2006 8:13 PM

#6

Can anybody explain how that happened without using God/Lord to me. (I mean phyics)

Posted by: twinklelove | October 28, 2006 6:25 AM

#7

Hm... this proves my theroy to be true. Sorry but most of today's scientist's won't talk a lot about God, and I finaly understand why. Most people won't talk about anything that they can't see with there eyes or touch with there hands. Many people won't talk about God either because they're scared to, or they just can't explain him. It takes a real scientist to ask about God, and that's alright, but in this day God is put down and not talked about as if he doesn't exist!! If this is true then there is no meaning in life whatsoever. To come out with the truth, I don't believe that. I'm a Christian interested in learning about the World and how it works based on the way that God created it to work. It's really interesting when we understand the world through the eyes of the creator. Sure there are many different religions out there, and I have studied most all of them, but the only one that has evidence to support it is Christianity. I don't mean to offend any of you who are reading this. I am merely practicing my freedom of speech and stating what I believe. You say the Big Bang denies God. I say it proves the Bible right. God said let there be light and it was so! Do you see what I'm saying? Also, I am not saying that you have to change your beliefs. That's why God gave us all free will. Well anyway, I'm ready for your insults, as I know they're coming. That will prove my theory even more. A scientist is someone who asks a question and then tries to answer it. As for the lightning and the rainbow, truly a remarkable sight! How awsome our God is!

Posted by: Steven | March 14, 2007 5:10 PM

#8

Datz WIkid...:D... I Love Dat Pic

Posted by: Beckaa | March 30, 2007 8:14 AM

#9

not to insult anyone, but "oh god!"

If there's no god, there's no meaning to life? ... well, obviously you can back this up with evidence so how can I dispute?

I'm not here to insult you, and I have no interest to make fun ... I just can't believe that you are telling me here, on this blog, the meaning to life - and I almost missed it.

To be fair, I thought the answer was 42. Of course God gave us free will, except that if we don't do what he wants he damns us to hell forever(did you know, they BURN you down there?!? WTF?) ... sounds more than a bit faschist to me ... but then again I'm obviously quite ignorant.

for now I will leave it at, "that is one hell of an image of the 7 colours of white light separated by rain drops creating a prism filter, framing a static electrical charge signifying several clouds moving close enough to trigger said electrical charge."

PEACE!
M

Posted by: Mauricio | March 30, 2007 6:33 PM

Post a Comment

(Email is required for authentication purposes only. Comments are moderated for spam, your comment may not appear immediately. Thanks for waiting. I reserve the right to delete comments that are irrelevent to the issue at hand or that are, frankly, soapboxes for the commentator. Call it censorship if you like … it's not - you are always free to say what you like in your own blog at blogger.com or elsewhere.)





Having problems commenting? (UPDATED)

Blogs in the Network

Advertisement

Top Five: Most Active

Search All Blogs

Science News From:

Science News from NYTimes.com