Science as a way of life
I am working on some very smart things to say here. Really. Meanwhile, there's this and this. Welcome.
« The Wretched Life of a Bee | Main | Unstrung in the New Yorker »
Category: Prime Stream
Posted on: September 25, 2006 6:55 AM, by Selva
The God Delusion is the new book by Richard Dawkins. Readers of Dawkins would already know Dawkins position on religion. Beebs has an interview with Dawkins in it's Newsnight programme. You can watch the video online. Quite interesting. Prospect Magazine has a review which is worth a read if you want to see the kind of reactions that Dawkins evokes in some people.
TrackBack URL for this entry:
YES! Send me a free issue of Seed.
If I like what I see, I'll receive 5 more issues (6 in all) for just $14.95. That's 50% off the cover price! If I'm not completely satisfied, I'll simply write "cancel" on the invoice and owe nothing. The free issue is mine to keep.
(Non-U.S. subscribers, click here.)
Comments
A very positive review in the Grauniad
The Grauniad prints an excerpt
Posted by: somnilista, FCD | September 25, 2006 5:15 PM
From Guardian: "an arcane survival mechanism is operating in grossly distorted circumstances". Worth pondering.
Posted by: Selva | September 26, 2006 3:35 AM
That review in Prospect was pure dreck.
Yet under Stalin almost the entire Orthodox priesthood was exterminated simply for being priests, as were the clergy of other religions and hundreds of thousands of Baptists. Oh, not this nonsense again! Yes, Stalin killed the priesthood. But it was not them being priests, it was that they were an ecclesiastical institution that held political power. Stalin also killed his secular political opposition, even that within his own party. Stalin came from the Czarist tradition that glorified absolute power, i.e., he was far more of a Russian than he was an atheist.
Literally everything in that review is as daft as that. China doesn't allow free speech, French Revolution, Tamil Tigers were suicide bombers too. Nothing of substance, no actual answers to Dawkins' arguments. Like I said, pure dreck. I'm dumber from having read it.
Posted by: Tyler DiPietro | September 28, 2006 8:34 PM
If atheism has to take the hit for Stalin, christianity gets the african slave trade, a centuries long killing spree with a death toll in the hundreds of millions, and the hundred years war, which killed a full third of the population of Europe.
The tamil situation is way, way more complicated than that glib little bit about "marxists in sri lanka" would suggest, too.
Posted by: Seth Manapio | September 30, 2006 12:27 AM
I have a certain sympathy for th argument that there is not a precise link between religion (specifically, Islam) and suicide bombing. At any given time, the practice of religion is an artefact of its social, political and historical context. The origins of islamicist suicide bombing were similar to the origins of militant islamicism as a significant force in the middle east: the Iranian regime. (Suicide bombing was an essential tool of an under-equipped Iranian military when faced with Iraqi armour).
Certainly, though, religion is a significant factor in the glorification of suicide bombing as something worthwile in itself, rather than a regretably necessary tactic.
I do have some qualms about Dawkins, though. I don't think he always makes his arguments with sufficient precision. He can't resist the temptation to taunt.
Posted by: Edward the Bonobo | October 4, 2006 9:17 AM