Now on ScienceBlogs: Alright, Neutrinos, The Jig Is Up!
exploring the evolution and architecture of the human mind
I am a graduate student in Developmental Psychology at the University of Southern California.
I'm interested in the way that the environment interacts with biology in producing
innate or skilled behavior, and the evolution of the mind. For a sample of my best posts, see my Greatest Hits.
You can also follow me on twitter and check out my tumblr.
I am also Psychology and Neuroscience Editor for ResearchBlogging.org and Editor of Open Lab 2010
Check out the comment policy.
All written material on the site is the copyright of the author and may
not be reproduced or redistributed without permission.
Want blog schwag?
Order of the Science Scouts of Exemplary Repute and Above Average Physique
« Music While Doing Science Survey | Main | A Cup for your Pup: Friday Weird Science Companion Post »
Category: Reptiles • Tortoise
Posted on: June 17, 2010 10:22 PM, by Jason G. Goldman
This video has been winding its way through the interwebs. It's pretty neat, but is it truly a case of tortoise altruism? Who knows. We don't know anything about those specific turtles or that specific situation. We don't know if they're kin, we don't know if they're trained, if they're pets or wild, we don't know what happened before the camera was turned on, or after it was turned off.
Even still, it's pretty cool.
Life Science
Brain & BehaviorTrackBack URL for this entry: http://scienceblogs.com/mt/pings/141976
Comments
A territorial battle? Maybe that's how it got flipped over in the first place. It looks more like an instinctive "rival tortoise -- must shove" reaction than altruism.
Posted by: Traveler | June 18, 2010 12:33 AM
I assume everyone has seen this?
http://news.mongabay.com/2005/0819-hippo_tortoise.html
Where a baby hippo was adopted or just co-opted a tortoise as a parent figure. Maybe turtles aren't altruistic, just nice.
Posted by: TMK
| June 18, 2010 2:40 AM
As much as we'd like to believe that this is a positive interaction, my experience tells me that the first leopard was knocked upside down(probably both males) and the second leopard tortoise is planning on finishing the job :) American Tortoise Rescue
Posted by: Susan | June 19, 2010 1:28 PM
Y'know, I could readily imagine that a species with limited ability to right itself when flipped might evolve a "right your neighbor" instinct. Looking at the seemingly complex behaviors that really boil down to simple operations in other animals (cats burying feces not by reason or learning, just pure instinct), I think it would be very easy for this behavior to develop. All the tortoise has to have neurologically is the ability to recognize an upside down turtle shape and have that activate its pushing instinct.
But it sounds like 1 and 3 have more tortoise experience, so it looks like I am talking out of my ass, as usual.
Posted by: CS Shelton | June 19, 2010 3:50 PM
The overturned tortoise is a female. The 'helper' is a male obviously looking for love. maybe they discovered the hazards of the 'missionary position'.....
Posted by: jerry | June 19, 2010 5:52 PM
Two adult leopard tortoises, Geochelone ("Stigmochelys") pardalis are shown, the overturned one probably a female. The extent of plastron concavity, which would help confirm gender, is not so clear. We are to assume that the smaller tortoise had overturned her off camera. Such behavior during tortoise courtship is not uncommon, but we don't know if it is always intentional. And tortoises of the same gender will ram, mount, or overturn one another--most such observations have been among captives. The final frames show a horizon without a barrier, suggesting this sequence was filmed in nature, but the evidence is equivocal. There is a published reference to sparring male North American desert tortoise (Gopherus agassizii), in which an overturned male is subsequently righted by the overturner, usually a rival for a nearby female, but I cannot place my finger on the reference.
Posted by: Jim Buskirk | June 19, 2010 10:23 PM
Either speculation is likely. I tend to go with the reproductive hypothesis (as it is more fun, and probably undocumented.) If there is intentionality, "he" is trying to get "her" in the right position. Check the way he is following her after righting her. He might have turned her over initially (rough foreplay?. "Oops! Sorry Dear."
Posted by: Steven C. Anderson | June 21, 2010 5:26 PM