Seed Media Group

The World's Fair

All manner of human creativity on display

Search

Profile

profile.gif David Ng is Director of the Advanced Molecular Biology Laboratory at the University of British Columbia - this is a just a fancier way of calling himself a science teacher.

profile.gifBenjamin Cohen is an Asst. Professor of Science, Tech., and Society at the University of Virginia. He studies the place of S & T in environmental history, policy, and ethics. He also writes other stuff.

mappsmall.gifTrying to find your way around this place? Like most expositions, we offer a map: Map of The World's Fair





Cannonball%20Morris%20Icon.jpg


The%20A-B%20icon.jpg




"The world is full of light and life, and the true crime is not to be interested in it." A.S. Byatt

Recent Posts

Recent Comments

Archives

Links

Blogroll

And so forth...

« Keywords: Sex, Hairyness and Pity (and other Scientific Eponyms on display). | Main | What do you think of Stephen Jay Gould? »

New Game: Historical Fill in the _____!

Category: The Book Building
Posted on: November 25, 2007 6:50 PM, by Benjamin Cohen

Taking a cue from Dave's recent meme-games and my own reading of the weekend book review section of the paper, I'm inspired to wonder how many answers can fit the following blanks:

"The period between the end of _______ and the end of ______ is one of the most important in American history and, these days, one of the most neglected."

This sentence was part of a review of Daniel Walker Howe's What God Hath Wrought: The Transformation of America, 1815-1848. The review was by Jonathan Yardley; recently, Jill Lepore had a fascinating essay centering on the same book in The New Yorker. Popular new book, I'd say. That's a lot of press for a work of antebellum history. Though I shouldn't feign shock -- I'm familiar with Howe's work, conversant with the historiography under discussion in both recent reviews, and wishing I can some day achieve the well-earned success Howe has. The period about which he writes is at the very core of my own historical work. All of which is to say, the answers to the fill-in-the-blank in original form are "War of 1812" and "Mexican-American War in 1848."

Thus: "The period between the end of the War of 1812 and the end of Mexican-American War in 1848 is one of the most important in American history and, these days, one of the most neglected."

But that alone isn't a lot of fun. What piqued my interest was the gall of the reviewer's statement. How could you verify such a claim? "One of the most neglected"? What does that mean? By what measure? A rhetorical flourish, I presume.

So, although I *should* be one to cheerlead the call for greater public awareness of that period, and I *do* agree that the period deserves more attention, I actually imagine one could say the same about almost any given time period in American history. Even if you fill in the blanks as such -- "The period between the end of the first hour of D-Day and the end of its fourth hour is one of the most important in American history and, these days, one of the most neglected" -- I bet someone could make a case. Or, "the end of Kennedy's motorcade in Dallas" and "the beginning of the Zapruder film's final cut." Or, "the end of Nixon's odd wave on those helicopter steps" and "the end of his last step into the actual helicopter." Or so on...

Dear able-minded World's Fair readership, any blank fillers?

(At least HgMan should pitch in, if not our interns.)

Comments

Hey, if the last 7.5 years were not so neglected, perhaps we would not be in such trouble right now.

Posted by: Coturnix | November 25, 2007 7:06 PM

Hmm. I don't think it's at all neglected, but from a technology/science standpoint, the period from the end of World War II to the end of the Cold War is pretty important.

Or, the period from the first wireless telegraph transmission by Morse (I don't know the date off-hand, late 1890s or early 1900s, I think) 'til the widespread use of commercial television in the mid-1950s (the golden age of radio technology, which saw many military applications, and also changed the face of western society; also RADAR was invented in the middle of this).

Posted by: Waterdog | November 25, 2007 10:20 PM

Ha. I like Coturnix's answer, so I'll repeat it, slightly modified:

"The period between Bush's Supreme Court-appointed presidency and the moment I post this comment is one of the most important in American history and, these days, one of the most neglected."

Posted by: Neal Son | November 26, 2007 8:08 AM

How about this?

"The period between the dropping of the atomic bomb in Hiroshima and the landing of that atomic bomb is one of the most important in American history and, these days, one of the most neglected."

Just think, worldwide, how many people died while the bomb was falling.

Posted by: AB Sesame | November 26, 2007 11:34 AM

"At least HgMan should pitch in"??

I think Daniel Walker Howe got it pretty close to right. I can't think of a more important and overlooked period in American history, though, perhaps, 1848-1861 (David Potter's "impending crisis") deserves a shout. And if the theme is science and technology, then it has to be the quarter-century and a bit after the Civil War.

Whatever Bush's transgressions, there is no way he transformed America on the level that was witnessed in the 19th century. I suspect that fifty to a hundred years from now, historians will look back on the now and be able to identify considerable consistency in American politics and history from Goldwater to 2012 (and beyond). Maybe I'm just a cynic, but what's really changed since Clinton? Presentism is so... well, yesterday.

Posted by: HgMan | November 26, 2007 7:36 PM

Post a Comment

(Email is required for authentication purposes only. Comments are moderated for spam, your comment may not appear immediately. Thanks for waiting.)





Having problems commenting? (UPDATED)

Blogs in the Network

Advertisement

Top Five: Most Active

  1. Here we go again — Mississippi's turn! 01.08.2009 · PZ Myers
  2. I'm in good company 01.06.2009 · PZ Myers
  3. The Madness of Roseanne Barr 01.08.2009 · Ed Brayton
  4. An Open Letter... 01.08.2009 · Isis the Scientist
  5. How To Choose A Post-Doc 01.07.2009 · PhysioProf

Search All Blogs

Science News From:

Science News from NYTimes.com