Seed Media Group

The World's Fair

All manner of human creativity on display

Search

Profile

profile.gif David Ng is Director of the Advanced Molecular Biology Laboratory at the University of British Columbia - this is a just a fancier way of calling himself a science teacher.

profile.gifBenjamin Cohen is an Asst. Professor of Science, Tech., and Society at the University of Virginia. He studies the place of S & T in environmental history, policy, and ethics. He also writes other stuff.

mappsmall.gifTrying to find your way around this place? Like most expositions, we offer a map: Map of The World's Fair





Cannonball%20Morris%20Icon.jpg


The%20A-B%20icon.jpg




"The world is full of light and life, and the true crime is not to be interested in it." A.S. Byatt

Recent Posts

Recent Comments

Archives

Links

Blogroll

And so forth...

« Our High School Science Teacher Conference - It Rocked! | Main | The Candy Hierarchy Anew (Halloween Experiment Debriefing '08) »

Killing Pigs Old Style, Killing 'Em New Style

Category: Industrial Agriculture
Posted on: October 28, 2008 4:00 PM, by Benjamin Cohen

I lectured today on technology and progress in my big-lecture class (the main thrust being: in what way is technology progress, and who says so, and why). Just before I'd watched a documentary, Our Daily Bread (and here), about the modern industrial agriculture process. It pairs very well with another documentary, Manufactured Landscapes, and in that way ties into the recent thread of "landcsape" images at the site (the West, fences, and bombs). In discussing technology and progress, the lecture was built with commentary on mechanization and the values of technical rationality. That got me to thinking of the "disassembly" line as the antecedent to the assembly line. Which leads me here to offer two images, one from 1869 that I got from Mechanization Takes Command by Siegfried Giedion, the other from Our Daily Bread.

Hog%20Disassembly%20Line.JPG


Schweineklaue.sm.JPG

You should see the other images available at the Our Daily Bread website, if you haven't seen the documentary itself. Try this other one of hog processing; and this one of chickens; and this one of cows. If you've seen No Country for Old Men, what you're missing in the cow slaughter image is the next scene when the guy comes by and stuns the cow in the skull with that thing the guy in No Country used.

How far have we come?

Comments

It is my understanding that in the industrial pig biz, the size of the pig is very important. The pigs are fed at troughs that weigh the pig and determine if it gets food, and how much. At the end of the cycle, all the pigs planned for a particular run to the slaughter house (via truck or train) have to be standard size. Larger or smaller pigs don't fit in the machine, essentially, and are thus slaughtered by hand. That costs more.

But let us never forget the words of Homer Simpson: "Oh, right, some magical animal that produces ham, bacon, AND pork... A likely story.."

Posted by: Greg Laden | October 28, 2008 4:53 PM

Greg is right - size matters. Of course, the industry would like to do more than just have an automated kill process. They'd like to be able to "process" the whole animal, too. Butcher it up into the hams and the pork butts and the ribs and the like. But they haven't been able to engineer the animal that closely to arrange their insides to be uniform (even with cloning - stupid environment).

And, how far have we come? Well, the assembly line worker above IS wearing ear protection. And we'd be even farther if nogoodnicks like Geyrhalter and Byrtynsky would just keep that stuff invisible. (I forget, does sarcasm come across in blog comments? Probably not.)

As Homer has also said, "What's Maggie ever done? Nothing for nobody."

Posted by: lwn | October 28, 2008 8:49 PM

Hmmmm. "It's all about the pork products..."

Is this the final final final clue to Puzzle Fantastica #3 in disguise?

Posted by: Joe in LA | October 29, 2008 12:52 AM

Yup - we kill things and eat 'em. *dis*gusting, and it out to made illegal. While we are at it, we orta make defecation illegal, because that's disgusting, too.

You and me, baby, we ain't nothing but mammals, and the particular mammals we are eat meat.

Posted by: Paul Murray | October 29, 2008 1:43 AM

You and me, baby, we ain't nothing but mammals, and the particular mammals we are can eat meat.

Posted by: Dagor | October 29, 2008 2:33 AM

You and me, baby, we ain't nothing but mammals, and the particular mammals we are can eat meat.

Posted by: glenstein | October 29, 2008 7:57 AM

Well played, Paul! You managed not to get even the slightest bit of it. Plus, yeah for Palinesque folksiness.

Posted by: A. Lucas | October 29, 2008 8:15 AM

Post a Comment

(Email is required for authentication purposes only. Comments are moderated for spam, your comment may not appear immediately. Thanks for waiting.)





Having problems commenting? (UPDATED)

Blogs in the Network

Advertisement

Top Five: Most Active

  1. Here we go again — Mississippi's turn! 01.08.2009 · PZ Myers
  2. I'm in good company 01.06.2009 · PZ Myers
  3. The Madness of Roseanne Barr 01.08.2009 · Ed Brayton
  4. An Open Letter... 01.08.2009 · Isis the Scientist
  5. Coming out 01.08.2009 · John Whitfield

Search All Blogs

Science News From:

Science News from NYTimes.com