An Hypothetical for Huckabee

What would you do if a series of archaeological expeditions
uncovered ancient texts that indisputably showed that Matthew, Mark,
Luke, and John each independently quoted Jesus as having said that
waterboarding is immoral?




More like this

Via Bob O'H and Cath Ennis comes this truly bizarre article from the Virology Journal: "Influenza or not influenza: Analysis of a case of high fever that happened 2000 years ago in Biblical time". Now, regular readers will know that I normally love this type of thing; digging back through history…
The much awaited Harvard University proposal to revise its aged core curriculum has been released. So far, two details have gotten most of the attention: 1) The committee did not follow Larry Summer's suggestion to increase core requirements for science. Students would still have to take one course…
Here's your quiz for the day. Who wrote this? There is no theistic God who exists to take care of you or me. There is no God who stands ready to set aside the laws by which this universe operates to come to our aid in time of need. There are no everlasting arms underneath us to catch us when we…
Here's a bonus bit of analysis from last week's Casual Fridays study. In addition to asking respondents how familiar they were with our selection of stories, we also asked them to describe some detail of the story that was independently verifiable, like how the story ended. The reason we did this…

Hypothetical questions do not really work on religious people - they have limited imagination - that is why they gratefully accept scripture instead of thinking for themselves.

Any new gospel, however unequivocal it may read to the open-minded, will always be "interpreted" by the religious to justify his own prejudice.

I'm sure you knew that anyway, there is already more than enough in Huck's holy book to absolutely prohibit any torture, and also more than enough there to justify far worse.

I don't know that Huckabee is a fundamentalist, but based on many of his statements, I think that his political persona is one. If so, he likely believes that the Bible, as "faithfully" translated in the King James version, is the complete, inerrant word of God. As such, it would be impossible to create a hypothetical argument involving new biblical material that would make any sense to him.

You do realize that Huckabee is opposed to waterboarding, don't you?