What strange beast is this?

The Institute for Creation Research is going on and on again about Haeckel and gill slits. It gets tiresome; I've explained so many times that Haeckel's theory was wrong and he skewed his drawings to fit his model, but that it really is true that human embryos have pharyngeal arches that are modified in a peculiar way to build the face and neck, and this really is evidence for our evolutionary history. Fortunately, this time, I don't have to go into it because Troy Britain has covered all the details. Yay!

But I do want to mention one really strange thing. The ICR is going on and on about Haeckel faking his embryo drawings, but this is what they used to illustrate their own article.

CHRIST JESUS, WHAT IS THAT THING? That is creepy — no human embryo ever looked like that. They've neatly painted out any kind of branchial structures, and it has no post-anal tail — yet it's supposed to be a 7-8 week embryo. I guess reality was too uncomfortable for them, so they dug up some uninformed stock art that leaves out those vestiges of our ancestry, tails and gill slits, that refute their claims.

Either that or they performed an abortion on a Grey. Good for them, those UFO pilots are always sticking probes up our butts, it's only fair that someone grabbed one and did a D&C on them.

More like this

(This is a rather long response to a chapter in Jonathan Wells' dreadful and most unscholarly book, Icons of Evolution) The story of Haeckel's embryos is different in an important way from that of the other chapters in Jonathan Wells' book. As the other authors show, Wells has distorted ideas that…
Every biology student gets introduced to the chordates with a list of their distinctive characteristics: they have a notochord, a dorsal hollow nerve cord, gill slits, and a post-anal tail. The embryonic stage in which we express all of these features is called the pharyngula stage—it's often also…
[When I started this weblog, one of the hot topics in the Creationist Wars was Jonathan Wells, a Moonie who had trained as a developmental biologist and written a screed against evolutionary biology titled Icons of Evolution. This book purported to document serious flaws in some of the major…
"The pharyngula stage: the pharyngula is a vertebrate embryo that has assembled the outlines of the body plan. It has the key features of vertebrate morphology -- a post-anal tail, a notochord, a dorsal neural tube, a segmented musculature, and an array of branchial arches ("gill" arches). The…

That is sooo odd...
It looks nothing like the little squib that I am carrying right now (although he is now 19 weeks, I started having photos taken when he was about 7 weeks to try to work out dates...). Admittedly, I haven't seen any colour pictures, just grainy black/white, but still

I believe you have made several actually fascinating points. Not many individuals would certainly actually picture this how you merely do. Internet marketing actually impressed which theres a great deal about it issue thats been recently discovered and you also made it happen very well, with so much course. Doozy an individual, person! Great stuff the following.

What Jan said.

By Cat Ballou (not verified) on 01 Aug 2012 #permalink