Tetrapod Zoology

Return…. to the world of sheep

i-2b412bfa6df15ae12909f81c67f8ddbe-sheep skulls 2.jpg

My plan at the moment (in terms of blog-related writing) is to do nothing other than complete all those nearly-finished articles that I’ve been promising to do over the last weeks… or months… We begin with the second post on sheep, thereby completing what I started in the first sheep post (the first post is required reading before you launch into this one). As discussed back then, sheep are generally divided into three genetic groups: the Asian argaliforms, the mouflon-like moufloniforms, and the mostly American pachyceriforms. I covered the argaliforms last time and, of the pachyceriforms, got as far as introducing, and saying stuff about accidental falls and homosexuality, in Bighorn Ovis canadensis. The aim here is to finish dealing with pachyceriforms and to then get through the moufloniforms. Covering the latter group means including the confusing and complex story of sheep domestication… [in adjacent photo, the lamb skull at the front, and the big-horned ram, are Soay sheep; the other two are blackfaced sheep from Dartmoor. PS: note the small supraorbital foramina compared to McGowan's mystery bovid]

Given their wide distribution and habitat choice, bighorns are quite variable in size and morphology, and desert-dwelling forms are smaller, and with flatter, less widely spreading horns that mountain-dwelling populations. Though seven subspecies have been named, including four desert-dwelling forms and the extinct Audubon’s bighorn O. c. auduboni, recent studies have indicated that only three can be supported: the Rocky Mountain bighorn O. c. canadensis, Sierra Nevada bighorn O. c. sierrae and Desert bighorn O. c. nelsoni (Wehausen & Ramey 1993, 2000, Wehausen et al. 2005). The idea that bighorns (and other sheep) are phenotypically ‘plastic’ is supported by data on how much sexual dimorphism occurs when populations become crowded. LeBlanc et al. (2001) showed that body mass in both sexes was depressed when population densities were high, leading to a decline in sexual size dimorphism between 2-yr-olds. While males were unable to ‘catch up’ with the disadvantaged growth rate they experienced as lambs, females underwent compensatory growth, so the population ended up with relatively large females compared to relatively small males.

i-3500c992d8a516fc967514a2f3e62e3f-Dall's sheep.jpg

Closely related to the bighorns is O. dalli, a species often known as Dall’s sheep. However, the ‘correct’ name for O. dalli is actually Thinhorn sheep and, within this species, Dall’s sheep is a subspecies (O. d. dalli) [shown in adjacent image]. The other subspecies is the slightly larger and more robust Stone sheep O. d. stonei, named for Montana naturalist A. J. Stone (and not for small rocks). The validity of the Stone sheep has been controversial and it and Dall’s sheep grade into one another in NW British Columbia and central Yukon. Most recently, Stone and Dall’s sheep were supported as valid taxa by Worley et al. (2004). Thinhorn sheep are northern specialists of British Columbia, the Yukon Territory and Alaska. While Dall’s sheep is white, Stone sheep range from off-white in the north to grey and blackish further south.

Snow sheep

Bighorns and thinhorns share a number of genetic and morphological characters and form the pachyceriform clade, and they’ve also been given their own subgenus within Ovis, Pachyceros. Though sometimes called American sheep, there is in fact an Asian species that also seems to be part of the group: the Snow sheep O. nivicola of Siberia, sometimes called the Siberian or Asiatic bighorn and even included by some workers in the same species as the bighorn. It’s true that Snow sheep are highly similar to Alaskan bighorns, but while bighorns have 54 chromosomes, Snow sheep have 52 (though read on), so they are now thought quite distinct. It’s been suggested that bighorn and thinhorn sheep descend from a snow sheep-like ancestor that invaded Beringia and then moved south into North America, though some workers think that things likely occurred the other way round, with Asian snow sheep descended from a bighorn-like pachyceriform that re-invaded Asia.

i-3ea75d6ae91cfd40c6dd8037b9384bf8-Kamchatka snow sheep.jpg

Bunch et al. (2006) presented data suggesting that O. nivicola is not a clade, as while some snow sheep formed a sister-group to bighorns and thinhorns, others were at the base of the clade that includes argaliforms and moufloniforms. Geist (1991) and Bunch et al. (2006) speculated that the Kamchatka sheep O. n. nivicola [shown in adjacent image] might share 54 chromosomes with bighorns and thinhorns, and hence prove particularly close to these American species. Some of this data might mean that one or some snow sheep populations deserve recognition as distinct species-level taxa.

And on that note, snow sheep are polytypic, with between two and six subspecies being recognised by different researchers. I just know you want to see those listed, so: Kamchatka sheep O. n. nivicola, Koryak O. n. koryakorum, Okhotsk sheep O. n. alleni, Yablonov sheep O. n. potanini, Putorian sheep O. n. borealis and Yakut sheep O. n. lydekkeri. If we ever do get to the stage where people decide that the ‘subspecies’ concept is useless and that any such taxa should be classified as species, we’re clearly going to see a massive surge in the recognised number of extant sheep taxa. Like, from seven or eight species to over 30 or something. Yikes.

The mouflons

i-64c1986d47edca8fb0b6725246ca0709-mouflon.jpg

Finally, we come to the moufloniforms. This group is named for the Mouflon O. musimon Blyth, 1811 or O. gmelini Blyth, 1841*, the smallest of wild sheep (c. 25-55 kg), of Iran, Iraq, Turkey, Corsica, Sardinia and Cyprus [captive individual shown in adjacent image]. Six subspecies have been named. Closely related, and sometimes regarded as conspecific with O. gmelini/musimon, is the Asian mouflon O. orientalis. While it used to be thought that the mouflons of Europe were truly wild sheep, it now seems that most or all of them are Neolithic ferals descended from O. orientalis, though note that this does not apply to all mouflon populations and that those of Turkey, Iran and elsewhere might be truly wild. The mouflons on Corsica and Sardinia appear to have been introduced to the islands about 6000 years ago. There is a huge amount of disagreement as to the taxonomy and relationships of these sheep – for fear of adding another 1000 words to the post I am going to avoid it.

* Though O. musimon is older, many sheep experts now seem to prefer O. gmelini. I think this is because the type for the latter name is more clearly linked to a potentially wild mouflon population (rather than a feral or hybrid population), though I’m not sure.

Domestic sheep: confusing multiple origins

i-692bcde5668f3181c025bb8cb61e018b-soay sheep 2.jpg

How do domestic sheep O. aries fit into all this? Archaeological evidence suggests that sheep were first domesticated in the Fertile Crescent somewhere around 9000 years ago (though some workers suggest an origin about 11,000 years ago) and, while it is generally agreed that domestic sheep are moufloniforms, beyond that there this is some controversy as to their origins. It’s been proposed that Asiatic mouflon or urial might have been their ancestors, and/or that argali genes had been introduced into domesticated urial (for discussion of argali and urial, see the first sheep post). Stefan Hiendleder and colleagues found that the domestic sheep of Europe and Asia differ in mtDNA, with European domestic sheep being close to European mouflon while Asian domestic sheep were not only strongly divergent from mouflon, but also from urial and argalis, and thus must have been domesticated from as an-yet-unknown wild ancestor (Hiendleder et al. 1998, 2002). These two well-separated mitochondrial lineages (dubbed Group A and Group B) had become distinct well prior to 11,000 years ago. Group B is the one that shares haplotypes with mouflon, with wild populations present in Turkey and Iran being regarded as the most likely sources for origination of Group B domestic sheep [adjacent photo shows Soay sheep, one of the most primitive living breeds of European sheep].

By 2005, a third distinct domestic sheep lineage – Group C – was reported in Chinese and Turkish sheep (Guo et al. 2005, Pedrosa et al. 2005). Tapio et al. (2006) looked at mitochondrial variation in domestic sheep across Europe, the Caucasian region and central Asia, and found another distinct lineage – Group D – in a sheep from the north Caucasus. Meadows et al. (2007) further complicated this story by documenting a fifth distinct ovine mitochondrial lineage: Group E.

Paralleling studies of domestic cattle, goat, pig, horse, donkey and chicken, it now seems that sheep were domesticated on multiple occasions from several different wild populations, and that domestic sheep ancestry involves as-yet-unidentified wild ancestral populations. In fact perhaps the single most significant discovery from recent genetic studies of domestic animals is that domestic ‘species’ have arisen from multiple different local domestication events, and only rarely from single events (though the latter have been documented: in yaks for example (Guo et al. 2006).

i-aa9f83099ed02b556f0e5cd6889e0467-soay sheep.jpg

While Group B sheep (the group that includes most European domestic sheep breeds) are tied to European mouflon, and hence most likely share an ancestor that was a sort of wild, proto-mouflon, the wild ancestors of Group A, C, D and E sheep all remain unknown, and genetic distances show that these wild ancestors were not urial or argali as used to be thought. The most likely hypothesis is that these distinct domestic sheep matrilines descended from wild moufloniform populations that are now extinct. The good news is that the evidence for these populations hasn’t necessarily disappeared, as there is a vast amount of unsampled archaeological sheep specimens: as Meadows et al. (2007) suggested, ‘perhaps the next phase in mtDNA discovery should be aimed at ancient DNA from the Fertile Crescent’ (p. 1378) [another Soay sheep shown in adjacent image].

Sheep taxonomy, ancestry and phylogeny is far from resolved, and we have much to learn about the relationships between living species, and huge holes remain in our understanding of the history of domestic breeds. That might be surprising in such a ubiquitous and familiar group of animals – or does it highlight how much we have yet to learn about even the most mundane of beasts?

Incidentally, for those who follow various of the discussions that we have here at Tet Zoo, keep an eye on Picture of the day # 14 for more on the maximum authenticated size of Crocodylus porosus. I have recently added a few new bits of information to the post on Peter Hocking’s big cats (including a mention of the alleged African tiger Panthera tigris senegalensis), and Marc van Roosmalen has recently sent me a new, very long piece of text on his new Amazonian mammals that I will adapt and publish on the blog soon.

Refs – -

Bunch, T. D., Wu, C., Zhang, Y.-P. & Wang, S. 2006. Phylogenetic analysis of snow sheep (Ovis nivicola) and closely related taxa. Journal of Heredity 97, 21-30.

Geist, V. 1991. On the taxonomy of giant sheep (Ovis ammon Linnaeus, 1766). Canadian Journal of Zoology 69, 706-723.

Guo, J., Du, L. X., Ma, Y. H., Guan, W. J. & Li, H. B., Zhao, Q.-J., Li, X & Rao, S.-Q. 2005. A novel maternal lineage revealed in sheep (Ovis aries). Animal Genetics 36, 331-336.

- ., Savolainen, P., Su, J., Zhang, Q., Qi, D., Zhou, J., Zhong, Y., Zhao, X. & Liu, J. 2006. Origin of mitochondrial DNA diversity of domestic yaks. BMC Evolutionary Biology 2006, 6: 73.

Hiendleder, S., Kaupe, B., Wassmuth, R. & Janke, A. 2002. Molecular analysis of wild and domestic sheep questions current nomenclature and provides evidence for domestication from two different subspecies. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 269, 893-904.

- ., Mainz, K., Plante, Y. & Lewalski, H. 1998. Analysis of mitochondrial DNA indicates that domestic sheep and derived from two different ancestral maternal sources: no evidence for contributions from Urial and Argali sheep. The Journal of Heredity 89, 113-120.

LeBlanc, M., Festa-Bianchet, M. & Jorgenson, J. T. 2001. Sexual size dimorphism in bighorn sheep (Ovis canadensis): effects of population density. Canadian Journal of Zoology 79, 1661-1670.

Meadows, J. R. S., Cemal, I., Karaca, O., Gootwine, E. & Kijas, J. W. 2007. Five ovine mitochondrial lineages from sheep breeds of the near east. Genetics 175, 1371-1379.

Pedrosa, S., Uzun, M, Arranz, J.-J., Gutiérrez-Gil, B., San Primitivo, F. & Bayón, Y. 2005. Evidence of three maternal lineages in near eastern sheep supporting multiple domestication events. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 272, 2211-2217.

Tapio, M., Marzanov, N., Ozerov, M., Cinkulov, M., Gonzarenko, G., Kiselyova, T., Murawski, M., Viinalass, H. & Kantanen, J. 2006. Sheep mitochondrial DNA variation in European, Caucasian, and central Asian areas. Molecular Biology and Evolution 23, 1776-1783.

Wehausen, J. D., Bleich, V. C. & Ramey, R. R. 2005. Correct nomenclature for Sierra Nevada bighorn sheep. California Fish and Game 91, 216-218.

- . & Ramey, R. R. 1993. A morphometric reevaluation of the Peninsular bighorn subpecies. Transactions of the Desert Bighorn Council 37, 1-10.

Worley, K., Strobeck, C., Arthur, S., Carey, J., Schwantje, H., Veitch, A. & Coltman, D. W. 2004. Population genetic structure of North American thinhorn sheep (Ovis dalli). Molecular Ecology 13, 2545-2556.

Comments

  1. #1 Allen Hazen
    June 12, 2007

    Neat!

    I recall reading somewhere that there is a race of domestic sheep somewhere in the British Isles that are regularly four-horned. Is this true, or have I gotten something mixed up with something else? (One of my favorite displays at the AMNH in New York is a — probably very old, nad not as dramatic as their more famous “habitat groups” — group of Four-horned antelope, Tetraceros quadricornus. In that species the forward pair of horns is much smaller than the rear pair — my recollection is that the rear pair is about where you expect bovid horns to be, with the fore-pair more supraorbital — and I think some individuals are merely “bicornate”.)

    (Mammal chauvinist here: I particularly appreciate your long posts on unusual mammals: particularly when they show just how unusual the mammasls we take for granted are (cf. “Why rabbits are just wrong” on the old site)!)

  2. #2 Sordes
    June 12, 2007

    There is actually a race of sheep, called Jacob’s sheep, which have sometimes four horns. Even stranger, they have in some cases even six horns. But this is most probably only a new mutation, and no ancient trait. Sometimes they have not only four horns, but also slitted eye-lids, which causes often a blinding of the eyes.
    Picture here.

  3. #3 Anthony Docimo
    June 12, 2007

    I think there’s an endangered breed of sheep, kept by the Navaho of North America. (Navaho-Churro Sheep, I think; and mentioned in a book of endangered farm animals)

    on another matter…something that might make a cool Tet Picture: the recently-discovered Mecistotrachelos apeoros http://www.roanoke.com/news/roanoke/wb/wb/xp-120382
    my thoughts on it: http://rodlox.livejournal.com/16632.html which mentions this blog.

  4. #4 David Godfrey
    June 12, 2007

    What are the rules on issuing a species with a common name? Or indeed are there any?

    Surely if everyone calls O. dalli Dall’s sheep, then Dall’s sheep it eventually becomes?

  5. #5 cfrost
    June 13, 2007

    Visit a few county and state fairs and you’ll eventually see some four-horned sheep. The fairs, what with 4-H, livestock judging, and auctions are fabulous places to see bewildering varieties of domestic animals.

    My work occasionally takes me on the I-84 freeway along the Columbia River. About 120 miles or so east of Portland Oregon, just past the John Day River, the freeway runs between the Columbia and huge basalt cliffs for several miles where bighorns may often be seen as one zooms along at 70 mph. As there’s no easy place to pull off and look at them, no one does, and the sheep sometimes graze unmolested and unconcerned very close to the freeway. They’re doubtless usually mistaken for deer if they’re noticed at all.

    There was a small population of mouflon in central Oregon a few years back, but the Oregon Dept. of Fish & Wildlife opened a no-limit, free-for-all hunt to get rid of them. They figured they had the potential to host and transmit disease and parasites to the native bighorns.

  6. #6 Tommy Tyrberg
    June 19, 2007

    Four-horned rams were once rather common among the Utegångsfår of Gotland which is another very old sheep breed. However they have mostly been bred out of the stock nowadays.

  7. #7 Lin Missimer
    June 20, 2007

    I’ve been really impressed with your blog and thoroughly enjoy it, although my background isn’t really up to some of the extreme technical issues. But I am pretty serious about sheep and goats as I am a fiber person by avocation and am attempting to write a book about the whole development of yarn.

    So far I have frightened several professors with a 14 page list of questions I need answered. Know anyone with the time and inclination to answer a whole lot of questions about domesticating sheep, the appearance of useable fiber, how much down a mammoth would have produced. did they shed, any bone or stone implements in more recent neolithic sites that would indicate spindle spinning, comparison of wild US sheep with useable fleece to ancestral breeds and so on for a long time.

    In any case, you have a wonderful blog and I hope you get precisely the position you wish soon.

    Lin Missimer

  8. #8 Ahmad Faizan
    December 17, 2009

    Are there two lineages of Sheep, Goat, Camel and Cattle (cow)respectively?
    Why I’m asking because one day I was reading Qu’ran (6:143-144)”Eight Pairs: Of the Sheep two and of the Goat two…..”, “And of the Camel two and of the Cows(cattles)two,….” generaly some people without pondering translated it a pair of sheep “two” they took as one male and one female. For Camel (dromedary & Bactrian), Sheep (European mouflon (Ovis aries musimon)& Cyprus mouflon (Ovis aries ophion)/Asian lineage), for goat and cattle I’m still studing.

The site is currently under maintenance and will be back shortly. New comments have been disabled during this time, please check back soon.