Who's Blaming the Troops Here?

Yesterday, President Bush addressed the growing controversy over the missing explosives at a campaign stop and he predictably pulled out the ultimate appeal to uber-patriot morons, the claim that if you attack the administration's policies, you attack the troops themselves. And the audience, naturally, booed on cue. How dare those people say our troops screwed up! Well of course, no one is saying that the troops screwed up, we're saying that the war planners themselves screwed up, especially Rumsfeld, who refused to give the generals the troops they needed to do the job right. For crying out loud, we went into Iraq needing to conquer and occupy it indefinitely with 1/3 the number of troops that we used to liberate Kuwait in Desert Storm, when that mission didn't include any post-war occupation of a hostile country! But it seems that some of the President's defenders are in fact attacking the troops. On the Today show this morning, here's what Rudolph Giuliani had to say:

``No matter how you try to blame it on the president, the actual responsibility for it really would be for the troops that were there. Did they search carefully enough - didn't they search carefully enough?''

Or didn't they have the numbers or the orders to search and secure the munitions sites? That's what every outside military analyst says; that's what Jay Garner says; that's what Jay Bremer said; that's what the 3rd Infantry Division commander says. You gotta have some major league chutzpah to lead our young men and women into battle without a plan to keep them safe and protect them from the weapons we knew were there and then question the patriotism of anyone who points that out.

More like this

Much has been written about the incompetence with which the Bush administration has pursued the war and post-war occupation in Iraq. I'd like to add to our understanding of that situation by looking, in hindsight, at what was predicted with foresight before the war. Many of the people who were…
The administration's faithful defenders at Fox News are trying mightily to make the case that the explosives were gone before troops arrived, but they're doing so with misleading headlines. Look at this article on their website headlined "Search Showed No Explosives at Iraqi Base Before War's End…
From the "could this administration possibly be any more incompetent" file comes this report: The Iraqi interim government has warned the United States and international nuclear inspectors that nearly 380 tons of powerful conventional explosives - used to demolish buildings, make missile warheads…
Ask the average American their theory on why we "lost" in Vietnam and you are likely to get this answer or some variation of it: "We didn't let the military fight the war, the war was fought by politicians. If we'd let the military do their job, we would have won." This notion has become thoroughly…