1. pharyngula
  2. The Vatican has been beaming cancer rays into children!

The Vatican has been beaming cancer rays into children!

By pharyngula on July 14, 2010.

That's the latest news, anyway: radio masts operated by the Vatican have been implicated in an increased incidence of cancers nearby.

It is such a juicily evil story — it would just fit the Pope's Bond villain image so well — but, and I really, really hate to defend the Vatican, I don't buy it. Sorry. I know it's my mission to smack the Catholic church around, but this is a case where I just find it highly unlikely.

I have not read the report; all I've seen so far is the accusation, the small numbers (19 deaths in 23 years) and the excessive charges — 6 people are being investigated on criminal charges of manslaughter. Something's just not right here.

These stories crop up regularly. People claim power lines or cell phones cause cancer, but none of the data really support it — there is no plausible mechanism where these very weak fields could be causing cancer, and at best the epidemiological studies show there can be only a very small effect…or more likely, no effect at all.

Maybe there are some new and persuasive data and statistics in this new Italian study, but even if they actually have a believable measure of an effect, it's not going to justify criminal charges. It's also peculiar to focus on just the Catholic church; are there no other shortwave radio antennas in Italy?

Apparently there are: the Italian navy has radio masts in the same area, but to make the report even weirder, only Catholic antennas and not naval antennas cause cancer. I'd like to know how they determined that, and what makes Catholicism carcinogenic.

Tags
Skepticism

More like this

The bride of the son of the revenge of cell phones and cancer rises from the grave...again
I've caught some flak before over things I've written about the almost certainly nonexistent link between cell phones and cancer. Actually, it's not the kind of flak you probably think, unless you've been a long time reader and remember the relevant posts. You'd think it would be believers…
Does Cell Phone Use Cause Cancer? No.
Josh Harkinson at Mother Jones recently posted an item called "Scores of Scientists Raise Alarm About the Long-Term Health Effects of Cellphones." I like Josh's work, but there are some problems with this article I want to point out, some of which parallel problems in the more general discussion…
The President's Cancer Panel steps into it
I'm a bit of an odd bird in the world of cancer. No, it's not because I run a snarky skeptical blog that routinely deconstructs the nonsense that alt-med practitioners sprew far and wide, nor is it because I've developed a middling level of popularity that shocks me from time to time. Nor is it…
The revenge of cell phones and cancer strikes back yet again in the never-ending controversy...
NOTE: Orac is on semi-vacation this week, trying very hard to recharge his Tarial cells. Actually, although he is at home, he is spending much of his time in his Sanctum Sanctorum (i.e., his home office) working on an R01 for the February submission cycle. Given that the week between Christmas and…