1. pharyngula
  2. What is Richard Mabey smoking?

What is Richard Mabey smoking?

By pharyngula on July 18, 2010.

I really don't know who this Mabey fellow is — apparently, he's a well-regarded nature writer in the UK — but he's recently enthusiastically mentioned his summer reading plans, and they're freaky.

I'll need a long summer break just to finish Jerry Fodor and Massimo Piattelli-Palmarini's dense but explosively exciting What Darwin Got Wrong (Profile). The celebration of the great scientist's bicentenary last year courteously sidestepped the fact that most cutting-edge biologists now regard natural selection as little more than cosmetic tweaking in the process of evolution. What's happening is far more philosophically thrilling: creatures are doing it for themselves. The authors show how ancient "managerial" genes, self-organising systems in cells and the inherent tendency towards symmetry in living structures all help to generate new organisms fully pre-adapted to their environments. Wings already pre-balanced for flight!

Say what? Who are these mysterious "cutting-edge biologists" who have these bizarre misunderstandings of biology?

I think Mabey has been overdoing the herbs.

Tags
Kooks

More like this

Fodor and Piattelli-Palmarini get everything wrong
People who don't understand modern evolutionary theory shouldn't be writing books criticizing evolutionary theory. That sounds like rather pedestrian and obvious advice, but it's astonishing how often it's ignored — the entire creationist book publishing industry demands a steady supply of…
Scattered shots against Fodor and Piattelli-Palmarini
So I just put up this lengthy gripe about Fodor and Piattelli-Palmarini, and there were a bunch of other things I wanted to say that I couldn't squeeze in, so here are a few left-over comments. The best take-down so far is Block and Kitcher's review — go read that. Basically, they approach the…
Criticism deferred, but building. And no, my name is not Fermat.
Oh, no. Jerry Fodor and Massimo Piattelli-Palmarini have written a book and opinion piece in which they try to claim that natural selection is a dying concept, and what do they use to justify that outrageous claim? Evo devo! That's just nuts, and Mary Midgely compounds the crazy with terrible abuse…
I'm home!
I left Morris on the 19th of January, and finally, here it is the 8th of February and I finally made it back. Now leave me alone. I get a moment to rest, don't I? That bottle of Irish whiskey I was given in Galway will help. OK, moment over. Next up: I get to go the the University of Northern Iowa…